Review pending

Proposition 11.11.10 · The missing hypothesis in the interval claim

Proposition 11.11.10. (The missing hypothesis in the interval claim). A continuous g:[0,1]→Rg:[0,1]\to\mathbf R with a touching affine lower support at every interior point is convex. If an affine ℓ\ell also touches gg from below on [0,ϵ)[0,\epsilon) at 00, then g≥ℓg\geq\ell on all of [0,1][0,1]. The contact condition at 00 alone does not imply this conclusion.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. On any interval [a,b]⊂[0,1][a,b]\subset[0,1], let HH be the affine interpolant of the endpoint values. If g−Hg-H had a positive maximum MM, its maximum set would be a nonempty compact subset of (a,b)(a,b). At a maximum point, subtracting HH from a touching affine support gives an affine function with an interior local maximum, hence a constant. As in Lemma 11.11.1, the maximum set is therefore open as well as closed in [a,b][a,b], a contradiction. Thus g≤Hg\leq H, which proves convexity. If g(t)<ℓ(t)g(t)<\ell(t) for some t>0t>0, convexity gives, for 0<s<min⁡(t,ϵ)0<s<\min(t,\epsilon), g(s)≤(1−s/t)g(0)+(s/t)g(t)<(1−s/t)ℓ(0)+(s/t)ℓ(t)=ℓ(s),g(s)\leq (1-s/t)g(0)+(s/t)g(t) <(1-s/t)\ell(0)+(s/t)\ell(t)=\ell(s), contradicting the lower support near 00. Without the interior hypothesis, g(t)=t−2t2g(t)=t-2t^2 and ℓ=0\ell=0 give a counterexample: g≥0g\geq 0 near 00, but g(1)=−1g(1)=-1. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900161.

Proof in chapter