All continuity and local-uniform approximation in this chapter use the ordinary Berkovich topology, not the path metric on a skeleton. Example 4.2.1 shows why these topologies cannot be interchanged. A neighborhood on which an approximating family is defined is fixed before taking its limit; restricting to an analytic domain is not a substitute for proving such a neighborhood exists.
11.1 Continuous potentials, smooth approximation, and curvature
Assume for this section that has no analytic boundary. A function is locally integrable in the current formalism if it is locally integrable against the measures represented by smooth top-degree test forms. There is no unspecified ambient Lebesgue measure on in this definition. For a continuous real function , the current is well-defined and has bidegree .
Definition 11.1.1. (The continuous psh condition in CLD 2012). A continuous real function is psh in the sense of [CLD12] (Definition 5.5.1) if is a positive current. It is locally smoothly psh-approximable if each point has a neighborhood on which is a uniform limit of original smooth psh functions.
The second condition is Definition 5.6.3 of the same source. It has an existential approximation requirement that does not occur in the first condition.
NAG-900102 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.1.2. (Stability under locally uniform limits). Let be continuous current-psh functions converging locally uniformly to a finite continuous function . Then is current-psh. In particular, local smooth psh approximation implies the continuous psh condition of Definition 11.1.1.
Proof. Let be a positive smooth test form of bidegree , and choose a compact neighborhood of its support. The smooth top-degree form represents a signed measure of finite total variation on . Hence Each is nonnegative, so its limit is nonnegative. Positivity is local and the test form was arbitrary. ◻
NAG-900103 Open proof obligation
Remark (What the 2012 construction does not establish). The converse to Proposition 11.1.2 is not proved in CLD 2012; [CLD12] (Remark 5.6.4) explicitly records this difficulty. Consequently, a theorem whose hypotheses require local smooth psh approximation cannot be invoked merely because a continuous function has positive -current.
The sentence following [CLD12] (Definition 5.5.1) also asserts functoriality for all continuous current-psh functions. Later work distinguishes current-psh from functorial psh and does not supply that general assertion as an automatic consequence of the current definition. It must therefore be cited with a separately verified hypothesis, rather than proved by an undefined pullback of currents. Smooth potentials and local uniform limits of smooth psh potentials are legitimate settings for the corresponding pullback argument; the smooth comparison is also covered by [GK19] (Corollary 8.9).
Example 11.1.4. (A corner contributes to the current). On an interval around , set . Both restrictions to and are affine, hence convex. Nevertheless, for a smooth compactly supported test function , Thus and is not psh. The identical calculation applies in a tropical coordinate on an annulus. The facewise Hessians vanish; the negative contribution lies at the corner.
For a tropical curve with three outgoing primitive directions , , , a continuous piecewise affine potential with outgoing slopes has vertex mass . Choosing gives the counterexample in [GK19] (Example 3.3) to the continuous version of [CLD12] (Lemma 5.5.3). The smooth restriction of that criterion is the one retained in [GK19] (Remark 3.2).
NAG-900104 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.1.5. (The mixed product constructed in CLD 2012). Let be locally smoothly psh-approximable continuous functions, where . There is a positive current of bidegree denoted by On an open subset where are smooth psh functions converging uniformly to , its value on a test form is The limit is independent of the approximating sequences and is compatible with restriction. If , it is a positive measure.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the native mixed-current assertion under its local uniform approximation hypothesis. CLD12 Corollary 5.6.5 is supplied here; the described internal route also has open multiplier convergence.
Definition 11.1.6. (Metric weights and curvature). Let be a line bundle with a finite continuous metric. For a local nonvanishing frame , write The metric is current-psh if its local weights satisfy Definition 11.1.1.
NAG-900105 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.1.7. (Frame independence and the Poincaré–Lelong sign). The local curvature currents in Definition 11.1.6 agree on overlaps. If is an algebraic variety and a nonzero meromorphic section of , then
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the scalar divisor/current identity with the stated sign and scope; CLD12 Theorem 4.6.5 or the cited Gubler alternative is the premise.
A local smooth approximation of each weight, a global smooth approximation of a metric on a fixed line bundle, and an approximation by relatively nef algebraic models are three different requirements. The first two are already separated in [CLD12] (§6.3.1); the third belongs to model positivity. The weak convergence of curvature currents proved in Proposition 11.1.2 does not identify these approximation categories. Likewise, adding a constant to every local weight leaves the curvature unchanged but changes the metric. Curvature comparison alone does not identify metrized line bundles.
11.2 The change of psh definition from 2012 to 2025
We work on a good Hausdorff boundaryless analytic space of pure dimension and use the original smooth-form sheaf. An original smooth function is called psh when the smooth -form is positive. The smooth-form/current comparison identifies this with positivity of in this regularity class; see [CLD25] (Corollary 7.3.10 and Theorem 12.11.1). The issue in this section is the passage to nonsmooth functions.
The classes that must remain separate
Definition 11.2.1. (Local approximation classes). For an open set , let be the continuous real functions such that every has an open neighbourhood on which is the locally uniform limit of a sequence of original smooth psh functions defined on that same . Let be the finite continuous functions which, locally on one fixed open neighbourhood, are decreasing limits of sequences of original smooth psh functions. Write for the continuous current-psh functions of Definition 11.1.1.
The neighbourhood in the definition is fixed for the whole approximating sequence. Neither definition is satisfied merely by finding, for every accuracy parameter, a function which is psh on a different shrinking neighbourhood of the point.
Definition 11.2.2. (The two generated sheaves in CLD25). The sheaf is the smallest subsheaf of functions with values in which contains the original smooth psh functions and is stable under decreasing limits of sequences on every open set. The sheaf is the smallest subsheaf of finite continuous functions which contains the same smooth functions and is stable under uniform limits. These are [CLD25] (Definitions 8.1.1 and 8.1.7).
The ordinal stages of the first construction are defined by with consisting of local decreasing limits of sequences from ; at a limit ordinal one takes the sheaf of functions which locally belong to an earlier stage. In particular, the first stage has an explicit local decreasing smooth approximation. The generated sheaf includes the later stages as well.
The word “smallest” refers to intersection among subsheaves satisfying the two defining properties. It is an exact definition and does not assert that every resulting section is a one-step limit of smooth functions. The transfinite description in [CLD25] (Lemma 8.1.4) makes this distinction visible.
NAG-900106 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.2.3. (The continuous first stage). As sheaves of finite continuous functions,
Proof. If on a fixed neighbourhood and are continuous, Dini’s theorem gives uniform convergence on every compact subset. This proves .
Conversely, fix a smaller open neighbourhood with compact closure inside a common approximation neighbourhood. Choose smooth psh functions such that Put . Addition of a constant preserves smooth psh. On , Hence on . This proves the reverse inclusion. The last equality is the definition of the first generated stage, with the continuous endpoint required explicitly. ◻
NAG-900107 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.2.4. (Implications obtained without identifying the higher stages). In the setting above one has More generally, a locally integrable section of has positive original current . None of the reverse inclusions for general analytic spaces is inferred here from the definitions.
Proof. The first inclusion follows by restricting to relatively compact neighbourhoods and applying the uniform-limit closure property of . The generated psh sheaf is a cone, is stable under addition of constants, and is local. A locally uniform limit of finite members can therefore be replaced, on a smaller relatively compact neighbourhood, by a decreasing subsequence after adding positive constants, exactly as in Proposition 11.2.3. Thus contains smooth psh functions and is stable under uniform limits; the minimality of proves the second inclusion.
For the last assertion, use transfinite induction on the decreasing-limit construction. Suppose , where is locally integrable and each belongs to an earlier stage. All generated functions are upper semicontinuous, so is bounded above on compact sets. The inequalities imply local integrability of ; Proposition 11.6.7 records this inheritance at every ordinal. If is a positive top-degree test form, monotone convergence applied after subtracting a local upper bound gives A general top-degree test is a difference of positive tests. Hence , and Positivity is preserved under this convergence because each positive test has a nonnegative value at every stage. Locality treats sheafification and limit ordinals. The smooth initial stage follows from integration of positive smooth forms. This supplies the usable argument for [CLD25] (Proposition 8.3.1(a)) without invoking Proposition 8.1.11 or the false weak-positive order-zero statement. ◻
Remark 11.2.5 (The equality printed in Proposition 8.1.11). CLD25 states the stronger equality and an equality at every ordinal stage. Its printed successor-stage argument starts with approximants in the continuous stage, whereas the decreasing-limit definition provides approximants in the possibly discontinuous stage. The missing replacement is discussed in Remark A.1.4. We use (11.2.2) and the proved first-stage equality (11.2.1); no argument in this book requires the stronger printed equality. This is a limitation of the available argument, not a counterexample to that equality. Sections 11.6.1–11.6.3 prove the compact-domain barrier theorem, the indexed forward inclusion and the locally integrable comparison, and isolate the additional domain requirement. A projective route, using Wu’s comparison and envelope inputs, is given in Section 11.7. Theorem 11.7.5 proves that bounded first-stage decreasing stability is sufficient for the full continuous-stage equality.
Remark 11.2.6 (Translation of the word approchable). In [CLD12] (Definition 5.6.3), “locally psh-approachable” is the positive approximation condition represented here by , whereas “locally approachable” denotes a difference of two such functions. In [CLD25] (Definition 8.1.13), a psh function is “locally approachable” when it belongs to . Thus the latter expression is on the positive side of the theory. For finite continuous endpoints, Proposition 11.2.3 compares the positive classes; it does not identify the old difference class with the new positive class.
Pulling back functions and pulling back currents
NAG-900108 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.2.7. (Pullback for generated and approximable psh functions). Let be an analytic morphism in the preceding category. Pullback of functions preserves and . In the generated class it preserves each ordinal stage.
Proof. Pullback of an original smooth function is original smooth, and pullback of its positive -form is positive. It commutes with composition and with pointwise decreasing limits. Transfinite induction, followed by locality, proves the assertion for , as in [CLD25] (Proposition 8.1.5). For , pull back the smooth approximants on the inverse image of a common neighbourhood. A compact subset of that inverse image has compact image, so local uniform convergence is preserved. ◻
The proof constructs and, whenever this function is locally integrable, its curvature current. Local integrability holds for continuous ; a singular psh pullback may instead be identically . The proof never defines a pullback of an arbitrary current. In particular, the notation does not by itself justify an operation on the whole current space. The general pullback assertion following [CLD12] (Definition 5.5.1) cannot be used as a proof of this operation or as a comparison with all current-psh functions; see Section A.1 and the functorial conditions in the delta-form section.
A complete comparison on real convex domains
NAG-900109 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.2.8. (Continuous distributional convexity). Let be open and convex, and let be continuous. The following are equivalent:
is convex;
is a positive supercurrent;
is locally a uniform limit of smooth convex functions;
is locally a decreasing limit of smooth convex functions.
Proof. Convolution on a slightly larger relatively compact domain preserves convexity and gives smooth functions converging uniformly on smaller compact sets. Thus (1) implies (3). The shift construction in Proposition 11.2.3 proves (3) implies (4), and local uniform convergence of the corresponding distributions gives (3) implies (2).
If (2) holds, convolve the distributional Hessian with a nonnegative smooth kernel. The resulting matrix is positive semidefinite, so each regularization is convex by Proposition 7.2.4. Continuity gives uniformly on compact subsets. Passing to the limit in the convexity inequality proves local convexity. Restricting to a line segment in then gives global convexity on the convex domain. Finally, (4) implies (3) by Dini’s theorem. ◻
Remark 11.2.9 (Why continuity cannot be omitted from a pointwise statement). On define and for . Then is locally integrable and even upper semicontinuous, and . Thus , but is not convex: The implication from the locally integrable current condition to pointwise convexity in [CLD25] (Proposition 8.3.2) is therefore false literally. A distribution determines an almost-everywhere class; a convex representative must be specified, or continuity must be assumed as in Proposition 11.2.8. Upper semicontinuity alone does not repair this example.
11.3 Positive distributional Hessians and convex representatives
A current defined by a locally integrable function only remembers its almost-everywhere class. To repair a pointwise convexity assertion, one must first construct the canonical representative of that class. The continuous comparison in Section 11.2 is a special case of the result below; the proof also explains precisely why changing one point can invalidate the unrepaired statement.
Let be a nonempty convex open set. For , say that its distributional Hessian is positive if This is equivalent to ordinary positivity of in the real superform convention. It is a condition on a distribution, so it is unchanged by modifications on Lebesgue-null sets.
NAG-900110 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.3.1. (An interior bound from an bound). Let be a smooth convex function on and put . With , one has The functions with a common bound are uniformly Lipschitz on , with a constant depending only on .
Proof. For , the average of points in is . Jensen’s inequality gives . For and , the point lies in ; convexity gives If there is nothing to prove. Otherwise the right side is negative throughout that ball, and integration of yields . Thus . For and a unit vector , the two points lie in after an arbitrarily small inward adjustment. The tangent-line inequality for a convex function bounds by . This gives a uniform gradient bound and the Lipschitz assertion. ◻
NAG-900111 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.3.2. (The convex representative theorem). A function has positive distributional Hessian if and only if its almost-everywhere class contains a finite convex function . Such a representative is unique. Every standard compactly supported nonnegative smooth approximate identity gives
Proof. Assume first that the Hessian is positive. On the inner domain where convolution is defined, is smooth and its Hessian is positive semidefinite: for each vector , its quadratic Hessian coefficient is the convolution of the nonnegative distribution with a nonnegative kernel. Thus is convex on every convex inner subdomain.
The convolutions converge to in on every relatively compact open subset. Their norms are therefore uniformly bounded there for sufficiently small . Cover a given compact subset by finitely many balls whose fourfold enlargements remain in . Lemma 11.3.1 gives uniform bounds and equicontinuity on the compact subset. Arzelà–Ascoli and a diagonal argument over an exhaustion give a subsequence converging locally uniformly to a finite continuous function . The convex inequality passes to the limit on each compact line segment, so is convex. Its limit is also , hence almost everywhere.
Two finite convex representatives are continuous. If they differed at one point, they would differ on a nonempty open set, which has positive Lebesgue measure. Hence they coincide. This uniqueness and the same local compactness argument show convergence of the whole family , not just the selected subsequence: any sequence violating uniform convergence on a compact set would have a locally uniformly convergent subsequence with the same unique limit.
Conversely, if almost everywhere for a finite convex , its convolutions are smooth convex functions and converge locally uniformly to . Their positive Hessian distributions converge to the Hessian distribution of . Positivity is closed under convergence on tests, proving the converse. ◻
Which pointwise representative is admissible
NAG-900112 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.3.3. The representative in Theorem 11.3.2 is characterized by If the chosen pointwise function is strongly upper semicontinuous, in the sense that for every Lebesgue-null set , then everywhere. Ordinary upper semicontinuity alone does not suffice.
Proof. The integral and essential supremum are unchanged by replacing with . Continuity of makes both limits equal to . For the last assertion take , which is null. Its complement is dense in every open ball. Strong upper semicontinuity and continuity of therefore give . To see the failure for ordinary upper semicontinuity, put and elsewhere on a ball containing zero. This function is upper semicontinuous and defines the zero distribution, but is not convex. ◻
This gives two precise replacements for the pointwise claim in CLD25 Proposition 8.3.2: either work with a continuous function from the outset, or work with an class and its unique convex representative. Strong upper semicontinuity selects that representative. The approximation converges uniformly to the representative, not to an arbitrarily modified pointwise version.
11.4 The Hessian kernel and potential independence on a real domain
NAG-900113 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.4.1. If a distribution on a connected open subset of satisfies for all , then is the distribution of an affine function. Consequently two finite convex functions on a convex open set with the same Hessian current differ by an affine function.
Proof. On any ball compactly contained in the domain, small convolutions have zero Hessian, hence are affine on a smaller concentric ball. The finite-dimensional space of affine distributions on that smaller ball is closed in the distribution topology. To see this directly, choose test functions whose integrals against form an invertible matrix; convergence on these tests forces convergence of all affine coefficients. Since as distributions, is affine on the smaller ball. On overlapping balls the affine polynomials agree as distributions and hence as functions on an open set, so their coefficients agree. Connectedness glues them to one affine function. Apply this to the difference of the two functions and then use their continuity. ◻
NAG-900114 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.4.2. Let be an ordinary positive current closed under both differentials on a convex real domain. If finite convex functions have , then
Proof. Both functions are continuous, so multiplication is defined by the order-zero theorem. Their difference is affine by Proposition 11.4.1. The smooth Leibniz formula and closedness give . Subtracting the two products proves the result. ◻
On a singular tropical support, the kernel of the current Hessian can be larger than the affine functions inherited from the ambient space. The cross example in Chapter 14 exploits exactly that enlargement. Thus the Euclidean argument proves potential independence on its own domain and simultaneously identifies the step that cannot simply be carried over to an arbitrary quotient of charts.
References. This section supplies the representative-sensitive repair of [CLD25] (Proposition 8.3.2). The distinction between strong upper semicontinuity and a mere distributional class is also used in [BGJK25] (Section 3.1).
11.5 A convex potential for a positive closed real current
On a convex real domain, every positive closed supercurrent has a convex potential. The assertion concerns an ambient Euclidean domain. It is a useful comparison theorem for the local analytic problem, but its proof uses linear coordinates and cannot be transferred to a singular tropical quotient without checking those operations. We include the distributional step so that regularizing the current does not conceal a missing convergence argument for its potentials.
NAG-900115 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.5.1. (Positive Laplacian gives local integrability). Let be a distribution on an open subset of . If is a positive distribution, then is represented by a locally integrable function.
Proof. A positive distribution is a positive Radon measure; write . Choose a compactly supported smooth cutoff equal to one on a smaller open set. A fundamental solution for is Each kernel is locally integrable. The convolution is locally integrable by Fubini: on a compact set, the integral of in is uniformly bounded for in the compact support of . In distributions, . Thus is a harmonic distribution on the smaller open set.
For completeness, a harmonic distribution is smooth. Its small convolutions are smooth harmonic functions. Fix a smooth radial averaging kernel supported in a ball small enough for the harmonic mean-value identity. Every such convolution equals its convolution with this fixed kernel on a smaller ball. Passing to distributions shows that the original distribution equals its convolution with the fixed kernel there, which is smooth. This is the distributional Weyl lemma. Consequently is locally integrable. ◻
NAG-900116 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.5.2. A distribution whose Hessian is positive semidefinite in the distributional sense is represented by a unique finite convex function on a convex domain.
Proof. Its Laplacian is a sum of positive distributions, hence positive. Lemma 11.5.1 gives a locally integrable representative, and Theorem 11.3.2 gives the unique finite convex representative. ◻
NAG-900117 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.5.3. (The real potential theorem). Let be convex and open. A symmetric ordinary positive supercurrent with has a finite convex potential satisfying . The potential is unique up to addition of an affine function.
Proof. Write . Symmetry gives , and closedness gives The trace is a positive Radon measure. Commuting distributional derivatives and using symmetry gives
First work on a relatively compact convex subdomain . Choose near its closure and form . The preceding lemma’s argument makes locally integrable. On , the distributions are harmonic, hence smooth. They remain symmetric and satisfy . Translate an interior base point of to zero and define Differentiating and using the closed-column identity gives Symmetry now says that the smooth one-form is closed. A second radial integration, gives and . Hence the locally integrable function has Hessian on . Positivity and Theorem 11.3.2 replace it by a finite convex representative .
Exhaust by nested relatively compact convex open subdomains . Such an exhaustion is obtained by intersecting large balls with inner parallel convex domains. On , the difference has zero Hessian, hence is affine by Proposition 11.4.1. Subtract this affine function from and proceed inductively. Affine subtraction preserves convexity, and the adjusted potentials agree on overlaps. They glue to the required finite convex function on . The same Hessian-kernel proposition gives uniqueness modulo affine functions. ◻
This proof makes two uses of the ambient real structure explicit. Coordinate derivatives commute as distributions, allowing the Laplacian calculation; and straight segments remain in the convex domain, allowing the two radial integrations. The equation on a tropical support is an equality modulo tangential relations. It need not furnish an ambient matrix satisfying these unrestricted coordinate identities. This is the precise obstruction to treating the real potential theorem as a local-potential theorem on every Berkovich chart.
NAG-900118 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.5.4. For a positive closed current on all of , every connected component of the complement of its support is convex.
Proof. Let be its global convex potential and let be such a component. The potential agrees there with one affine function . At any point of , that affine function is a supporting plane for , so globally. The zero set of the convex nonnegative function is convex. It contains , hence its convex hull. Since is open, its convex hull is open as well; is affine on that open hull, so the current vanishes there. Connectedness and maximality of the component then imply . ◻
References. The potential theorem and the support-complement consequence occur in [Lag12] (Propositions 1.13–1.14). The proof here supplies the distributional integrability and gluing steps explicitly, using the representative theorem of Section 11.3.
11.6 Which approximation statement is available
The first-stage theorem and the generated-sheaf comparison serve different purposes. The former constructs a single smooth sequence on a fixed neighbourhood and is the input for Theorem 13.6.3. The latter allows repeated local limiting operations. A section obtained after several such operations must not be used as a first-stage section without an additional argument.
NAG-900119 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.6.1. (The upper-semicontinuous form of Dini’s argument). Let be compact, let be finite upper semicontinuous functions decreasing to a continuous finite function . Then uniformly on .
Proof. For , the sets are open, increase with , and cover . Compactness gives for some . Thus on for all . ◻
This observation locates the difficulty in CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11 more precisely. The obstacle is not the uniformity of a decreasing limit with continuous endpoint: upper semicontinuity already suffices for that. It is the replacement of the possibly discontinuous predecessors in by members of . Uniform convergence of discontinuous predecessors does not make those predecessors continuous. Proposition 11.2.3 avoids this issue because its predecessors are smooth.
| Assertion | Usable justification |
|---|---|
| Proposition 11.2.3, with fixed local approximation domain. | |
| Proposition 11.2.4; no reverse inclusion is used. | |
| Stronger source assertion; the predecessor replacement remains unproved here. | |
| Theorem 13.6.3 for and the stated ordinary positive closed . |
The kernel question is independent of this existence statement. The cross calculation in Proposition 14.2.2 refutes its unrestricted abstract version. A positive result on an analytic space must specify the harmonic kernel, the test quotient and the permitted background currents.
References. CLD25 Definitions 8.1.1, 8.1.7 and Proposition 8.1.11; the compactness argument above is elementary.
A continuous upper barrier on a fixed compact set
To understand the missing step in Proposition 8.1.11, we first remove one difficulty from the problem. Repeated decreasing limits on a fixed compact set can be handled without making every predecessor continuous. A continuous upper barrier allows us to select one predecessor at a time. The distinction between this construction and a sheaf construction will then be explicit.
Definition 11.6.2. (The decreasing hierarchy on a fixed compact set). Let be a compact Hausdorff space and let be nonempty. Define classes of actual functions by Write for the class obtained after stabilization. All functions at all stages have domain . There is no sheafification or passage to a smaller domain in this definition.
The classes increase because constant sequences are allowed. They stabilize since they are subsets of the fixed set of all functions on . Every member is upper semicontinuous: this is preserved by a decreasing limit and is unchanged by taking a union of classes. These observations alone do not give first-stage stabilization for discontinuous functions. Corollary 11.24.6 below proves it by a separate compact diagonal argument.
NAG-900120 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.6.3. (Selection below a continuous barrier). If and satisfy everywhere on , then there is such that
Proof. We prove the assertion by induction on the stage containing . At stage zero, take . At a successor stage, write with all in the preceding stage. The sets are open, increase with , and cover . Openness uses upper semicontinuity of , and the covering property uses . By compactness, for some . Apply the induction hypothesis to and the same barrier . It gives . At a limit ordinal, already belongs to one earlier stage by definition, so the induction hypothesis applies directly. ◻
Only one predecessor is retained at each successor step. The selected predecessor may be discontinuous; its upper semicontinuity is enough for the next selection. All selections use the same compact set and the same barrier. This is the point that a direct appeal to continuity of the predecessors would miss.
NAG-900121 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.6.4. (Continuous endpoints of the compact hierarchy). Suppose is stable under addition of real constants. Then Consequently, the continuous parts of agree for every .
Proof. Let be a finite continuous member of . Apply Lemma 11.6.3 with . For every it gives with on all of . Thus is in the uniform closure of .
Conversely, let be in that uniform closure. Choose with , where , and set . Then and Hence uniformly on , so . The remaining inclusion follows from . The assertion for every positive ordinal follows by inserting into (11.6.2). ◻
This is an elementary statement about monotone closure on a fixed compact domain. It does not use positivity, tropical charts or a regularization theorem. Its application to the generated psh sheaf requires an additional representation property, stated next.
The remaining domain requirement
NAG-900122 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.6.5. (A compact representation gives first-stage approximation). Let be a compact neighbourhood of in a Hausdorff locally compact analytic space . Let consist of the restrictions to of original smooth psh functions defined on open neighbourhoods of . These neighbourhoods may depend on the function. Let be finite and continuous near . If then has a decreasing original smooth psh approximation on the single open neighbourhood of , uniformly on compact subsets there. In particular, is locally in near .
Proof. Theorem 11.6.4 gives a decreasing sequence converging uniformly to . Choose smooth psh representatives near . Every representative is defined on , even though their larger neighbourhoods may differ. Their restrictions to this fixed interior therefore give the required sequence. The inequalities and the uniform bounds on remain valid there. ◻
Condition (11.6.3) is the substantive hypothesis. Membership in allows local representations at every successor stage and sheafification at limit stages. Restricting one section to does not by itself give a representation in : the lower-stage sections may only have representations on a cover of , and their smooth predecessors need not extend across that cover. The compact hierarchy has no such local operation.
In particular, approximation on a neighbourhood depending on the error is insufficient. On the real tropical line, the function is not psh on any interval, since . Nevertheless, for every , the smooth psh constant zero satisfies Indeed, every continuous function admits such shrinking-domain constant approximations at a point. Thus this condition carries no psh information. In Corollary 11.6.5, the compact neighbourhood is fixed before the error tends to zero.
The conclusion of the corollary is stronger than the unindexed equality asserted in CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11: it gives first-stage approximation. Consequently, constructing compact representations for every continuous generated psh function would settle more than that equality. Failure to construct them does not refute the weaker equality. For that weaker target, continuous replacements already in on one fixed domain would suffice; their ordinal need not match the ordinal of the original predecessor. The same-ordinal assertion in the source imposes this further constraint.
What survives at every ordinal
We record the valid direction of the continuous comparison with its ordinal intact. Define , let be the sheaf of local uniform limits of sections of , and at a limit ordinal take the sheaf of functions locally in an earlier continuous stage. All its sections are finite and continuous.
NAG-900123 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.6.6. (The indexed inclusion). For every ordinal , Equality holds for . No reverse inclusion at later stages is asserted here.
Proof. First, addition of a constant preserves every : prove this by induction, using the assertion for smooth psh functions, compatibility of translation with uniform limits, and locality at limit ordinals. Now argue by induction for the displayed inclusion. The zero stage is immediate. At a successor stage, work on an open set where converges uniformly to . After passing to a subsequence, assume . The functions remain in and decrease to , by the estimate in Proposition 11.2.3. By induction they lie in ; hence . If the convergence is only locally uniform, first restrict to a relatively compact open neighbourhood. Sheafification and limit ordinals are treated by restriction to the corresponding local representations. Equality at stage one is Proposition 11.2.3. ◻
Local integrability behaves differently under the order relation defining a decreasing limit. If is locally integrable, is upper semicontinuous, and , then on a compact set where one has Thus is integrable for each locally finite measure used in the definition. In CLD25 paragraph 5.7.2 this can be checked on skeletal cells with their Lebesgue measures, or against the specified locally bounded volume forms. It does not mean integrability against every arbitrary background current.
NAG-900124 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.6.7. (The locally integrable hierarchy). Let be the hierarchy obtained from the original smooth psh functions by the same local decreasing-limit and limit-ordinal operations as , but retaining only locally integrable functions and requiring locally integrable endpoints. Then, for every ordinal , These are classes of actual functions; the order and limits are pointwise, not operations on equivalence classes modulo null sets. Moreover, if are generated psh functions and is locally integrable, then every is locally integrable and in local for each of the measures in that definition.
Proof. This is the argument of CLD25 Proposition 8.1.12, with the inherited integrability made explicit. The inclusion from left to right in (11.6.5) follows from the construction. For the reverse inclusion, use induction on . At a successor stage, write a locally integrable locally as with . The functions are upper semicontinuous and bounded above on compact sets. Since , estimate (11.6.4) shows that each is locally integrable. The induction hypothesis puts them in , so their locally integrable endpoint belongs to . The zero and limit stages follow directly from the definitions and locality.
For the convergence assertion, work on a compact set for one of the defining measures. The nonnegative integrable function dominates , which decreases to zero almost everywhere. Dominated convergence gives Apply this on the local cells or to each required volume measure. Thus the currents converge to against the original smooth tests wherever these currents are defined, as used in Proposition 11.2.4. No continuous predecessor replacement is needed. ◻
Remark 11.6.8 (Consequences for the approximation audit). The compact barrier theorem resolves the transfinite selection problem when one common compact representation is supplied. It does not prove that sheaf-generated sections admit such a representation. The indexed inclusion and the locally integrable equality above are valid without that representation. Consequently, the gap identified in Proposition 8.1.11 does not invalidate Proposition 8.1.12 or the locally integrable current-positivity argument. Neither local convergence nor membership in a generated class alone defines products of unbounded potentials with arbitrary currents. Such products require their own integrability and continuity statements.
References. CLD25 v2, paragraph 5.7.2, Definitions 8.1.1 and 8.1.7, Lemmas 8.1.4, 8.1.8 and 8.1.10, Propositions 8.1.11–8.1.12. The compact hierarchy and its barrier proof are elementary deductions stated separately from the source’s sheaf hierarchy. The indexed forward inclusion and the equality expand valid portions of the source argument; no counterexample to its continuous equality is asserted.
11.7 Envelope methods and bounded localization
The compact argument of Section 11.6.1 leaves a geometric question: how can approximants on different local domains be compared on one neighbourhood? A projective ambient space provides another route. One first extends bounded local potentials to a common global background, uses an envelope comparison there, and then restricts back. This section gives the order estimates needed for that route and identifies the additional theorems it uses.
Three classes in the recent local theory
We fix the preprint [Wu26], arXiv version 1 of 23 September 2026. Its local theory is formulated on opens in algebraic analytifications over a complete discretely or trivially valued field. Write for its class of decreasing limits of tropically convex PL functions, and for its smooth-approximable class. These are first-stage local approximation conditions. They must be distinguished from the sheaf obtained by iterating decreasing limits and localization.
For the comparisons below we use locally bounded functions. They are finite, so the exclusion of functions identically on a component causes no ambiguity. The smooth generators are the original CLD generators; replacing them by weakly smooth or harmonic-chart generators would change the comparison.
| Class | Local requirement | Relevant source |
|---|---|---|
| One decreasing PL sequence on one open neighbourhood | [Wu26], Definition 3.8 | |
| One decreasing original smooth convex sequence | [Wu26], Definition A.1 | |
| The generated sheaf, including further decreasing limits | [CLD25], Definition 8.1.1 |
Theorem A.3 of [Wu26] asserts . Corollary 4.18(1) supplies decreasing-limit stability of when the projective ambient variety has the envelope property. Remark A.2 explicitly retains this hypothesis in the comparison with the generated CLD definition. These are substantial source inputs, not consequences of the terminology “psh”. Their implication for continuous generated functions is proved in Section 11.7.4.
In the convex terminology here, the supporting affine function touches the function at the point. Example A.8.1 records a defect in the source’s displayed definition and its repair. For the explicit rational-generator class of Section 11.9.1, Theorem 11.9.5 supplies one direction of approximation independently of Theorem A.3, over a nontrivially valued field.
Continuous obstacles on a compact space
An envelope argument needs continuous majorants of a local potential. Compactness alone does not make every upper semicontinuous function a decreasing limit of a sequence of continuous functions on an arbitrary Hausdorff space. The local approximation hypothesis supplies precisely the missing information here.
NAG-900125 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.7.1. (Continuous majorants from local sequences). Let be compact Hausdorff and let . Suppose every point has an open neighbourhood on which is a decreasing limit of finite continuous functions. Then there are with pointwise on . No metrizability assumption is needed.
Proof. Choose a finite open cover with continuous sequences . By normality of a compact Hausdorff space, choose a continuous partition of unity with . Extend by zero outside and put Each summand is continuous: its support stays inside its defining open set. Nonnegative coefficients give . At every point only finitely many terms occur, and their limit is . ◻
The functions are continuous obstacles; the proof does not assert that they are psh. Applying a partition of unity directly to psh potentials would introduce uncontrolled derivatives of the coefficients. Positivity is recovered by an envelope, under the following explicit hypotheses.
NAG-900126 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.7.2. (The bounded envelope comparison). Fix a projective ambient space and an ample semipositive model background . Let and be respectively its global and local classes of bounded -psh potentials, with . Assume the following inputs:
Every is locally a decreasing limit of continuous functions.
For , the envelope is a continuous member of , satisfies , and its Monge–Ampère measure is supported on .
Domination holds: for and , the inequality almost everywhere for implies everywhere.
is closed under decreasing limits with bounded endpoints.
Then .
Proof. Take . Lemma 11.7.1 gives with continuous. Put . The definition of an envelope is order preserving, so . On the support of one has . Domination gives on the whole space. Thus The endpoint is bounded, so the last hypothesis gives . ◻
This is the bounded part of the mechanism in [Wu26], Theorem 4.17. Envelope continuity, orthogonality, and domination remain imported inputs; none follows from Lemma 11.7.1. The lemma makes the continuous-obstacle construction independent of a countable dense subfield. It does not remove countability hypotheses from other theorems in that paper.
An order-preserving extension on a fixed neighbourhood
The next construction explains why the global comparison is relevant to a local decreasing sequence. The extensions must preserve order; choosing an unrelated global extension for every term would not suffice. We use a local potential class closed under finite maxima, positive scaling and addition of constants. Model backgrounds in this subsection are curvature classes of metrics, not automatically original smooth CLD forms.
NAG-900127 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.7.3. (A fixed bounded extension formula). Let be projective. Let be semipositive model backgrounds on the same -line bundle, admitting local psh potentials in the chosen class, and choose a global continuous PL function with . On an open let be a continuous psh potential of . Assume where is an open set on which the local potentials will be given. Fix and a positive rational number with , and set . For any psh on with on , define Then is a bounded local -psh potential. On the same open neighbourhood of , for all such , The map preserves order and decreasing pointwise limits within this bounded family. Moreover,
Proof. On one has . On the compact collar one has . Consequently vanishes on a neighbourhood of the boundary of , and the piecewise formula is well defined without a boundary jump. On , is psh. Outside a smaller compact sublevel set, . Since is semipositive with admitted local potentials, these statements show that is locally -psh. After scaling and changing the background, in the local-potential sense. Boundedness follows from the bounds on , continuity of on , and continuity of on the compact space. On the maximum selects , which proves (11.7.2). Finally, the scalar map is increasing, continuous, and -Lipschitz. This proves the order, limit, and norm assertions using the same throughout. ◻
NAG-900128 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.7.4. (One collar for a whole decreasing tail). In the preceding setting, suppose are finite upper semicontinuous functions on with and on . Then, for all sufficiently large , on the fixed collar . If the are continuous, their extensions by (11.7.1) are continuous for this entire tail. On the identity (11.7.2) holds for every .
Proof. The open sets increase and cover the compact set , since . One index therefore works on all of , and every later index works as well. There . On , the inequalities give the claimed identity. ◻
These formulas reconstruct the bounded localization mechanism of [Wu26], Proposition 3.28, while recording the background change and the common collar. The existence of the projective barrier data is a separate geometric input, constructed for integral projective varieties in Theorem 11.8.9. In a weighted Fubini–Study presentation its local shape can be Here the are normalized logarithmic section ratios with their weights, and the outer sublevel set must be chosen compactly inside . The negative constant branch is essential. A formula is nonnegative and cannot satisfy . Also, equality of underlying line bundles does not identify their model backgrounds; the term in (11.7.1) performs the required conversion.
What bounded decreasing stability would settle
We now isolate a sufficient input that is weaker than constructing the raw compact representation of Corollary 11.6.5. Let denote the original first-stage sheaf, allowing discontinuous functions.
NAG-900129 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.7.5. (Bounded stability implies collapse of continuous stages). Assume that on every open set a decreasing sequence of locally bounded sections of , whose endpoint is locally bounded, again has its endpoint in . Then For every ordinal , one moreover has All boundedness conditions here concern actual pointwise functions.
Proof. We prove by induction on that each locally bounded section of belongs to . This holds at stage zero. At a successor stage, work on an open set where , with and locally bounded. Since and is upper semicontinuous with no value , every is locally bounded. The induction hypothesis puts every predecessor in . The assumed bounded decreasing stability now applies on this open set. At a limit ordinal use the local earlier-stage representations and the sheaf property of . This proves (11.7.5).
A finite continuous is locally bounded, hence belongs to . Dini’s argument on a smaller relatively compact neighbourhood turns its decreasing smooth approximation into local uniform approximation. Thus . Conversely, by Proposition 11.2.3, and the continuous hierarchy is increasing. Combine these inclusions with Proposition 11.6.6 to obtain (11.7.6). ◻
The hypothesis is a genuine stability statement on a common open set. It does not follow merely by choosing a separate regularization neighbourhood for each predecessor. Once it is known, no additional ordinal estimate is needed for continuous functions: all positive stages already coincide. This strengthens the earlier repair plan, which treated ordinal control as a further possible task.
The projective scope and its source dependencies
NAG-900130 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.7.6. (Application of the envelope comparison inputs). Let be complete and discretely or trivially valued, let be projective over , and suppose has the envelope property over in the sense of [Wu26]. Import Theorem A.3 and Corollary 4.18(1) of that source, with its comparison of analytic and algebraic smooth generators. Then on opens of , the conclusions (11.7.5) and (11.7.6) hold.
Proof. For locally bounded functions, Theorem A.3 identifies with . A locally bounded decreasing endpoint is generically finite, so Corollary 4.18(1) gives the bounded stability assumed in Theorem 11.7.5. Apply that theorem. ◻
Wu’s Theorem 7.1 supplies the envelope property for projective geometrically unibranch varieties over discretely or trivially valued fields of equicharacteristic zero; normal projective varieties are included. Accordingly, this is a source-dependent route to the continuous-stage comparison in that category. The paper’s Fornæss–Narasimhan step, Theorem 6.5, includes a countable-dense-subfield hypothesis; the proof of Theorem 7.1 contains a further descent argument to remove it. Neither hypothesis nor descent step should be suppressed when reconstructing that proof.
Remark 11.7.7 (What has been proved here and what is imported). The continuous-majorant lemma, the fixed extension estimates, and the transfinite bounded-stability implication have complete proofs above. The projective corollary uses the indicated preprint theorems. It is not an independent reconstruction of the full proof of Theorem A.3, the domination principle, or the envelope theorem. In particular, Appendix A of [Wu26] invokes two Amini–Piquerez–Wu preprints and passes from approximation of generators to approximation classes. Section 11.8 matches the localization and PL-approximation locators, corrects a false whole-domain inequality, and proves fixed-domain estimates. The general generator-to-class passage and the separate mixed-calculus input remain to be verified.
The general analytic question from Proposition 8.1.11 remains separate. The cited envelope theorem does not cover arbitrary complete fields or arbitrary Berkovich spaces; in particular, its equicharacteristic-zero statement is not a theorem for every finite extension of . Nor does a comparison of functions establish an arbitrary-background-current Bedford–Taylor calculus. The next task is to verify the source comparison chain in the projective category, while retaining bounded first-stage stability as the precise remaining input outside it.
References. Wu, arXiv:2609.27610v1, Definitions 3.8 and A.1, Proposition 3.28, Theorem 4.17, Corollary 4.18, Theorems 6.5 and 7.1, Remark A.2 and Theorem A.3. The present bounded extension is a corrected reconstruction of the localization mechanism; the continuous-majorant and transfinite arguments are elementary deductions. The external comparison theorems remain attributed inputs.
11.8 Common domains in local approximation
A comparison of generators becomes a comparison of first-stage classes only when the approximations can be made on one neighbourhood. We first give the required diagonal argument. We then reconstruct two localization procedures that produce such neighbourhoods: one on a tropical compactification and one on a projective analytic space. The tropical argument also identifies an incorrect extra inequality in the printed source. The local conclusion survives after a precise restriction of its domain.
A diagonal sequence on a prescribed domain
NAG-900131 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.8.1. Let be a fixed set, let decrease pointwise to , and let be a class stable under addition of rational constants. Suppose that, for every , there is with Then belongs to and decreases pointwise to on this same .
Proof. The errors give The first pair of inequalities gives the pointwise limit, including at points where . No boundedness of and no continuity of the endpoint are required. ◻
NAG-900132 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.8.2. (A sufficient criterion for transferring first-stage classes). Let and be classes of finite continuous functions on ordinary open sets of a locally compact Hausdorff space, stable under restriction, and suppose is stable under addition of rational constants. Assume that whenever are open and , then for every there exists with . Every function locally given by a decreasing sequence of -functions is then locally given by a decreasing sequence of -functions. Any separate endpoint condition, such as generic finiteness, is unchanged.
Proof. At a point , choose a representation on one open . Choose once. The hypothesis gives an approximation to with error at most for every , without changing . Lemma 11.8.1 applies. ◻
The hypothesis is stronger than approximation near each point of each individual generator. From statements with domains depending on , one cannot simply form and call it a neighbourhood. For example, the neighbourhoods of zero have intersection . This logical distinction identifies a missing justification; it is not by itself a counterexample to equality of the two function classes.
NAG-900133 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.8.3. (Decreasing finite logarithmic maxima). Let be an ordinary open set of a good analytic space in the original CLD category. Suppose decreases pointwise on and each term has a finite presentation where are analytic on all of and are real constants. There is one decreasing sequence of original smooth psh functions on with the same pointwise limit. Different terms may use different analytic functions; these functions may have zeros.
Proof. For each , regularize its finite maximum by the compactly supported regularized maximum used in Theorem 20.8.1. The constant branch makes finite and continuous. At a zero of one of the , its logarithmic branch tends to and is strictly below the constant branch on a neighbourhood. Exact deletion of inactive coordinates makes the regularization smooth there. At other points the surviving functions are analytic units, and convexity of the regularized maximum gives a positive Hessian in a moment chart. The local formulas agree by exact deletion. Thus they define a smooth psh function on all of , with a uniform error bounded by the regularization parameter. Choose that parameter at most and apply Lemma 11.8.1. ◻
This is a common-domain result for the displayed presentations. It does not assert that an arbitrary locally tropically convex PL function has one such presentation on an arbitrarily prescribed open set. Log-sum-exp alone would not justify smoothness at zeros; the exact-deletion property is the reason for using this regularization. The unit-only formula in Theorem 19.18.15 has no such zero issue.
The local affine support calculation
NAG-900134 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.8.4. Let be a locally finite polyhedral complex in a finite-dimensional real vector space , let , and let be an open neighbourhood of . There is , depending only on , such that every cell meeting contains and . If is convex on for every cell , then In particular, the same radius works for any family satisfying these hypotheses for the same complex and open set.
Proof. Local finiteness gives a neighbourhood meeting only finitely many cells. Each of those not containing is closed and has positive distance from . A sufficiently small ball avoids all of them and lies in . If is in the remaining ball and in a cell , then and their segment lies in . Apply the supporting-line inequality to the convex function on . Its right derivative at zero is . ◻
The affine expression must be centred at . Interpreting as a linear functional on , the expression generally fails to take the value at . Also, the cells here contain the tropical point , not the analytic point . These observations correct the notation in the supporting-affine-function step of Wu’s Appendix A. They prove local support for a fixed polyhedral presentation, not ambient convexity on all of .
A false global inequality and the local replacement
We fix [APW26], arXiv:2610.25602v1. Its Proposition 5.19 contains both a local extension assertion and the additional inequality on the whole original open set . Only the latter is contradicted by the following example.
Example 11.8.5. (Failure of majorization on all of ). For every , take the projective tropical toric variety , with dense stratum and product fan. Set The function satisfies the positivity and conewise-linearity assumptions in that proposition, and is smooth and strictly convex on . Nevertheless, for , there are no and satisfying throughout .
Proof. The function is convex, homogeneous, linear on each orthant, and positive away from zero. The Hessian of is diagonal with entries , hence positive definite. By Definition 4.3 of the source, every member of is bounded. Since on , the left-hand side of the proposed inequality is bounded above there. The right-hand side tends to along as . This is impossible for . ◻
The printed proof first bounds on an inner compact neighbourhood but then uses that bound to control the set where a global barrier lies below on all of . The example shows why that enlargement of the domain is invalid. The construction can instead be carried out on the inner neighbourhood alone. The following formulation makes the domain and all constants uniform for a bounded family.
NAG-900135 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.8.6. (Uniform tropical localization on an inner domain). Use the projective tropical toric setting and the bounded-growth correspondence of [APW26] (Example 4.9). Write , let be convex homogeneous PL with away from zero, put , and let . Fix , an open , and such that Fix . There are one neighbourhood of in and one such that every with on admits satisfying The assignment preserves order and is -Lipschitz for the uniform norms on and . If is PL, the extension is PL in the source’s category. No inequality is asserted on .
Proof. Continuity on the unit sphere gives with . Choose with and put On a fixed inner collar of , the inequality holds, so the two formulas agree on a neighbourhood of that boundary. Thus is continuous and locally convex on : use the maximum of locally convex functions inside, and outside. On the fixed neighbourhood one has , so . Set on . Outside this is . A finite convex homogeneous PL function is globally Lipschitz, hence . On boundedness follows from the hypotheses. Example 4.9 of the source therefore gives the bounded -psh extension to . In the PL case, the translated background extends as a PL potential difference as in the proof of its Proposition 5.19; the modification has compact support in and is locally a maximum of PL functions. This preserves PL.
The two identities follow directly from the maximum. On , this maximum is increasing and -Lipschitz as a function of ; outside the extension is independent of . The norm bound follows on , hence on by continuity and density. These observations prove order preservation as well. If a decreasing family stays within the stated bounded class, the same formulas also commute with its pointwise limit. ◻
This proves the uniformity needed to localize a sequence already uniformly bounded on a prescribed compact tropical domain. Combined with the source’s uniform PL density theorem, it repairs the localization input in Proposition 5.21. That proof uses the local identity, not majorization on all of . The correction consequently does not refute its local PL approximation conclusion. Neither the tropical extension nor uniform PL density, however, supplies the analytic pullback comparison invoked separately in Wu’s Appendix A.
Projective Fubini–Study barriers
We now supply the geometric data assumed in Proposition 11.7.3, first as an explicit construction of weighted metrics. Let be any complete non-Archimedean field, let be an integral projective -variety, and let be ample. A -line bundle is handled by first taking an actual tensor power. All topological neighbourhoods below are ordinary neighbourhoods in .
NAG-900136 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.8.7. (An affine compact buffer). For with open, there are , a nonzero , the affine open containing , finitely many , and rational constants , such that
Proof. A globally generated power of has a section nonvanishing at ; its principal open is affine. The topology of its analytification is generated by absolute values of regular functions, as in Section 2.10. Thus a finite intersection of strict inequalities and contains and is contained in . On the lower inequalities become upper inequalities for . This is again a principal affine open of the required type: clear the denominators of the finite product of the using a power of , then multiply its extending section by to ensure nonvanishing only inside . The resulting nonzero section of a power of defines exactly .
Replace each strict upper bound by a closed bound strictly between the value at and that upper bound. These bounds may be chosen in , which is dense in . Add bounds, again strict at , for a finite set of algebra generators of . Those latter bounds cut out the intersection of a closed polydisc with a closed affine embedding of , hence a compact affinoid domain; arbitrary positive radii are allowed. Intersecting with the other closed inequalities gives a compact subset of it. All original strict inequalities hold on , so . Their strictness at supplies its ordinary interior neighbourhood. This argument applies also to a trivially valued field and to non-strict affinoid radii. ◻
NAG-900137 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.8.8. (One denominator for finitely many functions). Let be a nonzero section of on an integral projective variety, and let be regular on . For every sufficiently large , each extends to a section of on .
Proof. Cover by finitely many affine opens trivializing . On such an open , the section is a nonzero element , and . Clearing the finitely many denominators gives a common exponent for every and every open in the cover. The resulting local sections agree on the dense open and hence on overlaps, since is integral. They glue. A larger exponent is obtained by multiplication by a further power of . This also justifies the denominator-clearing step in Lemma 11.8.7. ◻
NAG-900138 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.8.9. (A negative Fubini–Study barrier). In the projective setting above, given there exist a rational-weighted finite Fubini–Study metric on , an affine open containing , and a continuous local weight for on such that, for some , The weight is locally tropically convex and is locally uniformly approximable by original smooth psh functions. These assertions concern a metric and its local weights. Identifying its curvature with a model background in a narrower source category requires that category’s Fubini–Study/model comparison.
Proof. Take from Lemma 11.8.7. By Lemma 11.8.8, choose one such that all extend to sections of and that line bundle is globally generated. Choose a finite globally generating list of its sections. Every is regular on . Choose rational so negative that , with . Choose also a rational constant . On put This is the weight, relative to the nonvanishing section of , of the metric The last group of sections has no common zero, so this formula defines a continuous metric globally. Every branch of (11.8.5) is strictly negative at , and the maximum is finite because of . Hence and is continuous. Choose ; a neighbourhood of then lies in . Moreover, implies all inequalities defining , so . The set is closed in and therefore closed in the compact set . This proves the required compact containment.
Locally, branches vanishing at a point can be deleted because the constant branch dominates them nearby. The remaining branches are logarithms of analytic units with constants; their maximum is a convex PL function of moment coordinates. This proves local tropical convexity. Theorem 20.8.1, or its local exact-deletion argument, supplies the original smooth psh approximations. The construction uses rational weights but does not require those weights to belong to the value group, nor does it change the field. ◻
In the normalized discrete/trivial framework of [Wu26], Definition 2.3 admits these rational-weighted metrics; Proposition 2.4 is the cited model identification. Thus the theorem reconstructs the barrier geometry for integral projective varieties in that framework. If is the initial model background on , let be the difference of the constructed metric and the initial metric. It is a global continuous PL function there, and . Inserting this and (11.8.4) into Proposition 11.7.3 gives its extension formula on a fixed neighbourhood, with the required background correction. The geometric construction is proved here; the model identification is an explicitly attributed input. Reducible varieties and more general analytic spaces have not been added to this statement.
The remaining comparison input
The preceding results settle the quantitative diagonal step, bounded-family tropical localization and projective barrier geometry. Section 11.9 now assembles these with model approximation to obtain the PL-to-smooth direction on one ordinary neighbourhood, for its explicitly stated nontrivially valued rational-generator category. Proposition 11.22.14 supplies the smooth-to-PL direction for one original smooth psh input in this projective setting. The common-domain passage for arbitrary sequences, identification of the full source generator class and extension to trivial valuation remain separate.
There is also a source dependency that cannot be replaced by the elementary constructions above. Wu invokes Theorem 6.13 of Amini–Piquerez–Wu, Mixed differential calculus and Monge–Ampère equations on tropical varieties. Both inspected bibliographies list it as a 2026 preprint without an identifier. A targeted search of the title and the authors’ publication pages did not locate its primary full text in this revision. Accordingly, the analytic comparison assigned to that theorem is recorded as an unverified imported input. This is an access limitation, not evidence that the paper or theorem does not exist. Corollary 11.7.6 retains its explicit source-dependent status.
References. Wu26, Definitions 2.3 and A.1, Propositions 2.4, 2.11 and 3.28, and Appendix A, pp. 52–54; APW26, Definition 4.3, Example 4.9 and Propositions 5.19 and 5.21, fixed October v1. The counterexample and the common-domain estimates are proved here. Tropical bounded-growth extension and the indicated model comparison remain cited framework inputs.
11.9 From PL sequences to smooth sequences on one neighbourhood
The projective barrier of Section 11.8.4 can be chosen before the functions to be approximated. The bound of an individual function then affects only a scalar in the construction, not the final neighbourhood. Combining this observation with the known approximation of nef model metrics gives one direction of the local comparison without an envelope hypothesis. We state the coefficient and model conventions explicitly: arbitrary real PL weights cannot be identified with rational model metrics without a further argument.
The model-compatible class of generators
Throughout this section is complete and nontrivially valued, its absolute value is fixed, and is an integral projective -variety of dimension at least one. Put and . For an ordinary open , write for the finite continuous functions which locally have the form where the are analytic units on the neighbourhood in question. Presentations and neighbourhoods may vary with the point. This is the local convex rational PL class used below. It is stable under finite maxima, positive rational scaling, and addition of constants in . Products of the finite lists of units give common moment charts for these operations.
Every such local presentation is uniformly approximable by original smooth psh functions on that neighbourhood: apply the regularized maximum to its affine branches. This assertion concerns a single presentation. It does not yet give a common approximation domain for a sequence of functions, each with its own covering by presentations. A finite convex PL function on an ordinary real open set has the displayed form after shrinking to a convex neighbourhood. At a boundary point of an extended tropical space, the reduction to finite coordinates is supplied for ambient convex PL functions in Section 11.10.1. The present theorem assumes (11.9.1); the relative-image class is discussed separately in Remark 11.10.10.
NAG-900139 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.9.1. (Positivity at a continuous endpoint). On an ordinary open set, suppose decreases to a finite continuous function . Then is positive against the original CLD compactly supported smooth tests.
Proof. Local regularization of (11.9.1) gives positivity of . For a fixed test , Dini’s lemma gives uniform convergence on its compact support. The smooth top-degree form defines a signed measure of finite total variation there, so Nonnegativity on positive tests passes to the limit. No smooth approximating sequence on a common neighbourhood has been used. ◻
We use two model-theoretic inputs. First, on a proper algebraic analytification, integral PL metrics are formal/model metrics; rational versions follow by taking a common tensor power on a finite cover. The model/formal/PL comparison is [GM] (Theorem 1.1). Constants in cause no extension of : after a tensor power they are logarithms of absolute values of elements of . Second, a model metric whose curvature current is positive on the whole projective analytification is nef. This is the model criterion in [CLD25] (Corollary 18.8.8), with the residual mechanism recorded in Theorem 19.18.12 and Section 19.18.13. These are named geometric inputs. For the specific maximum weights below, Proposition 11.10.7 also supplies a route through Gubler–Künnemann functorial positivity and Gubler–Martin descent; its proof uses the displayed generators and does not depend on the present approximation theorem.
A fixed barrier with variable scales
NAG-900140 Open proof obligation
Lemma 11.9.2. For , the data of Theorem 11.8.9 can be chosen so that all weights of the Fubini–Study metric lie in . In particular is a rational model metric and .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the value-group barrier in the stated scope; BE21 Theorem 5.14 is invoked.
NAG-900141 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.9.3. (Localization with a domain independent of the bound). Fix the preceding barrier, put and , and let . Choose with , , on , and a rational with . Then there is a nef rational model metric on the fixed line bundle whose weight relative to the same power-section frame as satisfies The neighbourhood depends only on and the chosen barrier. The numbers may depend on .
Proof. Define a global function by Every boundary point of lies in and has . There . Continuity gives an open collar on which the maximum vanishes, so the formulas glue. The collar may depend on , which is harmless: it is used only to construct this one global metric. Since are locally rational PL with constants in , the glued function is rational PL. The model/PL comparison stated above makes a rational model metric.
On the interior of , its local weight is Both branches, and their maximum on a common moment chart, are in . Outside the modification the metric is . Hence its curvature current is positive everywhere. The quoted current/model criterion gives nefness; alternatively apply Proposition 11.10.7 directly to these weights. Finally, on , so the first branch is active and (11.9.2) follows. ◻
Unlike Proposition 11.7.3, this proposition does not claim that the global extensions preserve the order of an entire family. Different scales usually destroy that order. Order is restored only after restricting the approximants to the fixed . This is why a uniform bound for the whole family is unnecessary.
Global approximation and the fixed-domain diagonal
NAG-900142 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.9.4. (A known global approximation input). A nef rational model metric on an ample line bundle over a projective -scheme is a uniform limit of pure Fubini–Study metrics. Consequently, for every it admits a global original smooth semipositive metric with . Here is complete and nontrivially valued.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the required FS density for the nef classes and its exact hypotheses; BE21 Theorem 7.8 is invoked.
This approximation theorem is already in the literature. Its role here is to supply functions on all of , so that the local domains no longer depend on the generator being approximated. No envelope continuity theorem is used in this step.
NAG-900143 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.9.5. (One neighbourhood for a decreasing PL sequence). Let decrease pointwise to . For every there is one ordinary open neighbourhood of and original smooth psh functions on such that . Neither a uniform bound on the family nor local boundedness or continuity of is required. Any generic-finiteness condition imposed in the definition of the endpoint class is preserved.
Proof. Choose the barrier and once by Lemma 11.9.2. Fix in . Each is continuous on the compact set , so choose its own and rational as in Proposition 11.9.3. This gives nef model metrics on the same ample , with weights satisfying Put . Apply Proposition 11.9.4 to with error less than . Let be the resulting smooth weight in the same power-section frame on . The function It is original smooth and psh because . A power-section frame defines a normalized weight by dividing by its tensor exponent; it does not require a root of that section over . Finally set . Lemma 11.8.1 proves on this same . ◻
NAG-900144 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.9.6. Under the hypotheses of Theorem 11.9.5, if is finite continuous, then is locally uniformly approximable by original smooth psh functions. Thus the continuous endpoints of this PL first-stage class belong to .
Proof. Shrink to a relatively compact neighbourhood inside and apply Dini’s lemma to the decreasing continuous functions and their continuous limit. ◻
Remark 11.9.7. This combines Wu’s localization mechanism, a model semipositivity criterion, Gubler–Martin’s PL/model comparison and Boucksom–Eriksson’s approximation theorem. The explicit choices are a fixed neighbourhood and errors ; no priority claim is made. Wu’s convention places his rational constants in . The ambient analytic generators are identified in Theorem 11.10.3; the relative finite-selection presentation is supplied in Theorem 11.12.5, with its explicit convention. Arbitrary real PL weights and trivial valuation are not covered.
First-stage comparison and further stability
Let be the local decreasing class generated by , with the same endpoint convention as the original smooth first-stage class . Theorem 11.9.5 proves . Corollary 11.24.4 now supplies the reverse inclusion in the same nontrivially valued integral-projective category, by rational replacement on a fixed affinoid. Thus in this precisely specified first-stage sense.
The following sufficient criterion is retained for its stability implication. Generator membership and first-stage equality are no longer the missing steps in this setting. Closure under decreasing limits of arbitrary sections of the resulting sheaf remains additional: their row domains may vary. Lemma 11.24.5 handles common-domain rows, but does not provide a common domain from termwise germ membership.
NAG-900145 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.9.8. (A sufficient stability criterion). Suppose every original smooth psh function locally belongs to , and is closed under decreasing limits of its sections on ordinary open sets whenever the endpoint is allowed. Then . In particular, its bounded decreasing stability implies the continuous-stage equalities of Theorem 11.7.5.
Proof. On a neighbourhood representing a section of , each smooth predecessor is a section of the sheaf by the first hypothesis. The second hypothesis places their decreasing limit there on that same open set. This proves the reverse inclusion; combine it with Theorem 11.9.5. Apply Theorem 11.7.5 for the last assertion. ◻
11.10 Convex PL generators at the extended tropical boundary
The logarithms in the presentation of are logarithms of units. An analytic tropicalization, however, may be defined by functions with zeros, so its image meets the boundary of , where . We explain why this distinction disappears locally for finite ambient convex PL functions. The argument expands [Wu26] (Remark 3.2); it also makes precise the absolute-value estimate used in Remark 3.9 of that paper. The word ambient is essential: the defining function is given on an open subset of , not merely on a tropical image.
Finite affine selections and boundary factorization
We use the finite-valued convention of [Wu26] (Definition 3.1(1)–(2)). On an ambient open , an affine function is a finite continuous function for which every summand is finite; in particular if contains a point with . A finite PL function is locally a continuous selection from a finite list of such affine functions. Locally convex means that at every point there is a touching affine lower support on a neighbourhood. Thus the contact condition is and there, with the correction explained in Example A.8.1.
NAG-900146 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.10.1. (Eliminating infinite coordinates). Let have its first coordinates infinite and its remaining coordinates equal to . Let be finite PL on an ambient open neighbourhood of . There are , an open ball about , and a finite continuous PL function on such that where is the projection onto the last coordinates. The affine pieces of are obtained by deleting the first coordinates from one local affine list for . If , the conclusion is that is constant on .
Proof. Choose one open patch containing on which selects from finitely many affine functions , and choose the product inside that patch. Finiteness of each summand at forces all coefficients of the first coordinates to vanish. Write the remaining affine functions as on . For fixed , the continuous function on the connected fibre takes values in the finite set . It is therefore constant on that fibre. Evaluation along any fixed section of defines a continuous , and is one of the . This proves the factorization and the PL assertion. ◻
Independence of the infinite coordinates is not yet a maximum presentation. The following elementary real argument supplies that remaining step, and keeps the original affine coefficients.
NAG-900147 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.10.2. (From affine selection to a convex maximum). Let be an open ball and let be continuous, with for affine . Then is Lipschitz on , with constant for the Euclidean norm. If has a local touching affine lower support at every point, it is convex and there is a nonempty subset such that
Proof. On a line segment in , restrict the finite list of affine functions and discard identical restrictions. Distinct restrictions intersect at at most one point. Between these finitely many intersection points, continuity forces to follow one affine restriction. Its slope on each interval is bounded by times the speed of the segment. Summing the interval estimates proves the Lipschitz bound.
At an interior breakpoint of the segment, a touching affine lower support has slope satisfying , where and are the left and right slopes of . Hence the slopes never decrease. The restriction to every segment is convex, so is convex on .
Discard duplicate affine functions on . The hyperplanes cut a dense open subset of into finitely many chambers. On each chamber the selected affine function is fixed. Let consist of the indices selected on some chamber. If , choose in that chamber. For any and sufficiently small , the point remains in the chamber. Convexity gives so . Equality with one of these supporting pieces holds on every chamber and hence, by continuity, throughout . This proves (11.10.2). For both assertions are immediate. ◻
If the function of Lemma 11.10.1 is locally convex, then has the lower supports required by Lemma 11.10.2: fix finite values of the first coordinates and restrict each local support to that slice. Thus a finite ambient convex PL function near a boundary point is a maximum of finitely many affine functions of the finite coordinates alone. No convex-extension theorem for a tropical variety enters this argument.
Analytic pullbacks and the value group
Fix the absolute value of and put , . In this subsection a compatible PL function has rational slopes and constants in in its local affine lists. This is a coefficient convention, not a normalization of the field.
NAG-900148 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.10.3. (Ambient analytic generators and ). Let be an ordinary open in a -analytic space, let be analytic functions on , and write , with . Suppose is a finite compatible locally convex PL function on an ambient open containing . Then locally has the unit-logarithm maximum presentation (11.9.1).
Conversely, if is nontrivially valued, every germ with that presentation can be written as for analytic units and a finite compatible locally convex PL function on all of . Consequently these global-ambient analytic generators and define the same sheaf of germs.
Proof. Fix . Reorder the coordinates so that the functions vanishing at are precisely the first functions. Apply Lemmas 11.10.1 and 11.10.2 at . On a product neighbourhood of that point, On the inverse image of , shrink about so that the remaining are analytic units. Substitution gives (11.9.1), with . The functions that vanish at have been deleted exactly, not assigned logarithmic values by a limiting convention. If all vanish, the pullback is constant near .
For the converse write on a neighbourhood of . Choose a positive integer with and put . Negative exponents are allowed because the are units. Nontrivial valuation makes dense in . Choose with and shrink so that . Define where a branch with contributes to this maximum. At such a coordinate, the inequality deletes that branch on a neighbourhood. The remaining branches are finite affine functions. More explicitly, cover each coordinate by and ; their finitely many product sets give finite affine presentations after the inactive branches are deleted. Thus is finite continuous PL on all of , with the stated coefficients. On each such neighbourhood it is a maximum of affine functions and hence has touching lower supports. Finally on the chosen neighbourhood. No extension of or change of its absolute value has occurred. ◻
Remark 11.10.4. Wu assumes for a nontrivially valued field in [Wu26] (Section 2.1, p. 5). Under that convention, the rational constants in Definition 3.1 belong to , so the preceding theorem applies to the ambient analytic generators in Remark 3.9, after correcting the touching-support formula. For a fixed absolute value without this convention, rational constants need not lie in ; our theorem retains the actual value-group condition. The boundary factorization itself allows real coefficients, but the rational model argument of Section 11.9 does not thereby acquire real coefficients.
Approximation through zeros
At a zero of , uniform control of is unavailable. The useful coordinates for perturbing the analytic functions are their absolute values. Boundary factorization provides precisely the needed regularity in these coordinates.
NAG-900149 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.10.5. (A local Lipschitz estimate in absolute values). Let be any finite PL function with real affine pieces on an ambient open . Define , with . Then is locally Lipschitz on for the Euclidean distance. Its restriction to every compact subset is Lipschitz. Convexity is not required.
Proof. Fix , with its first coordinates zero and the rest positive. Lemma 11.10.1 makes independent of the first coordinates on a neighbourhood of . For the remaining coordinates choose a neighbourhood on which and the logarithmic image lies in the ball of that lemma. The first part of Lemma 11.10.2 gives a Lipschitz constant for on . Since the resulting local constant for is at most . If there are no positive coordinates, is locally constant.
To pass to a compact , take a finite cover by relative neighbourhoods on which these pairwise Lipschitz estimates hold. A Lebesgue number ensures that two points of at distance less than lie in one member of the cover. Use the largest of the finitely many local constants for these pairs. For the other pairs, use the bound . The maximum of the two constants works on all of . ◻
NAG-900150 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.10.6. Let be compact. Suppose that continuous maps from to satisfy uniformly and . For all sufficiently large , the compositions are defined and for a constant independent of . In particular, this applies to uniformly approximating tuples of absolute values of analytic functions, including at their zeros.
Proof. The compact image has a compact neighbourhood inside the relatively open set . Uniform convergence places all sufficiently large images in that neighbourhood. Apply Proposition 11.10.5 there. ◻
This proves the change-of-coordinates estimate used in [Wu26] (Remark 3.9). It does not construct the algebraic approximants to the analytic functions: that is a separate approximation assertion on the specified rational domain. Once absolute-value approximants on a fixed compact domain are supplied, the displayed estimate transfers their error without taking logarithms at zeros.
Model semipositivity through functorial positivity
For these generators the model-nefness step also follows from the earlier work of Gubler–Künnemann and Gubler–Martin. The reason is stronger than positivity of a single current: the same maximum presentation survives pullback. This gives another route for the metrics constructed in Proposition 11.9.3.
NAG-900151 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.10.7. (A criterion for the constructed model metrics). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, let be a proper -scheme, and let be a rational model metric on a line bundle . Suppose its local weights have the maximum presentation (11.9.1). Then is a nef model metric.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Establish the model-nef criterion and its functoriality in the stated category; the proof uses GK19 and GM.
This proof uses the published model comparison and descent theorems as inputs; it does not re-prove their lifting arguments. The passage through descends a numerical property of a model, rather than an equality of currents or representatives. The local regularizations and the final sequence of Theorem 11.9.5 are still constructed over the original . The criterion is specific to weights with the displayed presentations and does not assert that arbitrary positive currents are functorially positive.
The resulting regularization statement
NAG-900152 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.10.8. (Decreasing ambient PL generators). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, let be an integral projective -variety of positive dimension, and let be ordinary open. Suppose the finite continuous functions decrease pointwise to , and that each locally admits an ambient analytic presentation as in Theorem 11.10.3, with rational slopes and constants in . Then near each there is one ordinary open and original smooth psh functions on with . The analytic functions in the presentations may have zeros; their charts and neighbourhoods may vary with both and the point. If is finite continuous, the convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Proof. Theorem 11.10.3 gives for every as a local membership assertion on the original . Apply Theorem 11.9.5. Its projective barrier construction, not an intersection of countably many presentation neighbourhoods, provides the common . The last assertion is Dini’s lemma on each compact subset. ◻
A relative touching-support condition on a polyhedral set must be distinguished from ambient convexity even before passing to analytic spaces. The following example explains why a same-chart extension cannot be taken for granted.
Example 11.10.9. (Relative supports do not give a same-chart convex extension). In , let be the one-dimensional fan with primitive ray vectors It is positively weighted and balanced. Define a continuous rational PL function on its support by for , and for . At every point of , has an affine lower support touching on a relative neighbourhood. Nevertheless its germ at the origin is not the restriction of an ambient convex function on any open convex neighbourhood of the origin.
Proof. Balancing is the identity . The function is continuous at the origin and affine on each ray; it selects from and . At the origin, the constant zero function is a touching lower support. At a nonzero point a sufficiently small relative neighbourhood meets only its ray, where either or agrees with . Suppose that a convex ambient extension existed near the origin. For sufficiently small , its midpoint inequality would give a contradiction. The obstruction depends on the presentation. Indeed, take the balanced fan in with rays generated by , all of weight one. The integral linear map maps these generators to , respectively. It maps the supports homeomorphically, and its ray lattice indices give the weights on . On the lifted support one has This is an ambient convex PL presentation after changing the fan. This calculation is polyhedral; Proposition 11.16.1 realizes it by analytic units over fields with . ◻
Remark 11.10.10 (The remaining source-class interface). The ambient analytic generators of [Wu26] (Remark 3.9) are now covered, with the stated coefficient convention and corrected convexity. Definitions 3.6–3.7 there instead use PL and convex functions on , and the two properties may initially be presented in different charts. Such an image need not be ambient open. A general identification therefore needs a presentation theorem with any necessary changes of chart, not a presumed same-chart convex extension. Example 11.10.9 refutes that elementary extension shortcut; Section 11.16 supplies its analytic realization and a smooth psh variant, but no obstruction after changing tropicalization. The unit-chart PL identification and the relative-support positivity step are proved in Section 11.11. Section 11.12 completes the extended-image PL identification for its explicit relative finite-selection convention. The prescribed-affinoid reverse replacement and the comparison of four explicit first-stage classes are proved in Section 11.24.3. Source-category identification and sheaf-level decreasing closure remain separate before identifying the full classes in Theorem A.3.
A transfer for locally semipositive rational PL functions
There is another way to use the projective barrier without demanding an ambient maximum presentation for every generator. Assume directly that the rational PL generators are locally semipositive in the model sense. The maximum theorem of Gubler–Rabinoff then supplies the positivity of the patched metric. We record the precise synthesis because it isolates a potentially weaker interface for comparison with another local psh theory.
Write for the finite continuous -PL functions on an ordinary open whose residues are nef at every point, in the sense of [GJR] (Proposition 7.1 and Definition 7.2). Equivalently, locally a tensor power of the metric is given on a strictly analytic neighbourhood by a nef formal model. The equivalence is the cited proposition; it is not deduced merely from positivity of . Rational PL here uses logarithms of analytic units on a strict analytic domain cover, so constants in are admitted.
NAG-900153 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.10.11. (Fixed-domain transfer from locally nef PL generators). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, let be an integral projective -variety of positive dimension, and let be ordinary open. If decreases pointwise to , then every has one ordinary open neighbourhood carrying original smooth psh functions . No uniform bound on the family and no local boundedness of the endpoint are required. For a finite continuous endpoint the convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the transfer between nef, PL and approximated metrics in the original hypotheses; the proof uses the listed GM, GRPL and GJR inputs.
Every member of is locally in : its affine unit-logarithm branches are rationally harmonic, and repeated application of the same maximum theorem preserves semipositivity. The new theorem therefore gives a second proof of the earlier transfer. More generally, it suffices to verify model compatibility and local semipositivity of a proposed source generator; an ambient convex extension is unnecessary for this route. Theorem 11.11.6 completes the semipositivity step whenever the function is already model-compatible PL; Proposition 11.11.5 verifies that membership for unit-chart relative presentations. Theorem 11.12.5 now supplies extended relative-image membership under its common-branch convention. The rational coefficient restriction also remains substantive: [GRPL] (the paragraph following Corollary 5.5) warns that maxima need not remain -PL in the strict domain category for larger groups .
For a single , apply Theorem 11.10.11 to the constant sequence . This gives decreasing original smooth psh approximants near each point. The related [GRPL] (Theorem 1.5) applies to semipositive real PL functions on a boundaryless strictly analytic space and gives uniform approximation by locally Fubini–Study functions. The present argument keeps rational coefficients and a projective ambient space, while handling a whole decreasing family on one neighbourhood and choosing original smooth approximants. The locally Fubini–Study conclusion and the original smooth conclusion should not be identified without the smoothing step. Likewise, [GRPL] (Theorem 1.4) gives semipositivity of a pointwise limit only when that limit is still real PL; it does not supply the decreasing closure of an arbitrary generated psh class needed in Section 11.9.4.
11.11 Relative supports and the curvewise route to nefness
The obstruction in Example 11.10.9 concerns extension in a fixed tropical chart. It does not obstruct a different route: pull a touching affine support back to an analytic curve, use harmonic comparison there, and then apply the curve criterion for semipositive PL functions. The two steps to distinguish are positivity and membership in the model-compatible PL class. This section proves the positivity step even at extended tropical boundary points, and proves the PL identification when the presentation uses analytic units.
A lower-contact criterion on curves
We first isolate a comparison argument that requires no polyhedral subdivision and no differentiability. Harmonicity in this subsection is Thuillier harmonicity on smooth strictly analytic curves over a nontrivially valued field. We use its vector-space property, its local maximum principle, and the comparison definition of subharmonicity; precise modern references are [GRPSH] (Sections 3.2–3.3 and Proposition 3.14).
NAG-900154 Open proof obligation
Lemma 11.11.1. (Harmonic lower contacts). Let be a smooth strictly analytic curve over a complete nontrivially valued field, and let be continuous. Suppose that every has an open neighbourhood and a harmonic function on such that Then is subharmonic.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Establish the comparison for the pulled-back function on the analytic curve; GRPSH 3.1(3) used.
The contact inequality is used on a whole neighbourhood. Convexity on individual cells would not give it at a branching point. The proof also tests every interior point of ; no restriction to skeleton vertices or to a chosen collection of outgoing directions has been made.
Relative tropical supports, including zeros
Here is the exact relative interpretation used below. For a subset , a finite continuous has relative affine lower supports if for every there is a relative open neighbourhood and an expression , with real coefficients, such that every summand is finite on , there, and . This is the corrected touching convention of Example A.8.1, now explicitly on the relative image. We do not silently extend a definition stated only for ambient opens to arbitrary subsets.
NAG-900155 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.11.2. (Relative supports give classical psh functions). Let be any complete non-Archimedean field and a -analytic space. Suppose locally on ordinary opens that where is finite continuous on and has relative affine lower supports in the convention just specified. Then is classically psh in the sense of [GRPSH] (Definition 4.1). The functions may vanish; no PL assumption on is needed.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the curvewise test in the specified relative setting; the proof uses GRPSH Proposition 3.14.
NAG-900156 Open proof obligation
Corollary 11.11.3. (Decreasing limits in the curvewise class). A pointwise decreasing sequence of functions covered by Theorem 11.11.2, all defined on the same ordinary open , has a classically psh limit . The presentations may vary with the sequence index.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the relevant limit property inside the curvewise psh class; the proof applies GRPSH Proposition 4.2(4).
Identifying PL functions on a unit chart
We now impose the nontrivial valuation needed for the strict model theory. Put and . A rational affine expression has rational slopes and its constant in . This coefficient condition is essential for the strict analytic domains in the proof.
NAG-900157 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.11.4. (Selection on a finite polyhedral image). Let be the support of a finite rational -polytopal complex. Let be continuous and satisfy for finitely many rational affine expressions . There is a finite rational -polytopal subdivision of on each of whose closed cells equals one .
Proof. Subdivide every cell by all hyperplanes . On the relative interior of any resulting cell, two branches either agree identically or are everywhere distinct, and their order is fixed. At a point of , distinct values have a positive separation, so continuity of makes the chosen equivalence class of branches locally constant. The set is connected; hence one branch is selected throughout it. Continuity extends the identity to . Finiteness and rationality follow from the finite hyperplane arrangement. This argument uses connected polyhedral cells, not connected fibres of the tropicalization. ◻
NAG-900158 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.11.5. (Relative unit-chart PL functions are model-compatible). Let be a good strictly -analytic space of pure dimension, with complete and nontrivially valued. Suppose that, locally on ordinary opens , a finite continuous function has a presentation , where for analytic units on , and is locally a continuous finite selection of rational affine expressions on the relative image . Then is Q-PL in the sense of [GJR] (Definition 5.1). No convexity is assumed.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the polyhedral image and analytic sheaf gluing required by the local presentation; GJR section 3.2 and 5.2(4).
Nef residues and the fixed-domain consequence
NAG-900159 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.11.6. (The relative-support model criterion). Let be good and strictly analytic over a complete nontrivially valued . Let be an R-PL function in the GJR sense. If has the relative-support presentations of Theorem 11.11.2, then its residue line bundle is nef at every . In particular, on a pure-dimensional , it suffices that have both a unit-chart rational PL presentation as in Proposition 11.11.5 and a relative-support presentation. These two presentations need not use the same tropicalization.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the model-nef comparison and the residual criterion; GRPSH Theorem 4.3 and GRPL Proposition 5.1/Corollary 5.4.
There is a version-numbering discrepancy worth recording for citation. The proof of [GRPSH] (Theorem 4.3) in arXiv:2506.13548v2 refers to Proposition 3.1 and Corollary 3.5 of its companion paper. In the fixed arXiv:2503.05513v1 consulted here, the corresponding statements are Proposition 5.1 and Corollary 5.4. We use the latter locators for that file; the discrepancy is bibliographic and does not invalidate the comparison theorem.
NAG-900160 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.11.7. (Relative generators on one final neighbourhood). Let be integral projective of positive dimension over a complete nontrivially valued , and let be ordinary open. Suppose decrease pointwise to , each has the relative-support presentations above, and each is Q-PL in the GJR sense. For every there are one ordinary open neighbourhood and original smooth psh functions on decreasing to . It is enough to verify the Q-PL hypothesis by the local unit-chart presentations of Proposition 11.11.5. If is finite continuous, convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Proof. Theorem 11.11.6 gives nef residues for every . Apply Theorem 11.10.11. In that theorem the barrier and final neighbourhood are fixed before the sequence terms are extended; their bounds and scaling factors may depend on . Consequently no intersection of countably many chart neighbourhoods is taken here. The last assertion is Dini’s theorem on each compact subset. ◻
Example 11.11.8. (Cellwise affine does not suffice). Choose with , and on the open annulus put . This function is Q-PL and affine on each of the two skeletal intervals separated by , but it is not subharmonic. Indeed, choose with . On the strict closed annulus , the constant harmonic function agrees with at both boundary points, whereas at the unit-radius Gauss point. Thus harmonic comparison fails. Equivalently, a touching affine lower support at the central tropical point would require a slope simultaneously at least and at most .
Example 11.11.9. (A monomial inequality at a common zero). In the closed unit bidisc over a complete nontrivially valued field, put . There is no rational domain of with . In particular is not a finite union of rational domains of . This explains why the Laurent-domain step in Proposition 11.11.5 cannot simply be repeated with vanishing coordinates.
Proof. Write a rational domain containing in the form , where and generate the unit ideal. Necessarily , since otherwise all would vanish. An analytic function nonzero at the -rational point has constant absolute value on some ordinary neighbourhood of : use . For the finitely many vanishing at , continuity makes after shrinking. Hence every such rational domain contains an ordinary neighbourhood of . But, for any with , the points converge to and lie outside . This proves the claim. ◻
Two local proof repairs in tropical regularization
The reverse approximation direction leads back to [APW26] (Proposition 5.21). We record two elementary repairs in its surrounding convexity and localization arguments. They concern the stated auxiliary claim and a displayed zero set, not counterexamples to the intended regularization theorem.
NAG-900161 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.11.10. (The missing hypothesis in the interval claim). A continuous with a touching affine lower support at every interior point is convex. If an affine also touches from below on at , then on all of . The contact condition at alone does not imply this conclusion.
Proof. On any interval , let be the affine interpolant of the endpoint values. If had a positive maximum , its maximum set would be a nonempty compact subset of . At a maximum point, subtracting from a touching affine support gives an affine function with an interior local maximum, hence a constant. As in Lemma 11.11.1, the maximum set is therefore open as well as closed in , a contradiction. Thus , which proves convexity. If for some , convexity gives, for , contradicting the lower support near . Without the interior hypothesis, and give a counterexample: near , but . ◻
The auxiliary interval claim printed in the proof of [APW26] (Proposition 3.3), p. 23, states only the condition at . Its subsequent proof uses a support at an interior maximum point. The proposition’s actual local-convexity hypothesis supplies exactly that missing condition, so the corrected claim above repairs this inference.
NAG-900162 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.11.11. (The strict-support zero set). Let be a compact Hausdorff space, , and let be continuous nonnegative functions with and . For positive decreasing sequences , put Then , the closures are nested, and For every neighbourhood of , eventually .
Proof. Positivity of gives , and nonnegativity of makes decreasing. Continuity and the uniform bound give Thus their intersection lies in and contains . If the final assertion failed, the nonempty nested compact sets would have a common point, contradicting (11.11.3). ◻
In [APW26] (Proposition 5.10), put , let be its strict local affine support at , and let support . Shrink to a compact neighbourhood on which both support inequalities hold, and take The strict support gives . Thus the displayed intersection in the proof on p. 37 must use , not . The latter can be the whole neighbourhood when . The shrinking argument is valid with the corrected zero set. In addition, the maximum modification has the exact pointwise increment Taking the right side at most and the modification set compactly inside the support neighbourhood makes the function equal to near its boundary. Hence it glues to outside. On one obtains , where . Preservation of the tropical psh class under this maximum and gluing is the separate cited input [APW26] (Lemma 4.13). We have repaired its localization calculation, not re-proved the entire tropical regularization theorem.
Remark 11.11.12 (The coefficient issue in local PL density). In [APW26] (Sections 2.1.1, 2.1.4–2.1.5), rationality of a polyhedron constrains the normals of its defining half-spaces, while their constants may be real; the affine functions used for PL functions are real affine. Proposition 5.21 is stated for this PL class. It does not state that its approximants have rational slopes and constants in the value group of an independently chosen analytic field. This extra conclusion cannot be inferred from the word “rational” attached to the polyhedral structure.
For example, the real convex PL function is allowed in that polyhedral category. Over a field whose fixed additive value group is , its pullback on is not R-PL in the strict GJR category: the bend at cannot occur in a finite strict polyhedral presentation. This is the example of [GJR] (Example 5.3), applied to the present comparison. It does not disprove the existence of better approximants. It shows that a coefficient-preserving approximation theorem, or an explicit replacement argument, is required before using APW local density as a Q-PL/model input.
There is nevertheless a simple replacement on a bounded unit chart when an ambient convex maximum is already available. This distinguishes a coefficient issue from the separate problem of extending a relatively convex function off its tropical image.
NAG-900163 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.11.13. (Coefficient-controlled approximation on a bounded chart). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, with . Let be bounded and There are convex maxima of affine functions with slopes in and constants in such that decreases uniformly to . Consequently, on a good strict analytic unit chart with bounded tropical image, the pullback of has a decreasing uniform approximation by GJR Q-PL functions having relative affine lower supports. No change of the absolute value or extension of is required.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the analytic Q-PL assertion for the finite maxima. The coefficient approximation is in the withheld proof; the non-Stacks use is GJR 5.2(7).
The monotonicity is asserted on , not on all of . Every point of a unit chart has a neighbourhood with bounded tropical image. Thus the proposition resolves the local coefficient problem for finite ambient convex maxima, including the irrational-bend example above. It does not supply such a maximum for an arbitrary relatively convex tropical function; Example 11.10.9 prevents that shortcut on a fixed chart.
What remains in the source comparison
Under the stated relative interpretation, Wu’s convexity condition gives classical psh, and known Q-PL membership then gives nef residues. The unit-chart membership is proved above. With vanishing coordinates, the ambient connected-fibre proof of Lemma 11.10.1 does not apply directly. Section 11.12 supplies the missing strict G-local unit-log presentation using finite polyhedral strata, with explicit common-branch and coefficient hypotheses.
Proposition 11.22.14 proves the reverse original-smooth-to-PL comparison for a single input in the stated projective setting. The arbitrary-family comparison and first-stage decreasing closure remain open; Corollary 11.11.3 proves only classical closure. Full Wu Theorem A.3, CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11 and arbitrary-current mixed products are not established here. The primary text of mixed-calculus Theorem 6.13 remains unavailable and is not used.
11.12 Finite selections at the extended tropical boundary
The remaining PL identification in Section 11.11.6 can be settled for a precise relative finite-selection class. The missing ingredient is finiteness of the polyhedral strata of an analytic tropical image. It permits a function to forget the coordinates tending to infinity, even though the fibres of the projection need not be connected. We first prove that assertion as a statement about polyhedra, and then identify its analytic hypotheses.
A recession argument
A closed polyhedron is an intersection of finitely many closed affine half-spaces in a finite-dimensional real vector space; the empty set is allowed. For , its recession cone is . Thus for every , and .
NAG-900164 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.12.1. (Simultaneous escape). Let be a nonempty closed polyhedron, where , and suppose that its projection to the second factor is bounded. Exactly one of the following alternatives holds:
There is with for every .
There is such that for every .
Proof. We use the elementary finite-dimensional Farkas alternative in the following form: if a linear functional is nonpositive on , then for some column vector . Here is a brief justification. The cone generated by the rows of is closed: in each nonnegative representation, a linear dependence can eliminate one positive coefficient, until its support is linearly independent. There are finitely many such supports; on a fixed independent support convergence of the represented vectors forces convergence of the coefficients. If were outside this closed convex cone, separation would give with , a contradiction.
It follows that a linear functional unbounded above on a nonempty polyhedron is positive on some recession vector: otherwise gives on . Apply this observation to If alternative (2) fails, is unbounded above on . Hence has a recession vector with . The inequalities give . Boundedness of the -projection forces , proving (1). Conversely, a ray with every makes unbounded. ◻
NAG-900165 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.12.2. (Factorization on a polyhedral tail). Let be bounded and let be compact, with . For each , assume that the stratum is, after deleting the infinite coordinates, a finite union of closed polyhedra. Let be continuous and suppose that there are finitely many functions such that everywhere. Then there exists such that, for every with all , The threshold depends on and its finite polyhedral presentations, not on or on the functions .
Proof. For a polyhedron in a stratum with at least one finite -coordinate, apply Lemma 11.12.1 to those coordinates. If its second alternative holds, choose as there. Finitely many strata and polyhedra occur, so choose greater than all these bounds and at least ; if there are no such bounds, any suffices.
A point in the stated tail either already has all , or lies in a polyhedron of the first type. In the latter case choose its recession vector . The ray obtained by increasing the finite -coordinates by , and leaving the others infinite, lies in for every . Along this connected ray, takes values in the fixed finite subset of . Continuity therefore makes constant on the ray. Its limit in the ambient extended space is ; compactness of places that point in , and continuity gives (11.12.1). ◻
No connectedness of a whole projection fibre was used. The proof instead connects each point in a sufficiently deep tail to the same boundary point in its fibre. This distinction is important for relative images.
Example 11.12.3. (Why finite polyhedral structure is needed). In , let Set on the first curve, on the second, and . Both compactified curves are continuous images of , so is compact. They meet only at their common endpoint, where both values tend to zero; hence is continuous and selects from the two affine functions . It also has relative affine lower supports: use the active branch away from the endpoint, and at the endpoint. For every , small positive gives two points in the tail with the same and opposite values. Thus does not factor through on any tail. The finite-coordinate stratum is not a finite union of polyhedra. This is an abstract counterexample to dropping that hypothesis, not an asserted analytic tropical image.
The analytic image input and zero strata
We use the following named input from Martin: for a compact strictly -analytic space over a complete nontrivially valued field, the positive-coordinate image of finitely many analytic functions is a finite polyhedral set. In logarithmic coordinates its normals are rational and its constants lie in , where . See [Mar13] (Theorem 4.3.1, pp. 172–173; conventions in Section 4.1.1). The published strict version is [Mar15]. We checked the thesis proof; the published article was available only through its abstract. No broader non-strict or trivially valued formulation is used.
NAG-900166 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.12.4. (Stratified polyhedral analytic images). Let be strictly -affinoid, with complete and nontrivially valued. Let be analytic functions and analytic units on . The image satisfies the compactness, boundedness and finite-stratum hypotheses of Theorem 11.12.2, for some and bounded box .
Proof. Compactness follows from continuity and compactness of . The functions are bounded, so their negative logarithms have a common lower bound. Both and are bounded, so the last coordinates lie in a bounded box. Fix and take the closed analytic subspace defined by for . It is strictly affinoid. Apply Martin’s theorem on to the remaining , together with all , and take its positive-coordinate image. Positivity excludes exactly the additional zeros for . After taking negative logarithms this is precisely with its infinite coordinates deleted, not its closure across other strata. Martin’s finite union of closed polyhedra gives the assertion; empty strata cause no difficulty. If no coordinates remain, the stratum is empty or a single point, and the conclusion is immediate. ◻
From relative finite selections to model PL functions
Specify the relative convention before using it. On a relative neighbourhood of a point in a tropical image, a rational finite selection is a continuous real-valued function selecting from one finite list Every individual summand of every branch must be finite everywhere on , with . In particular, a branch cannot be defined only on the subset where it is selected. This is a substantive hypothesis.
NAG-900167 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.12.5. (Relative rational PL identification through zeros). Let be a pure-dimensional good strictly -analytic space, where is complete and nontrivially valued. Suppose a function is locally, on ordinary opens, the pullback under the negative logarithms of finitely many analytic functions of a relative rational finite selection in the convention (11.12.2). Then is Q-PL in the strict GJR sense. More precisely, near each point it has such a finite-selection presentation using only analytic units. No convexity assumption is required.
Proof. Fix . Shrink to an ordinary neighbourhood on whose tropical image one finite list works. Reorder the coordinates as , vanishing at , and , nonvanishing at . Shrink again so that the latter are units. If , Proposition 11.11.5 applies directly. Otherwise finiteness of each summand at the image of forces the coefficient of each to vanish in every branch. Thus all branches have the form , where .
Choose a compact strict affinoid neighbourhood of inside this open, and put . Lemma 11.12.4 and Theorem 11.12.2 give a threshold . Enlarge it to an element of ; this is possible since contains a positive element. Then is a strict affinoid domain containing an ordinary neighbourhood of . Indeed, choose and with ; its inequalities are . At they are strict, and lies in the ordinary interior of .
Define the boundary slice and its restricted function by The function is continuous on the compact set . The tail theorem gives and . It still selects from the same rational branches . Restrict to the ordinary interior of and apply Proposition 11.11.5. Varying proves the Q-PL assertion by sheafiness. ◻
This proof avoids subdividing inequalities between vanishing monomials into rational domains at their common zero, the invalid shortcut excluded by Example 11.11.9. Only inequalities against a nonzero constant are used to select ; the subsequent Laurent subdivision involves units. The argument combines Martin’s image theorem with an elementary recession calculation and the earlier unit-chart identification; no priority claim is made for that combination.
NAG-900168 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.12.6. (Relative generators in the fixed-domain transfer). Let be an integral projective variety of positive dimension over a complete nontrivially valued field . On one ordinary open , let be a decreasing sequence of functions satisfying Theorem 11.12.5, and assume each has local relative affine lower supports as in Theorem 11.11.2. The presentations and their charts may depend on . For every , there is one ordinary neighbourhood and a decreasing sequence of original CLD smooth psh functions on with . If is finite continuous, this convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Proof. Theorem 11.12.5 gives Q-PL membership for each term on . Theorem 11.11.6 gives nef residues, using the classical psh criterion and its cited comparison theorem. Now apply Theorem 11.10.11. The varying neighbourhoods used to identify individual terms are not intersected: they establish a sheaf property on before the fixed projective barrier is chosen. Its termwise scaling constants remain free to vary. Dini’s theorem gives the final assertion. ◻
Remark 11.12.7 (One tube for a family of finite selections). The unit-reduction part of the proof does not require rational coefficients. On a fixed compact image as above, every continuous finite selection from branches depending only on factors on the same tail, since the threshold in Theorem 11.12.2 is independent of those branches. The finite lists may differ for different members of a family. The resulting boundary restriction preserves pointwise order, maxima and minima. This gives a uniform domain when the image and the vanishing-coordinate set are already fixed. It gives no uniform domain for an arbitrary family of different analytic charts, and real coefficients do not by themselves give strict GJR PL membership.
Example 11.12.8. (Rational constants and a fixed valuation). Equip with the absolute value . This complete nontrivially valued field has . The constant function on the analytic point is not Q-PL in the strict unit-log sense: such a presentation would give for some positive integer and , which is impossible. The same obstruction holds at a -rational point of an analytic space, by evaluating the unit-log presentation there. Nevertheless is an original smooth pluriharmonic function. Thus this example separates coefficient categories; it is not a counterexample to smooth approximation or to psh comparison. No absolute value is changed during either argument.
Coefficient control for ambient convex functions
The remaining relative approximation problem should be distinguished from a coefficient problem that can be solved directly. Proposition 11.11.13 treats finite ambient maxima. Supporting hyperplanes extend that argument to every finite convex function on an ambient convex open set.
NAG-900169 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.12.9. (Decreasing rational approximation of ambient convex functions). Let be convex and open, let be finite continuous and convex, and let be nonempty compact. For every nonzero additive subgroup , there are finite maxima of affine functions with rational slopes and constants in whose restrictions to decrease uniformly to . Each is defined and convex on all of , but monotonicity is asserted only on .
Proof. At each a supporting affine function satisfies on and . To recall the input, separate the open convex epigraph from its boundary point . The separating functional has nonnegative last coefficient; that coefficient cannot be zero because is interior to . Division by its positive last coefficient gives .
Choose positive and . For fixed , continuity and compactness give finitely many supports with maximum satisfying on : the relative open sets , for , cover . Since is bounded, approximate each selected slope by a rational vector and each constant by an element of so that the resulting affine function differs by at most on . Let be the maximum of these rational affine functions. Then Set . The shift is still in , and This proves both assertions. It is not necessary to choose nested sets of supporting hyperplanes: the positive shifts enforce monotonicity on the prescribed compact set. ◻
NAG-900170 Open proof obligation
Corollary 11.12.10. (A coefficient-compatible local analytic class). On a pure-dimensional good strictly analytic space over a complete nontrivially valued , suppose locally that , where is given by analytic units and is finite continuous convex on a convex ambient open containing the image. Near every point, is a uniform decreasing limit of finite rational maxima of unit logarithms, with constants in . These approximants are Q-PL and have relative affine lower supports. For an integral projective of positive dimension, Corollary 11.12.6 consequently gives a decreasing original smooth psh approximation on one neighbourhood.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the Q-PL analytic presentation and stability under the maximum operation; the proof takes GJR 5.2(7) as input.
The supporting hyperplanes in this proof lie below on the entire ambient convex open. Relative local supports on a polyhedral union need not have that property. Thus the proposition cannot be used to fill the remaining general relative-density step by replacing the ambient set with a tropical image.
A maximum statement that must retain PL membership
The coefficient distinction also corrects a literal closure assertion in the consulted GJR v3, also present in the published 2026 version, pp. 191–192. Remark 7.11 suggests that the maximum of two semipositive R-PL functions is again semipositive R-PL, and its proposed argument treats maxima of R-PL LFS functions as R-PL LFS. Example 5.3 of that same version prevents this without an additional membership hypothesis. The later [GRPL] (Corollary 5.5) explicitly restricts the unconditional statement to or .
NAG-900171 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.12.11. (Maximum with the correct coefficient scope). Let be a good strictly analytic space over a complete nontrivially valued field. If are semipositive R-PL functions and is R-PL, then is semipositive. For Q-PL or integral PL inputs, membership of the maximum is automatic and the conclusion holds in the same coefficient class. For arbitrary R-PL inputs, that membership can fail even when both inputs are harmonic.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the applicable positivity and closure implications for the specified maximum; the proof uses GRPSH, GJR and GRPL.
The obstruction also occurs in the proper ambient setting of GJR Remark 7.11, which asks for semipositivity at a point. On extend by its constant values near and . This is integral PL when . Then and are global R-PL functions, harmonic near the point of the standard skeleton with . Their maximum has the same irrational bend there and is not R-PL near that point. Thus properness of the ambient curve does not repair the omitted local membership hypothesis.
The other expectation in GJR Remark 7.11, concerning pointwise limits, has a different status. It is now supplied by [GRPL] (Theorem 5.6): a pointwise limit of semipositive R-PL functions is semipositive when the limit is itself R-PL. That final membership hypothesis must also be retained. It neither asserts that all such limits are PL nor proves first-stage original-smooth decreasing closure.
Gaussian regularization at a boundary stratum
The projective tropical localization used earlier rests on a Gaussian regularization of a finite convex conewise-linear function. The calculation at infinity in [APW26] (Proposition 5.7, pp. 34–35) can be made independent of the chosen approach sequence. We give the elementary calculation, including the growth hypothesis and the direction of monotonicity.
NAG-900172 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.12.12. (Gaussian boundary limit for a finite maximum). Let be a finite-dimensional Euclidean space, let be linearly independent with , and put , and . Let be orthogonal projection. Suppose Set , and for . This set of active indices is nonempty. If and are the standard normalized Gaussian densities and , then The convergence is uniform for in compact subsets of . No monotonicity of the approaching parameters is assumed. Moreover for . If for a nonzero , the inequality is strict.
Proof. Every is nonpositive. Since , a maximizing index there has all these coefficients zero, proving that is nonempty. For , every inactive linear form in tends to as ; active forms annihilate . Consequently, for each fixed , Write . The function is -Lipschitz and subadditive. For , its nonnegativity and give the integrable bound Dominated convergence now gives the limit of the integral. Orthogonal decomposition factors the normalized Gaussian into the product of the two Gaussian densities; integration in gives exactly (11.12.3). Both sides, as functions of , have Lipschitz constant at most . A finite net on a compact subset of upgrades pointwise convergence to uniform convergence. Equivalently, any failure of uniform convergence would give a sequence of parameters and a convergent sequence of points contradicting that bound and the already proved pointwise limit.
Finally, , and integration gives monotonicity. If , the difference is a nonnegative continuous function of and is positive at : its value there is . It is therefore positive on a nonempty open set of positive Gaussian measure. Its integral is strictly positive. This proves strictness without a separate strict-convexity argument. ◻
NAG-900173 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.12.13. (Strict affine contact across all faces). In Proposition 11.12.12, suppose in addition that . The Gaussian convolution extends continuously to by its quotient formulas on all infinity strata. At each point it admits a strict affine lower support depending only on . Here strictness means equality only at that point, including comparison with points on partial infinity strata.
Proof. For put and , with orthogonal projection . Retain only the linear forms annihilating , and let their maximum on be . The preceding proposition, applied to the face generated by the for , gives the boundary value , evaluated at . For this is the original convolution.
We check the zero cone, since it controls strictness at partially infinite points. For , put . If , all active linear forms at have value at most zero on . Every inactive form is strictly negative on , so for sufficiently large all forms have value at most zero on . Since and , this gives . Conversely, if , every active form is nonpositive at , and by nonnegativity. Thus The projected generators are linearly independent, because the original generators are. In particular this cone is pointed. The formula is immediate also for . If , repeating the active-form construction on gives precisely ; orthogonal Gaussian pushforwards compose because . Proposition 11.12.12, with its locally uniform assertion, therefore proves continuity on approaching any higher stratum. There are only finitely many strata, so this proves continuity of the assembled extension.
Let contain all indices, so and . Gaussian convolution of a Lipschitz function is smooth, by differentiation of the Gaussian under the integral. It is strictly convex here. Indeed, for each nonzero direction , the restriction has different one-sided slopes: their difference is . A translate of any nontrivial segment in direction can cross this bend. The convexity gap is then positive on an open set of translates, and integration against the positive Gaussian makes the gap strictly positive. Hence the tangent affine function to at lies strictly below for . If , take its unique constant affine function instead.
On a proper infinity stratum indexed by , move in the nonzero direction . Its negative is outside the pointed zero cone, so Proposition 11.12.12 gives strict decrease after any positive step. Continuing toward the full infinity stratum yields . On the full infinity stratum equality occurs only at . This proves the stated strict contact, including all partial strata. ◻
Remark 11.12.14 (What the corrected calculation supplies). In the application of APW Proposition 5.7, is a finite maximum of linear forms with zero set the strongly convex cone . Thus for every nonzero , and finite points lie strictly above the boundary limit: first move by a positive multiple of , then pass to infinity using monotonicity. The normalized quotient Gaussian in (11.12.3) is the pushforward of the ambient Gaussian; an arbitrary nonorthogonal coordinate splitting must instead retain that pushforward density.
On p. 35 the source initially allows an arbitrary sequence tending to infinity and then calls the translated functions decreasing. Arbitrary approach sequences need not be monotone; the dominated-convergence proof above removes that restriction. The integrand before taking the limit must be , with appearing after passage to the limit. Later on the same page, for , the printed strict inequality has the wrong direction: for a nonzero increment it is . If two terms coincide, only equality is available. These corrections preserve the intended finite-point-to-boundary inequality. Corollary 11.12.13 supplies the same calculation on every partial infinity stratum, with its pointed zero cone verified explicitly. This proposition supplies the analytic limit calculation, not a new proof here of every global tropical-geometric input of APW Proposition 5.7.
Example 11.12.15. (Why Gaussian convolution needs a growth hypothesis). The finite-valued formulation of [APW26] (Lemma 5.8) needs an integrability qualification for arbitrary convex functions. On , is convex, since , but for every : the quartic term dominates in the exponent as . Thus arbitrary finite convex input does not give finite Gaussian convolution. For the globally Lipschitz finite PL input actually used in Proposition 5.7, the bound in the preceding proof gives finiteness, and convolution preserves convexity by integrating its defining inequality. The local proof repair does not contradict that intended application.
Rational approximation on a fixed rational fan
There is a relative case beyond ambient convex extension in which coefficient control can also be proved. The essential restrictions are that the input is already piecewise linear and that its fixed fan is rational. The argument is a finite-dimensional rational-polyhedral calculation, not a general regularization theorem for continuous relatively convex functions.
NAG-900174 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.12.16. (Coefficient density for relatively convex fan functions). Let be a finite rational polyhedral fan in , let be nonempty compact, and let be continuous, homogeneous and linear on each cone. Suppose that has a relative affine lower support near every point of . For any nonzero additive subgroup , there exist functions on , affine with rational slopes and constants in on the same cones, which have relative affine lower supports everywhere and decrease uniformly to on . The monotonicity is asserted only on . No ambient convex extension of is assumed.
Proof. Choose ambient covectors with . For every face choose a point in its relative interior. A local affine lower support at that point has a slope satisfying Indeed, comparison in both tangent directions inside identifies the slope on , and the support’s constant is then zero by homogeneity. For and , the point lies in for . Applying the local support inequality for small gives the last line. Conversely, these constraints imply a relative lower support at every point of : cones not containing that point can be excluded by shrinking, and on every remaining cone the covector is a lower support with contact.
Because the fan is rational and finite, the displayed conditions are finitely many homogeneous rational linear equalities and inequalities in the coordinates of all . For the inequalities it suffices to test a finite rational generating set of each cone, including generators of its lineality space with both signs if necessary. Thus the tuples form a rational polyhedral cone in a finite-dimensional vector space. Rational points are dense in . To see this at a particular tuple , impose as equalities the rational inequalities active at , together with the original equalities. Their nullspace has a rational basis. Approximate the coordinates of in that basis by rational numbers. The inactive inequalities remain strict for sufficiently close approximations, and the active equalities are preserved exactly.
Choose positive and set . Approximate the tuple of inside so closely that its rational covectors define a continuous homogeneous function with on . This is possible because is bounded and there are finitely many cones. The constraints give relative affine lower supports for . Set . Then The constants belong to , and shifting the supports by the same constants preserves contact. This proves the assertion. ◻
This argument combines a finite support criterion with rational-point density in a rational polyhedral cone; no priority claim is attached to the combination. On a unit chart whose image is contained in , take to be the image of a compact strict affinoid neighbourhood. The pullbacks of are Q-PL and have relative lower supports. Thus, in the projective setting of Corollary 11.12.6, they yield a decreasing original smooth psh approximation to near the point. This does not require a same-chart ambient convex extension.
For a nonhomogeneous complex with vertices involving arbitrary elements of , the displayed system need not have rational coefficients, and its affine constants require separate control. The argument above does not treat that case. Nor does it show that a general continuous relatively convex function is approximable by functions linear on one fixed rational fan. These are distinct remaining questions.
Example 11.12.17. (A fixed irrational-length subdivision can obstruct density). Let , and let be the boundary of the rectangle with vertices , , and , with its four-edge polyhedral complex. Take . All directions are rational and all vertex coordinates belong to . Define by the vertex values and extend linearly on each edge. This is a continuous relatively convex real PL function, but any continuous function affine with rational slopes on these same four edges satisfies The obstruction persists if the affine constants of are allowed to be arbitrary real numbers.
Proof. At an interior point of an edge, its affine expression is a relative support after shrinking. At a vertex the two adjacent edge directions are linearly independent, so there is an ambient affine function agreeing with on both incident edges. This supplies a relative support near that vertex. Thus has the stated relative convexity; no ambient convex extension is being asserted.
For let be the derivatives in the positive horizontal direction on the bottom and top edges, and the derivatives in the positive vertical direction on the left and right edges. Continuity around the rectangle gives Since and are linearly independent over , necessarily and . In particular For the same expression equals . Comparing the four vertex values proves (11.12.5). This calculation uses only the slopes and continuity, so there is no restriction on the constants. ◻
In this example refinement does remove the obstruction. Choose rational and rational with . Put on the bottom edge, on the top and right edges, and on the left edge set The values at the four vertices match. The new breakpoint is , and all slopes are rational, with constants in . The left-edge slopes increase from to , so relative convexity holds there; at the vertices affine supports again exist by independence of the incident directions. The uniform error is at most and tends to zero. Choosing these errors geometrically small and adding the positive shifts used in Proposition 11.12.16 also makes the approximation decreasing. Thus the example isolates the fixed-subdivision obstruction rather than an obstruction to approximation itself.
Taking and pulling back gives the same obstruction in every positive dimension , for the product complex: restrict any proposed approximant to . Relative supports pull back by projection. This is a counterexample in the category of finite polyhedral complexes with rational directions. The rectangle boundary is not asserted to be a balanced tropical variety or an analytic tropical image. The example does not rule out approximation after subdivision, changing charts, or using other analytic presentations, and does not refute the unrestricted regularization conclusion of APW. It explains why a proof that rationalizes coefficients while freezing an arbitrary -subdivision is insufficient. The distinction is sharpened in Section 11.19.4: the obstruction survives each fixed value-group refinement, but Example 11.19.9 gives an explicit decreasing approximation with a moving breakpoint.
Scope of the completed direction
The relative PL interface is now established with the stated common-branch and coefficient conventions. Wu’s Definition 3.1(1) uses rational constants, and his standing convention in Section 2.1 is when the valuation is nontrivial. Under that convention, these constants do lie in . Our formulation retains arbitrary fixed nontrivial absolute values by stating the coefficient condition explicitly; Example 11.12.8 explains why one must not omit it when leaving Wu’s normalization. It does not refute a claim under his standing convention. Definition 3.6 also uses images that need not be ambient open sets; our relative convention is explicit, rather than an attribution of an unstated convention to the source.
The direction obtained is from these relative rational convex generators to original smooth approximation on a fixed analytic neighbourhood. The reverse direction, coefficient-compatible approximation for general relatively convex functions, and the first-stage decreasing-closure problem remain separate. Neither full Wu Theorem A.3 nor CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11 follows from this section. No enlargement to an unrestricted positive-current Bedford–Taylor calculus, change of actual tests or support, or field-descent theorem is asserted.
11.13 Rational approximation on a fixed residue tube
The coefficient problem has a second, geometric form. A function already known to be R-PL has a finite presentation by integral PL functions. Their residue line bundles can be placed on one projective model. This permits rational perturbation after adding a small ample class, without rationalizing the vertices of a tropical subdivision. We carry out this argument with one neighbourhood for the whole finite-dimensional family.
Throughout this section is complete and nontrivially valued, , and . PL, Q-PL and R-PL have the strict analytic meaning of [GJR] (Section 5). In particular an arbitrary relative real PL presentation is not assumed to be an R-PL presentation in this sense. The geometric input below is the residue-model construction in [GJR] (Lemma 6.14 and proof of Proposition 7.10); the coefficient estimate and its ordered-family application are written out here.
A finite numerical estimate
NAG-900175 Open proof obligation
Lemma 11.13.1. (Rational perturbation with an ample margin). Let be a projective variety over a field, an ample line bundle, and line bundles. Choose positive integers such that and are ample, using additive notation in . If is nef, , and satisfy then is ample. In particular and may be chosen rational, with arbitrarily close to as tends to zero. No rational polyhedrality of the nef cone is required.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the ample margin used in the construction; the proof uses the GJR Proposition 7.10 argument.
Realizing a family before choosing its coefficients
NAG-900176 Open proof obligation
Lemma 11.13.2. (One residue tube for a finite PL presentation). Let be good and strictly -analytic, let , and let be integral PL functions on a neighbourhood of . After shrinking once, there are a compact strictly analytic neighbourhood of , an ordinary open neighbourhood of , an integral PL function on , a projective variety , line bundles on , and an ample line bundle on with the following properties.
and model the residues and . For every , is semipositive at if and only if is nef on .
If is semiample, then is locally Fubini–Study on . If that class is nef, the function is semipositive on . Here are real and locally Fubini–Study means semiampleness of the residue at every point.
All these data depend on the finite list and , not on .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the simultaneous neighbourhood/tube with the required residual class control; the proof applies the listed GJR inputs.
A decreasing Q-PL approximation
NAG-900177 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.13.3. (Rational approximation of a semipositive R-PL germ). Let be good and strictly -analytic, , and let be R-PL and semipositive at . There are one ordinary open neighbourhood of and Q-PL locally Fubini–Study functions on which decrease uniformly to . More precisely, for any fixed , the construction can be made to satisfy The approximants need not be harmonic when is harmonic. The claim is an explicit rational and ordered refinement of the construction of [GJR] (Proposition 7.10), not an assertion that that proposition is false.
Proof. Write on one neighbourhood, with integral PL, and apply Lemma 11.13.2. All and are continuous on the compact outer neighbourhood , so put and . Choose the integers in Lemma 11.13.1. For each choose and such that First choose the positive rational ; then choose the rational vector sufficiently close to . Zero values of some or impose no restriction. Since is nef, the class is ample. Consequently is Q-PL on and locally Fubini–Study on , while . Set . The added constant is in , hence is Q-PL with zero residue: after clearing denominators it is a logarithm of an element of . Thus is still locally Fubini–Study on . Its error band is (11.13.2), and The bound proves uniform convergence on all of . No intersection of a sequence of shrinking neighbourhoods occurs. ◻
NAG-900178 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.13.4. (Ordered families in a fixed finite presentation). In the setting of Lemma 11.13.2, suppose are semipositive at and decrease pointwise on their common original neighbourhood. Then on one ordinary open neighbourhood of there are Q-PL locally Fubini–Study functions such that No bound on the coefficient vectors or on the family is required. The common finite presentation is required.
Proof. Choose the data once for . In (11.13.3) replace by for the th term. The constants remain fixed; the rational choices may vary. The same estimate gives the first band, and Since uniformly, their decreasing limits agree, also when the limit takes the value . ◻
Consequences for original smooth approximation
NAG-900179 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.13.5. (Semipositive R-PL functions in the projective case). Let be an integral projective variety of positive dimension over . If is R-PL near and semipositive at , then on one ordinary open neighbourhood of there is a decreasing sequence of original CLD smooth psh functions converging to , uniformly on compact subsets. The same assertion holds for from Corollary 11.13.4, except that uniform convergence on compact subsets is asserted only when is finite continuous.
Proof. The preceding results give decreasing Q-PL functions on one ordinary open set, with nef residues at all its points. Apply Theorem 11.10.11 to that sequence. Its projective barrier and termwise rescaling supply the common smooth approximation domain. Dini’s theorem gives the asserted compact uniform convergence for a finite continuous endpoint. The residue rationalization itself used neither a scalar extension nor a change of the chosen absolute value. ◻
NAG-900180 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.13.6. (A comparison confined to strict R-PL germs). Under the projective hypotheses of Corollary 11.13.5, let be an R-PL germ at . The following three conditions are equivalent: is semipositive at ; is classically psh on a neighbourhood of in the curvewise sense of [GRPSH] (Definition 4.1); on some fixed neighbourhood is a uniform decreasing limit of Q-PL LFS functions. They imply that, on a fixed neighbourhood, is a decreasing limit of original CLD smooth psh functions, uniformly on compact subsets, and hence that is positive on the original CLD tests. Each neighbourhood here is ordinary open.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove both comparisons in the R-PL scope; the proof applies GRPL Theorem 5.6 and GRPSH Theorem 4.3.
The last current-positivity conclusion is not used to reverse the argument. In GRPSH, “classically psh” requires subharmonic pullback to curves after every analytic field extension. Positivity on tests on alone is a different condition. Neither a pullback of an arbitrary current nor an identification of these two definitions is hidden in this proof.
Remark 11.13.7 (What this coefficient argument does not identify). For an already R-PL function, classical psh is equivalent to semipositivity by [GRPSH] (Theorem 4.3), so that condition may replace semipositivity on a neighbourhood in the preceding corollary. An arbitrary decreasing sequence of semipositive R-PL functions need not come with one finite presentation valid for all terms. Applying Theorem 11.13.3 separately then gives neighbourhoods depending on the term; Corollary 11.13.4 does not remove that problem without its additional hypothesis. Nor does the construction identify arbitrary relative real PL functions with GJR R-PL functions, or approximate every original smooth psh function by relative rational generators. Those are different interfaces.
The projective corollary concerns the original CLD smooth class and consequently its original tests; it does not replace those tests by weakly smooth or tropical tests. It introduces no current pushforward, altered support, or unverified descent. Full Wu Theorem A.3, CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11, and an unrestricted positive-current Bedford–Taylor calculus do not follow. The improvement over the preceding section is a proved coefficient conversion for already semipositive strict R-PL germs, including ordered families with a fixed finite presentation.
11.14 Ample extensions: a fixed-model obstruction and the cofinal repair
The approximation argument in Section 11.9 needs an ample model after passing to a suitable higher model. It does not need an ample extension on every prescribed projective model. These assertions are different. The published [GM] (Lemma 4.12, p. 353) states the latter assertion; the example below disproves that literal statement. We then recover exactly the cofinal formal-model input needed for the metric approximation. This does not disprove [GM] (Proposition 4.11) or [BE21] (Theorem 7.8).
The missing generic-fibre factor
In that lemma, is a projective morphism of models inducing the identity on , and an ample extends . The proof chooses an arbitrary -ample bundle from a projective embedding and forms . Its generic restriction is The assumption does not trivialize : every line bundle is relatively ample for an identity morphism. The final identification in the published proof drops this factor. A missing justification alone would not refute the lemma. The following construction supplies the additional obstruction.
Example 11.14.1. (No ample extension on the prescribed model). Let , , with , where is any field. There are projective algebraic -models of and a morphism inducing such that extends to an ample line bundle on , but no , , extends to an ample line bundle on . The same obstruction exists in every generic dimension .
Proof. On , take the rank-two vector bundle defined by the extension class , where generates The middle term is locally free since the quotient is locally free. On the generic fibre the extension is nonzero, hence, by rescaling the one-dimensional extension class and using the Euler sequence, . On the special fibre the extension splits: . These are the classical deformation data relating the Hirzebruch surfaces and ; the argument uses them as an explicit model obstruction, not as a new deformation construction.
Use the quotient convention for and put . This is a smooth projective -scheme, hence regular and integral, with irreducible special fibre. Its generic fibre is , and . The special quotient defines a section on which has degree zero.
The vanishing shows that all three standard global sections of lift to . Together with the section of the subbundle , they generate : locally a section can first be matched in the quotient and then in the kernel. Thus is generated by four sections and defines . Its generic restriction is the Segre embedding associated to . Let be the schematic image. It is projective and flat over : its structure sheaf embeds into , which has no -torsion, and torsion-free modules over a DVR are flat. Its generic fibre is the Segre copy of . The induced is projective (use the closed graph and a projective embedding of over ). With this identification of the generic fibres it induces the identity. The bundle is ample and extends , and .
Suppose that a line bundle on extends . Then is generically trivial. A generic trivialization gives a rational section whose divisor is vertical. Since is regular and its special fibre is irreducible and reduced, this divisor is for an integer . But is principal. Thus , and . An ample bundle has positive degree on every projective integral curve, so is not ample. This proves the claimed failure for every .
For , take the products of both models with and replace by their external tensor products with . Regularity and irreducibility of the special fibre persist. The same vertical-divisor argument forces any extension of to be the indicated tensor power, whose degree on is zero for a -rational point . The ample extension on the target is the external tensor product of two ample bundles. ◻
NAG-900181 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.14.2. (The obstruction over any nontrivially valued field). The conclusion of Example 11.14.1 holds over every complete nontrivially valued field , with its fixed absolute value, and in every dimension at least two. No discrete valuation, characteristic assumption or field extension is needed.
Proof. Put and choose . On , with homogeneous coordinates , define by The minors include and , so is locally a split injection and is locally free of rank two. On the special fibre its cokernel is , as seen from the quotient map and the fourth basis vector. On the generic fibre, adding times the fourth row to the second row makes the matrix block diagonal, with columns and ; each block has cokernel . Thus . This is an explicit form of the preceding classical deformation; see also [Addington21] (Worksheet 2, part 3).
Set and . Its four generating sections give a morphism to the quadric Indeed the incidence relations are and , whose determinant is the displayed equation. The homogeneous coordinate ring is free of rank two over , because the equation is monic in . Hence is flat and of finite presentation over . The generic quadric is split and smooth: replacing by gives the usual Segre equation. The generic morphism is the complete embedding, so, after identifying generic fibres, is a projective model morphism inducing the identity. The target has the ample extension .
To replace the DVR divisor argument, use the projective-bundle Picard formula. Over a connected base , this formula says that a line bundle on is uniquely . Here is the needed general-base justification. At any , twist by the degree on the projective-space fibre. Its fibre cohomology is then one-dimensional in degree zero and zero otherwise. Cohomology and base change, in the form [StacksPB] (Tag 0B9S), gives locally a line bundle ; the evaluation map is an isomorphism on every fibre and hence an isomorphism after shrinking. Thus is locally constant, and connectedness makes it constant. The local glue by the evaluation isomorphisms, and uniqueness follows from . This argument applies without noetherian assumptions.
Since is local, . Applying the formula twice gives . On these generators restrict to and , a basis of . Therefore restriction is injective, and any extension of must be . Its degree on the section defined by is zero, so it cannot be ample. Products with projective space give every higher dimension, with injectivity of Picard restriction again supplied by the same formula. No renormalization of has been made. ◻
In this example the failure has a precise geometric cause. Every generically trivial line bundle on is trivial, whereas an -ample bundle must have positive degree on the contracted curve . Hence no -ample bundle can be generically trivial. Even though is semiample, no perturbation within the same generic line bundle on this fixed model can make it ample. Passing to a higher model in the approximation theorem is therefore essential.
The sufficient vertical hypothesis
NAG-900182 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.14.3. (Ample extension along a vertical polarization). Let be as above. If there is an -ample line bundle with , then some positive power of extends to an ample bundle on . This hypothesis holds when is the blowup of a coherent vertical ideal.
Proof. For sufficiently large , is ample by the relative ample twisting theorem, and its generic restriction is now . For a vertical blowup use the relatively ample tautological bundle of the Rees Proj. The ideal becomes the unit ideal on , so this bundle is generically trivial. This is the original proof with its missing hypothesis supplied. ◻
NAG-900183 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.14.4. (Cofinal ample models for metric approximation). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, projective, ample, and a formal model of . There is a projective algebraic -model whose completion dominates and which carries an ample extension of some , . No prescribed algebraic model is required to remain fixed.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the cofinal construction and its ample-model assertion; the proof applies the construction in GM Lemma 2.4.
NAG-900184 Open proof obligation
Corollary 11.14.5. (Finitely many ample generic polarizations). In the setting of Proposition 11.14.4, let be ample line bundles on . One can choose a single projective algebraic model whose completion dominates and on which every has an ample Q-model.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the relative ampleness step for the simultaneous models; the proof uses the GM Proposition 4.13 argument.
Remark 11.14.6 (Effect on the approximation argument). For a nef model metric of an ample , pull its formal model bundle to the completion in Proposition 11.14.4; nefness persists under pullback. Proper formal GAGA algebraizes the pulled-back formal line bundle on , preserving its generic identification. Divide the ample extension by its exponent to obtain an ample Q-model of the same . The rational convex combinations of these two model bundles are ample and their metrics converge uniformly to the original metric. Sufficient powers are generated by global sections, giving the pure Fubini–Study approximation used in Section 11.9. Thus the fixed-model counterexample removes an unnecessary stronger assertion without removing this metric approximation route. Corollary 11.14.5 also supplies the finite-polarization geometric input used in [GM] (Proposition 4.14) and [BGM22] (arXiv v1, Lemma 1.1). The generic Picard relation and the small model-function bound require a further argument, supplied in Proposition 11.14.8 below with explicit formal-domination scope. The reduced-special-fibre input of BGM Lemma 1.1 is separate. No scalar extension or change of valuation is involved.
Preserving the generic Picard relation
There is one further distinction in the proof of [GM] (Proposition 4.14). A numerical equality on the generic fibre does not itself trivialize a line bundle. To obtain a model function from the difference of two model bundles, one needs equality in . The ample generic class permits the following choice, which supplies that stronger relation before rational approximation.
NAG-900185 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.14.7. (Exact ample decomposition and rational relations). Let be projective over a field and line bundles. Suppose has ample numerical class. There are ample line bundles and real numbers such that Moreover can be approximated arbitrarily closely by rational vectors with all and the same exact relation in .
Proof. The inverse image of the numerical ample cone under is open and contains . Choose a rational box containing in its interior and contained in this inverse image. Every vertex gives an ample Q-line bundle ; multiplying by a positive integer gives an ample integral line bundle . Express as the convex combination of the vertices with its positive multilinear barycentric coefficients . Then the required equality in the Picard group, not merely in the numerical quotient, holds with . This is an explicit use of openness of the ample cone.
For the second assertion, map to the finite-dimensional Q-subspace of spanned by these bundles, sending to . Its kernel has a rational basis, and its realification contains . Rational linear combinations of that basis are dense. Choose one sufficiently close to preserve all strict inequalities . Equality in means that, after clearing denominators and killing a possible torsion class, the corresponding integral bundles are isomorphic. This is exactly what is needed for a generic trivialization. ◻
NAG-900186 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.14.8. (Ample correction of a real model class). Let be complete and nontrivially valued and projective. Let be a model -class in the sense of [GM] (4.4–4.6), represented by a finite real combination of model line bundles, with ample generic numerical class. Given a formal model carrying those data, there is a projective algebraic model whose completion dominates it and a rational model function such that is represented by an ample real class on that model. If is semipositive, then for every one can arrange on . This statement concerns GM model classes; it is not a new local theorem about arbitrary CLD currents.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the model-class correction and uniform comparison with the stated positivity prerequisites; the proof uses GM 4.5 and Proposition 4.14.
Section 11.15.1 now supplies the additional morphism-algebraization theorem and strengthens these statements to actual algebraic domination. Section 11.15.2 verifies the separate reduced-fibre input in the published BGM Lemma 1.1.
11.15 Algebraic domination and reduced models
The cofinal constructions of Section 11.14 were formulated for formal completions. To use them in algebraic intersection theory, one must recover actual morphisms of algebraic models. This passage is available over a complete rank-one valuation ring, but it requires the non-Noetherian form of formal GAGA. We give the hypotheses explicitly, then apply the result to the simultaneous ample-model construction. A second, independent step produces a reduced special fibre over an algebraically closed field. Its role is to turn an analytic supnorm into an algebraic lattice norm.
Algebraizing the morphism, not merely the line bundle
Throughout this subsection, is complete and nontrivially valued, with its given real-valued absolute value, and . Fix with . Completion always means -adic completion. We work with proper finitely presented -schemes. No discrete-valuation assumption is made.
NAG-900187 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.15.1. (Formal GAGA for model morphisms). For proper finitely presented -schemes , completion induces a bijection In particular, if they are models of the same proper -scheme , a formal morphism inducing algebraizes uniquely to a morphism inducing .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove formal existence and faithfulness of proper analytification in the stated formal model category; the proof uses the cited FK17 corollaries/proposition.
The distinction between sheaves and morphisms matters here. Formal GAGA for coherent sheaves, [FK17] (I, Theorem 10.1.2), algebraizes a formal line bundle on an already algebraized proper model. Proposition 11.15.1 also algebraizes the map to the prescribed model. In the source, the latter result is obtained by algebraizing the ideal of the graph. This is the additional step needed for domination in the algebraic directed system. All FK locators in this section refer to the fixed arXiv v5 of 28 February 2017.
NAG-900188 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.15.2. (Simultaneous algebraic domination). Let be projective, let be ample, and prescribe finitely many proper finitely presented algebraic -models of . There is a projective model with morphisms extending , on which every has an ample Q-model. All prescribed commutative diagrams among the remain commutative after pullback.
Proof. Choose a common formal refinement of the finitely many completions. Corollary 11.14.5 supplies and the ample Q-models, with a formal map from to each . Proposition 11.15.1 algebraizes each map and identifies its generic restriction. Equality of the two composites in any diagram follows from faithfulness of completion. Pullback of model line bundles along these algebraic maps has the prescribed formal pullback, so the metric identifications used in Section 11.14 are unchanged. ◻
NAG-900189 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.15.3. (The corrected algebraic model-class perturbation). Proposition 11.14.8 holds with algebraic domination of any prescribed proper finitely presented model. In particular, its rational model function can be represented on one algebraic model carrying the pulled-back initial data. If the initial class is semipositive, the bound holds on with the original absolute value.
Proof. Include the prescribed model and all finitely many representatives of the initial class in Corollary 11.15.2. The exact generic Picard relation and the rational perturbation are those of Lemma 11.14.7 and Proposition 11.14.8. The new algebraic maps realize exactly the formal pullbacks used there. Hence their numerical classes, model functions and uniform bounds agree. No additional approximation or limiting argument is required. ◻
These corollaries reconstruct the conclusions needed from GM Propositions 4.11 and 4.14, using a different cofinal model. They do not restore the false fixed-model assertion of GM Lemma 4.12. The counterexample in Section 11.14.1 continues to apply.
The reduced-special-fibre step
For the next theorem assume additionally that is algebraically closed and that is reduced. The closure used below is the integral closure of a model in its given generic fibre; it is not a replacement of by its normalization. This distinction preserves the model’s generic identification even when is singular.
NAG-900190 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.15.4. (Reduced cofinal models with finitely many polarizations). Let be complete, algebraically closed and nontrivially valued. Let be reduced and projective, and ample. Given finitely many algebraic models as in Corollary 11.15.2, there is a projective model dominating all of them, with reduced special fibre and ample Q-models of all .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove finiteness of the normalization and the reduced-special-fibre model step from the stated hypotheses; the argument invokes BE21 and BGM22.
Remark 11.15.5 (The field hypothesis in the reduced fibre theorem). BE Theorem 4.20 also gives finiteness of the integral closure when is discretely valued. It does not assert a reduced special fibre in that case. For an arbitrary densely valued field, even finiteness can fail; [BE21] (Remark 4.21) explains the obstruction from values of spectral norms outside . Thus algebraic domination, proved above over every complete nontrivially valued , and reduced cofinality, asserted here over algebraically closed , have different scopes.
Exact norms and the error that disappears in volume
Let be a line bundle on a projective flat -model , with generic fibre , and put . The lattice is finitely generated and spans the generic space. Its norm and the supnorm of the induced metric are By [BE21] (Lemma 6.3), , with equality when the special fibre is reduced. The equality is also the input of [BGM22] (Lemma 1.3). The next calculation shows why replacing the hypothesis by normality of the model would not justify the same conclusion.
Example 11.15.6. (A normal ramified model with unequal norms). Let be complete discretely valued, a uniformizer, and let be prime to the residue characteristic. Put , where . The polynomial is Eisenstein, is separable and totally ramified, and is the valuation ring of . For any take Then is normal, projective and flat over , and is smooth over . Its special fibre over is not reduced. For and the two norms are Consequently the norms have the same unit ball but are unequal, and
Proof. The special fibre is , whereas is a projective space over the DVR and hence is normal. The monomials form an -basis of , proving the first formula. Write a coefficient as . Distinct nonzero summands have valuations in different cosets of in , when . Thus there is a unique term of least valuation and no cancellation at that valuation: For the standard projective model metric, the supnorm of a homogeneous polynomial equals the largest absolute value of its coefficients. The ultrametric inequality gives the upper bound, and the Gauss point in the chart gives equality. This proves the second formula. Finally, holds for every if and only if every integer is nonnegative. Hence the unit balls agree. Taking gives supnorm and lattice norm , so the norms differ in every dimension. ◻
The discrepancy can be computed on the determinant line as well. Put and . The basis elements in (11.15.1) are orthogonal for both norms. The determinant norm of an orthogonal basis is the product of its norms: the ultrametric determinant inequality gives the lower bound for any decomposition of the same determinant vector, and the chosen basis attains it. Consequently, This grows like , but multiplication by makes it asymptotic to . Thus a persistent, nonzero norm discrepancy can disappear in the volume normalization. The pointwise comparison constant is optimal, as the section shows. These exact calculations illustrate the two different scales in Proposition 11.15.8.
The absolute value on in this example is the extension of the one on : . Renormalizing the valuation of so that has value would multiply its restriction to by and would change the problem. Also, equality of unit balls determines a norm when is dense, by arbitrarily close scalar rescaling; it need not do so over a discretely valued field. This is why a lattice description by itself does not establish an isometry.
This failure of isometry does not refute the effectivity criterion for vertical Cartier divisors on normal models. GM Remark 4.10 gives that criterion without a reduced-special-fibre assumption. In the explicit model above, a vertical divisor is effective exactly when , and its model function is , with the same sign. Effectivity detects the unit-ball inequality; an isometry determines every radius.
Example 11.15.7. (Strict norm inequality after wild scalar extension). Let be a finite extension of containing a primitive th root of unity , let be a uniformizer, and put with . Then is cyclic of degree . For and the trivial metric, the original supnorm is . On , the scalar extension of this norm is strictly larger than the supnorm of the pulled-back metric. More precisely, The same discrepancy occurs for sections of on regarded as a -scheme, in every dimension and every . This is an explicit instance of the obstruction in [BE21] (Lemma 6.2), not a counterexample to that lemma.
Proof. Eisenstein’s criterion gives , and the automorphisms are , . The distinct valuation classes of make this an orthogonal -basis of the normed space . Its scalar-extended norm, with the left tensor factor as coefficient field, is therefore For all displayed terms have norm . On the other hand, the splitting isomorphism sends to , by the finite geometric sum . The pulled-back metric has supnorm equal to the maximum of the component norms, so its value on is . For projective space, take the section . The monomial basis together with the orthogonal basis of gives the same tensor norm, and the Gauss point on the first split component gives the same supnorm. All norms use the unique extension of the original absolute value. ◻
NAG-900191 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.15.8. (Uniform norm comparison and relative volume). Let be geometrically reduced and projective over complete nontrivially valued , let be ample, and let be integral models of inducing metrics . Put , and . There are , independent of , such that With on the determinant line, one has If , the difference multiplied by tends to zero. Thus replacing supnorms by these lattice norms preserves relative volume, although it need not preserve any individual norm.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the uniform bound and determinant-to-volume limit; BE21 Theorem 6.4 and Lemma 9.17 are used.
There is a further distinction in the scalar-extension step. For a complete extension , the pulled-back metric has the same supnorm on sections originally defined over . On all of , however, its supnorm is only bounded above by the scalar extension of the original norm in general; see [BE21] (Lemmas 6.1 and 6.2). Equality on the original sections is sufficient in the comparison proof. One must not replace it by an unproved isometry on the enlarged vector space. None of these model and norm results identifies an arbitrary positive CLD current with a nef metric, or establishes an unrestricted Bedford–Taylor product.
Geometric reducedness also has a concrete role in the extension step. Over , put with . The scheme is reduced over , but . The nonzero element has zero analytic sup-seminorm after extension, whereas its scalar-extended vector-space norm is positive. Thus the proof cannot replace geometric reducedness by reducedness when it requires a norm on every extended section space. This calculation is not a counterexample to BE Theorem 6.4 under its stated hypotheses.
11.16 An analytic realization of the fixed-chart obstruction
Example 11.10.9 separated relative convexity from ambient convex extension on an abstract fan. We now realize that fan by analytic units. The same chart also supports an original CLD smooth psh function with no ambient convex extension, even locally at its central vertex. This gives a concrete test for a proposed smooth-to-PL argument: it must allow relative convexity or a change of chart. It does not contradict such a comparison when these choices are allowed.
Four punctures and two tropical coordinates
Let be complete and nontrivially valued, with . On use the analytic units and , and write The unit-disc Gauss point belongs to and maps to the origin. No extension of is made.
NAG-900192 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.16.1. (The fan and its analytic refinement). The image of is the support of the fan in Example 11.10.9: the four rays generated by . The refinement by the three units has image the four rays generated by . Under one has . The relative PL function of that example pulls back to . Thus its previously abstract convex presentation after refinement is realized by analytic units.
Proof. If , the ultrametric inequality gives , so with . If , both equal , so with . If , both . They cannot both be strictly smaller than , because their difference is and . Thus the image lies on a nonnegative coordinate ray or at the origin. These arguments apply to the multiplicative seminorm of every Berkovich point.
Conversely, the Gauss points of discs centered at with radius , and of discs centered at with radius , realize every point on the four rays. Arbitrary positive real radii are allowed for Berkovich points; no value-group enlargement is needed. The same case distinction gives the three-coordinate image and the identity involving . On the ray over the PL function is , and it is zero on the other rays, hence equals . The orders of at the four punctures are , explaining the primitive ray weights and their balancing identity. ◻
NAG-900193 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.16.2. (A smooth barrier does not remove the first-order obstruction). Let denote the relative PL function of Example 11.10.9, so and . For every ambient function near the origin, still has no ambient convex extension near the origin. If on the relevant segments, its midpoint convexity defect is at least .
Proof. Put and . The affine part of the Taylor expansion cancels in . The remainder is bounded below by . Adding the exact defect of gives the assertion, which is positive for all sufficiently small . Thus even an arbitrarily large fixed quadratic barrier cannot correct this first-order failure. ◻
For a convex smooth , the pullback is nevertheless psh: the first summand is a locally uniform limit of smooth convex functions of the pluriharmonic unit logarithm , and the second is an ambient convex pullback. The lemma therefore concerns a false extension shortcut even inside a positive class. It does not obstruct relative PL approximation or a change of analytic presentation.
A smooth psh function that is not ambient convex in this chart
NAG-900194 Proof review pending
Example 11.16.3. (A fixed-chart obstruction already for smooth psh functions). The function on is original CLD smooth and psh on all original tests. Nevertheless, the function restricted to has no ambient convex extension on any convex open neighbourhood of the origin. Moreover, on any subset containing with , every restriction of an ambient convex function satisfies Every ordinary open neighbourhood of has a tropical image containing such a triple for some . Consequently a fixed-chart uniform approximation by ambient convex functions fails on every such neighbourhood.
Proof. Smoothness follows because are logarithms of analytic units and multiplication is a smooth operation. The case distinction in Proposition 11.16.1 gives the additional identity The real function is convex: its derivative is for and for , with common value zero at the origin. Choose smooth convex regularizations converging uniformly on compact real intervals to . The function is original smooth and pluriharmonic, since is a unit. Therefore For every compactly supported original CLD test, is bounded on its support, so uniformly there. Passing to curvature currents preserves positivity on every original positive test. This proves psh without asserting that the ambient polynomial is convex. The relative function has touching affine lower supports: zero at the vertex and a tangent affine function along a ray away from the vertex.
Suppose the maximum error on the three points is . Since is the midpoint of and , convexity gives This proves (11.16.1) and rules out an exact extension. The three Gauss-point paths toward are continuous and have common limit as their radii tend to . An ordinary neighbourhood of therefore contains initial segments of all three paths, giving the asserted triple for small . The argument also rules out uniform convergence on a fixed compact set containing the corresponding three analytic points. ◻
NAG-900195 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.16.4. (The obstruction in every positive dimension). For every , the preceding smooth psh example occurs on an ordinary open subset of the integral projective variety . In the product moment chart the same fixed-chart obstruction persists, while a different analytic presentation makes the function ambient convex.
Proof. Use , pull back from its first factor, and take the chart consisting of and the torus coordinates. The smooth convex approximations still have positive original curvature, so their locally uniform limit is psh. Fix the remaining tropical coordinates to zero. Restricting any proposed ambient convex extension to that affine slice contradicts (11.16.1). On the other hand, the unit alone presents the function as the pullback of the convex real function . The coefficient-controlled approximation of Section 11.12.4 can be applied to this latter presentation on bounded tropical images. ◻
The example closes the analytic-realization question left by the earlier fan calculation, but not the general chart-selection problem. It proves failure of one fixed-chart shortcut, together with an explicit successful change of analytic presentation in the example itself. In particular, it is not a counterexample to full Wu Theorem A.3, and it does not identify the general original smooth psh class with a prescribed tropical generator class.
For uniform approximation, the fixed-domain qualification is essential: the error bound concerns ambient convex functions defined at the three fixed points, or locally convex functions on one fixed ambient neighbourhood containing a convex ball around the origin. It does not rule out approximants whose ambient neighbourhoods shrink with the index, nor approximants defined only by relative supports on the tropical image.
Removing the residue-characteristic restriction
The four rational punctures above require so that their residue directions remain distinct. That restriction can be removed by replacing one rational puncture with the zero locus of a polynomial whose reduction avoids both and . The resulting function and its convex alternative presentation are still defined over the original field.
NAG-900196 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.16.5. (A fixed-chart smooth psh obstruction over every nontrivial field). Let be any complete nontrivially valued non-Archimedean field, with its fixed absolute value. Set Then is original smooth psh on , but it has no ambient convex presentation in the fixed chart near the unit-disc Gauss point. The quantitative bound (11.16.1) still holds. The example extends to an ordinary open subset of for every . In particular, residue characteristics and are included.
Proof. Both and are units on . If , then , giving . If , then and , giving . If , put and note the exact identity . The numbers are at most and cannot both be smaller than . Since in this case, at least one of is zero. Therefore This function is convex, with derivatives for and for . The same convex regularization argument as above proves positivity against all original compactly supported tests. The formula proves original smoothness.
The diagonal and horizontal ray segments at the origin are realized by Gauss points of small discs around and . To exhibit the vertical segment, choose a root of in a finite extension , endowed with the unique extended absolute value. Both roots have absolute value , and implies . Gauss points of -discs centered at with radii and close to therefore have , while approaches as . More precisely, factor over a finite splitting extension. On such a disc, where roots are counted with multiplicity. For sufficiently close to , this is with , so it realizes a whole vertical interval. Restricting these multiplicative seminorms to gives actual points of tending to its unit-disc Gauss point. This use of an auxiliary field constructs points over ; the function, the positivity proof and the approximation question have not been base-changed, and no current-descent assertion is used.
Every ordinary neighbourhood of that Gauss point consequently contains analytic points with tropical coordinates for small . Their function values are , giving the same midpoint obstruction and error bound. The product construction of Corollary 11.16.4 gives every positive dimension. Repeated roots of cause no difficulty: their multiplicities are already included in the displayed Gauss-norm formula. ◻
11.17 Relative approximation in a chart without convex extension
The obstruction in Section 11.16 concerns ambient convex functions. It leaves open whether relative convex PL functions suffice on the very same chart. We answer this question for the explicit family constructed there, including a perturbation with a uniform positive tangential Hessian. The proof keeps the value group visible: all affine slopes of the approximants are rational, and all constants belong to . It gives a worked comparison in every positive dimension, rather than the general converse in Wu’s Theorem A.3.
The source distinction behind the construction is already important for smooth functions. Gubler–Künnemann retain the smooth facewise-convexity criterion in [GK19] (Remark 3.2), while their Example 3.3 disproves its extension to arbitrary continuous functions; see Example 11.1.4. For a smooth representative on a locally finite complex, Lemma 11.8.4 supplies a centred affine lower support at each point. Neither statement supplies an ambient convex extension, nor a lower bound on the contact radius independent of the point. The following calculation separates all three assertions.
Tangential positivity and the size of a contact neighbourhood
Fix a complete nontrivially valued field with its given absolute value. Use the all-field construction of Theorem 11.16.5: Here are the torus coordinates. The image is , where is the union of the four rays generated by . The unit-disc Gauss point in the first factor, together with in the other factors, gives a point with tropical image zero.
NAG-900197 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.17.1. (Positive tangential Hessian without ambient convex extension). Let , and put Then is original CLD smooth and psh. For each maximal face of and each vector tangent to , Nevertheless, has no ambient convex extension near zero. If an ambient convex function is defined on a convex set containing then Every ordinary neighbourhood of contains analytic points realizing such triples for all sufficiently small . Thus ambient convex approximation in this chart cannot converge uniformly on any fixed such neighbourhood.
Proof. Theorem 11.16.5 proves that is original smooth psh, by expressing it as the convex function of and using smooth regularization. The added quadratic is an ambient smooth convex function of unit logarithms. Its pullback is smooth psh, so their sum is psh on all original CLD tests. No pullback operation on arbitrary currents is involved.
Write a tangent vector as , where is a generator of one of the four rays. In each case , and which proves (11.17.2). This is the precise tangential positivity assertion used here; it is not a claim about every possible convention for strict psh.
Since , the values of give the midpoint defect If the error at all three points is at most , convexity of bounds this defect above by . This proves (11.17.3). The Gauss-point paths in Theorem 11.16.5, with , converge to and realize the three rays in question. Fixing one sufficiently small in a proposed approximation domain gives a positive error lower bound independent of the approximant. ◻
The threshold in this quadratic family is exact: the ambient Hessian has eigenvalues , , and in the remaining directions. Thus itself is ambient convex when . A positive lower bound on its restrictions to face tangent spaces is therefore strictly weaker than ambient convexity.
NAG-900198 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.17.2. (Monomial refinements and nonuniform contact radii). Replacing or augmenting the coordinates of only by constants times monomials in its original units does not remove the ambient convex obstruction. Also, any affine lower support for at , valid on a relative ball , must satisfy . In particular, the contact radii cannot have a positive uniform lower bound as .
Proof. A monomial change has tropical form , with an integral matrix and . It preserves the midpoint relation of the three points. The composition of an ambient convex function with this affine map is convex on the inverse image of its convex domain, so the preceding defect argument applies unchanged. Injectivity of is unnecessary. For the second assertion, if , both belong to the ball. An affine lower support with equality at would give contrary to the positive defect. ◻
There is no conflict with Lemma 11.8.4: that lemma fixes the contact point, and its radius is allowed to depend on the point. Nor does this corollary require a chart change for relative PL approximation. The construction below takes place in the original chart. New analytic units can change the ambient problem: the unit used above is not a monomial in and , even after allowing a nonzero integral power of . Indeed, in , orders at force , orders at a zero of force , and the order at then forces .
An explicit decreasing approximation with controlled coefficients
The general ambient density argument in Section 11.12.4 can be made particularly explicit for the positive-part square. We give the formula because it allows composition with relative PL functions without introducing constants outside the value group.
NAG-900199 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.17.3. (Rational PL approximation of the positive-part square). Let be a nonzero additive subgroup, fix and , and put . There are nonnegative, nondecreasing, convex PL functions , with rational slopes and constants in , such that on The decrease in is asserted on this fixed interval, not on all of .
Proof. Choose an integer with , and set and . For , put The slopes are rational and nonnegative. The rounded constants are in ; in particular we have not assumed that squares of value-group elements remain in that group. The branch is zero. Every other branch lies below the tangent line of at , and hence below on . For , select with . The two errors satisfy For , . Thus on . To obtain decrease without requiring the supporting lines to be nested, define Both and every affine constant of belong to . On the fixed interval, These inequalities prove the claim. Nonnegativity and monotonicity as functions of follow from the zero branch, the positive shift, and the nonnegative slopes. ◻
NAG-900200 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.17.4. (Composition with relative PL supports). Let be a subset of a real vector space. Suppose that the continuous functions have local affine lower supports and finite-selection PL presentations with rational slopes and constants in . For , the functions have the same two properties. On all of , they decrease uniformly to , with error at most . If is the image of a chart of analytic units over and , their pullbacks are actual -PL functions by Proposition 11.11.5, on its good strictly analytic pure-dimensional domain. They are classically psh by Theorem 11.11.2, and have nef residues by Theorem 11.11.6.
Proof. Fix and an affine lower support for at . Choose an active affine branch of at . Since , near one has with equality at . Summing the resulting affine lower supports proves the support assertion. Finite selections remain finite after composition with a finite maximum and after a finite sum. Rational coefficients remain rational, and is closed under rational multiplication and addition. The uniform estimate and the decrease follow term by term from Lemma 11.17.3. The analytic conclusions use the three cited results with exactly these coefficient and support hypotheses; no ambient convex extension is required. ◻
NAG-900201 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.17.5. (Same-chart relative approximation of the obstructed family). In (11.17.1), assume also . For every , on the single ordinary open set there is a decreasing sequence of relative convex rational PL functions in the original chart, with constants in , whose pullbacks converge uniformly to . These pullbacks are actual -PL functions with nef residues. No extension of the base field and no change of the analytic chart are needed.
Proof. On , define The function has local affine lower supports: at the vertex, zero is a support; away from it a sufficiently small relative neighbourhood lies on one ray, where is affine. The same argument applies on , since is independent of . The function is ambient convex. Both have rational finite-selection PL presentations with zero constants. Evaluating on the four rays gives Indeed, the values of are on with , on with , and on both nonnegative coordinate rays.
Choose , which is possible because the valuation is nontrivial, and use the functions of Lemma 11.17.3. On the fixed tropical image of , put Every argument of lies in . The functions are ambient convex rational PL. Proposition 11.17.4 therefore applies to all summands, and (11.17.5) identifies the limit as . More precisely, throughout , The set is an ordinary open subset of the smooth analytification , hence good, strictly analytic, and pure-dimensional. The coefficient, classical psh and nef-residue conclusions of Proposition 11.17.4 apply on . All constants were constructed inside the original ; the use of its divisible hull means rational model data, not a change of the absolute value or an implicit field extension. ◻
This example gives both the failed ambient approximation and a successful relative approximation on the same fixed neighbourhood. The argument extends beyond squares. The extra point in the next statement is to preserve nonnegative slopes when rationalizing supporting hyperplanes: that sign is what makes composition preserve relative lower supports.
NAG-900202 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.17.6. (Monotone convex composition in any dimension). Let satisfy the hypotheses of Proposition 11.17.4. Let be a finite convex function on a convex open neighbourhood of , nondecreasing in each coordinate there. For every there are finite maxima of affine functions with slopes in and constants in such that Consequently are coefficient-compatible relative PL functions decreasing uniformly to on the same set . The analytic PL, classical psh and nef-residue conclusions of Proposition 11.17.4 apply to their pullbacks.
Proof. Put and . As in Proposition 11.12.9, the supporting-hyperplane theorem supplies an affine minorant touching at each . All coordinates of are nonnegative: if , the support inequality at for small would contradict the assumed monotonicity of . This uses the open neighbourhood of , including at its boundary.
The sets where cover . By continuity and compactness, finitely many of these supports suffice. For each selected pair , choose with and , and set . On , Let be the maximum of the finitely many resulting affine functions. Then on . Set . Since , This proves (11.17.8). At a point of , choose local affine lower supports for the and an active affine branch of at . The function is a local affine lower support for , because every . Finite selections and the coefficient conditions are preserved just as in Proposition 11.17.4. ◻
The same construction is compatible with a decreasing tuple. More precisely, suppose each has the stated coefficient-compatible PL and support presentations and . The functions depend only on , not on these presentations. Hence The error estimate and continuity of identify the pointwise limit as . Each term is still a relative rational PL function on the same . Uniform convergence of the tuple gives uniform convergence of these composites by uniform continuity on ; pointwise convergence alone is not upgraded to uniform convergence. This is a finite-tuple closure statement for the displayed generator class, not closure under arbitrary successive approximation stages.
NAG-900203 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.17.7. (Original smooth approximation of these composites). Let be integral projective of positive dimension over a complete nontrivially valued . Suppose an ordinary open carries a unit chart and a bounded tuple as in Proposition 11.17.6. Then, near each point of , the pullback of is a decreasing limit of original smooth psh functions on one ordinary neighbourhood, uniformly on compact subsets.
Proof. The proposition supplies a decreasing sequence of actual Q-PL functions with relative supports on all of . Apply Corollary 11.11.7. Its neighbourhood is fixed before the individual extension and smoothing steps. The endpoint is continuous, so the compact-uniform conclusion follows from the last assertion of that corollary. ◻
These results combine the supporting-hyperplane argument of Section 11.12.4, sign-preserving rational approximation and the previously established relative-support bridge. They are recorded as reconstructions and consequences of those inputs, not as a claim of a new general regularization theorem. In particular, we have not shown that every smooth facewise-convex function admits such a finite monotone-convex composition presentation. Section 11.22 supplies coefficient-controlled density on any fixed compact image for continuous relatively supported inputs, without requiring such a composition presentation. The remaining reverse-comparison step concerns arbitrary families with different charts and their common analytic domain. The missing full text of the mixed-calculus Theorem 6.13 is not an input to any argument in this section.
11.18 Relative coefficient approximation on a finite polytopal complex
Section 11.12.7 already proves coefficient-compatible decreasing approximation for homogeneous relative convex functions on a fixed rational fan. Its proof approximates the function and all supporting covectors simultaneously inside a rational system. The obstruction following it shows why an arbitrary nonhomogeneous complex cannot be substituted without checking its affine constants. Here we extend that argument to finite polytopal complexes whose vertices share one value-group scale.
The source convention matters. In [APW26] (Section 2.1), a rational halfspace has an integral normal but an arbitrary real intercept; Section 2.1.6 assumes rational simplicial polyhedral structures in that sense. This does not impose the value-group condition on the vertices used below. The two qualifications must therefore be checked separately when importing PL approximants.
The affine support system
NAG-900204 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.18.1. (Rational approximation with one geometric scale). Let be a nonzero additive subgroup, and fix . Let be a finite polytopal complex in such that every vertex belongs to . Let be continuous, affine on each cell, and admit a relative affine lower support near every point. Then there are continuous functions on , affine on the same cells with rational slopes and constants in , admitting relative affine lower supports and satisfying Here polytopal means that the cells are compact polytopes. In particular, the hypothesis on the vertices holds for a finite -polytopal complex when . The conclusion does not require itself to be discrete if the displayed one-scale hypothesis holds.
Proof. First write and . This is a change of real coordinates and function units for the calculation; the absolute value on any analytic base field remains unchanged. The scaled complex has rational vertices. An affine function with rational coefficients in pulls back, after multiplication by , to a function with rational slopes and -constants in . It therefore suffices to approximate the function and its supports with rational coefficients in the scaled coordinates.
Write the affine expression on a cell as . For every face , introduce an affine support variable . The conditions are The first line is continuity. To justify the support conditions, choose . A touching affine lower support agrees with on the affine span of , since their affine difference has a local minimum of zero there. For , apply the support inequality at for small . Linearity on and equality at extend the inequality to all of . Testing it on vertices is sufficient. Conversely, the last two lines give a lower support on every cell containing . A small neighbourhood of avoids the other cells: the complex is finite, and a cell containing a point in contains . Thus the system is equivalent to the required local relative supports.
All vertices are rational in the scaled coordinates, so (11.18.2) is a finite homogeneous rational linear system in the combined tuple . Use the rational-density argument already given in Section 11.12.7: impose the active inequalities as equalities, choose a rational basis of the resulting nullspace, and approximate the tuple within that subspace. The inactive inequalities remain strict for sufficiently close approximations. This preserves both continuity and the existence of supports, rather than merely approximating the cellwise formulas.
Return to the -coordinates and choose the approximation so that on . This is possible by controlling the error at the finitely many vertices: on each cell the difference is affine, and its absolute value is bounded by the largest vertex error. Put . Constants still belong to , and Shifting the supports by preserves contact. This proves (11.18.1). For the discrete value-group case, a vertex of a -polytope is the solution of a full-rank rational linear system with right-hand side in , so its coordinates lie in . ◻
On an ordinary unit chart whose image is contained in , the pullbacks of are actual Q-PL functions by Proposition 11.11.5, provided the analytic space is good, strictly analytic and pure-dimensional over nontrivially valued , and . Their supports give nef residues by Theorem 11.11.6. In the integral projective setting, Corollary 11.11.7 gives an original smooth decreasing approximation near every point on one ordinary neighbourhood. These are consequences of the stated analytic inputs, not a new current-positivity criterion.
The compactness in the theorem serves to control the error by finitely many vertex values. It need not restrict the original tropical image to a compact polytope. A single truncation gives the following local version; the translation also clarifies which affine constants are allowed.
NAG-900205 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.18.2. (Translation and one fixed truncation). Let be a finite polyhedral complex in . Suppose that there are and such that every cell is given by rational affine inequalities in the coordinates ; both normals and intercepts are rational in these coordinates. Let be continuous, affine on each cell, and have local relative affine lower supports. For every compact , there is an integer such that and admits a decreasing uniform approximation with the bound in (11.18.1), by continuous functions affine on each , with rational slopes, -constants and local relative affine lower supports. The set is fixed for the whole sequence.
Proof. Choose so that lies in the interior of the displayed cube. Intersect the scaled complex with and include all faces. This is a finite rational polytopal complex. Apply Theorem 11.18.1 to , with subgroup and scale . Its hypotheses concern real polyhedra, so this use of makes no change to an analytic value group. A rational affine branch gives, after multiplying by and returning to , Its slope is rational and its constant belongs to . The error is multiplied by ; order and relative supports are preserved. Restrict to . Every original cell meets the closed cube in a cell of the truncated complex, so the approximants remain affine on . No extension beyond this fixed truncation is asserted. ◻
In particular, this applies to finite -polyhedral complexes over a discrete nontrivial value group , even when the cells are unbounded or have lineality. On a unit chart the inverse image of the open cube is an ordinary open set, so the truncation does not force the analytic domain to vary with the approximation index.
Two distinct restrictions on a fixed subdivision
Example 11.18.3. (Irrational directions). In , put , and subdivide the plane into , and their common face. The convex function is linear on these cones. Every continuous function which is affine with rational slopes on these same two cones is globally affine. Thus
Proof. Continuity makes the branch difference for some real . Both coordinates of the slope difference are rational, so and are rational; hence . The midpoint defect of at the three displayed points has absolute value , whereas an affine function has zero defect. Three errors bounded by change this defect by at most , giving . ◻
This subdivision is not rational in the APW convention, so the example does not contradict a statement under that convention. The next example has rational directions and isolates the separate intercept condition.
Example 11.18.4. (An intercept outside the value-group hull). Suppose , and choose . On , put . Every continuous function that is affine with rational slopes and -constants on each of the same halfspaces and is globally affine. For , its uniform error from at is at least .
Proof. The branch difference vanishes on , so it is with . If , its constant would force . Thus the branches agree. The midpoint defect of has absolute value , giving the error bound as before. ◻
Both examples allow rational approximation when the subdivision varies: approximate by rational numbers in the first, and by elements of in the second. On bounded sets the errors tend uniformly to zero; the error shifts of Proposition 11.12.9 enforce decrease. Neither example refutes unrestricted rational approximation. They exclude only freezing the displayed cells while rounding their coefficients. The earlier nonhomogeneous-complex obstruction in Section 11.12.7 addresses a further issue: vertices may belong to a higher-rank without sharing the one scale required in Theorem 11.18.1.
The remaining source-comparison task is therefore precise. The real PL output must be replaced by coefficient-compatible relative PL functions on one fixed domain, while allowing controlled changes of subdivision if its vertices or normals fail these conditions. Theorems for an already rational fan or for a one-scale complex do not establish that replacement for arbitrary smooth inputs. No full Wu Theorem A.3, CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11 or mixed-calculus comparison is inferred here.
11.19 Coefficient closure and relative supports
The one-scale hypothesis of Section 11.18 makes the entire support system rational. With several independent value-group scales, continuity alone may already prevent rational approximation. We first describe that obstruction exactly. We then separate it from the additional requirement of relative convexity, and give a finite strict-support condition under which no further obstruction occurs. All approximations use the same compact support; each statement specifies whether its subdivision is fixed or allowed to vary.
Continuity and the coefficient space
Fix a nonzero additive subgroup and put . Let be a nonempty finite complex of compact polytopes in , with support . Write for the real vector space of continuous functions on that are affine on each cell. Its uniform norm is the maximum of the absolute values at the finitely many vertices. Define the rational vector space The formula is required for every cell, but its ambient extension need not be unique. Let denote the uniform closure of in . This is a real vector subspace: rational scalar multiplication extends to real scalar multiplication by taking limits. The following description makes this closure explicit when the vertices have value-group coordinates.
NAG-900206 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.19.1. (Continuity closure). Suppose that is connected and every vertex of lies in . There is a rational linear subspace and a real linear map such that The construction below uses only the vertex coordinates and continuity equations. For disconnected , apply it to each connected component with a separate constant.
Proof. Let be the rational span of all vertex coordinates, enlarged by one nonzero element of if necessary. Choose a rational basis of . Introduce one ambient slope variable for each nonempty cell. The graph joining two cells with nonempty intersection is connected: otherwise the corresponding finite compact unions would disconnect . Choose a root cell , a spanning tree and, for each edge , a vertex of the intersection. Along the rooted tree define Continuity at the remaining intersection vertices requires Each is a rational linear form. Let be their common kernel, and set For , the expressions agree at every intersection vertex, hence on every intersection; thus is well-defined. If is rational and , all belong to . This proves one inclusion in the first equality of (11.19.1). Conversely, choose rational ambient slopes and value-group constants for . Continuity along the tree forces . In (11.19.2), all are rational. The rational independence of the therefore forces each to vanish, so .
The rational points of are dense in , and is dense in , since it contains for some . The image of their product is therefore dense in . This image space is finite-dimensional and hence closed in . These facts prove the second equality. For disconnected , there are only finitely many components, and their function spaces form a finite product. ◻
Remark 11.19.2. The criterion for a target is the existence of a representation with . On a lower-dimensional cell it is not legitimate to test an arbitrary ambient extension and declare failure. Nor does the construction claim an effective procedure for identifying rational relations among arbitrary unspecified real numbers. When all vertices lie in , one can take , and the split equations are exactly the original continuity equations. Then , consistently with Theorem 11.18.1. With several scales the equality can fail, as the rectangle calculation in Section 11.12.7 shows.
The relative-support cone
Let consist of functions admitting an affine lower support in the relative topology of near every point, with equality at that point. The support is allowed to depend on the point. This is the local support condition of Section 11.18; it is not ambient convexity on a neighbourhood of .
NAG-900207 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.19.3. (Finite support inequalities). The set is a closed convex polyhedral cone in , and contains all constants with either sign. Its defining real coefficients need not be rational. More precisely, if and only if for every nonempty face there is an affine function satisfying
Proof. Choose . A lower support at agrees with on , since their affine difference has a local minimum there. For any , apply the local inequality at and divide by ; this extends it to . Conversely, (11.19.3) gives a support on each coface of , and a sufficiently small neighbourhood of meets no other cells. This proves the equivalence.
The system is finite and homogeneous linear in the vertex values and support coefficients. Eliminating the latter preserves polyhedrality. For completeness, to eliminate a variable , write each inequality as . Keep the inequalities with , and require each lower bound from to be no larger than each upper bound from . If one type is absent there is no additional restriction. Equalities may be written as pairs of inequalities. Repeating this elimination gives finitely many weak linear inequalities in the vertex values alone, proving closedness as well. Addition, nonnegative scaling and constant shifts preserve the support condition directly. ◻
Closedness alone does not justify intersecting with a dense rational class. For instance, the ray is a closed real polyhedral cone whose intersection with is only the origin. This is a warning about a linear-algebra inference, not a tropical or analytic counterexample. The next statement gives the exact replacement.
NAG-900208 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.19.4. (Closure of admissible rational functions). For any finite compact polytopal complex, set Then If belongs to this set and , there are such that
Proof. Both and are closed, so the left side of (11.19.4) is contained in the right side. To prove density, choose a real basis of from . Its positive cone lies in and has nonempty interior in . In particular, has a ball contained in . For and , Approximate the coordinates of in the basis by rational numbers so closely that the resulting function lies in this ball. It belongs to , since that is a rational vector space, and it belongs to by the ball inclusion. Letting and the coordinate errors tend to zero proves density. The argument does not require the rational coordinates to be nonnegative.
Choose in this intersection with and put . The added constant belongs to , and shifting every support by it preserves contact. Thus and . This proves (11.19.5). ◻
This is an exact closure formula, but not by itself an effective description of . A useful finite certificate is a list of admissible rational functions whose real span contains the target . The finite support system checks admissibility, and the theorem then gives decreasing approximation. In general we have only ; equality requires an argument. The proof is an elementary combination of finite-dimensional convexity and rational approximation, and no priority claim is made for that combination.
A strict-support certificate
We now give a geometric sufficient condition for this equality. Say that has strict face supports if, for every nonempty face , there is an affine agreeing with on and satisfying This is a finite condition on a specified complex. It is not a definition of strict CLD plurisubharmonicity. For a maximal face the inequalities are vacuous.
NAG-900209 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.19.5. (Strict supports remove the positivity obstruction). If has strict face supports, then is an interior point of in , and Consequently every target in the latter intersection has the decreasing approximants of (11.19.5).
Proof. For each , choose a linear extension map from affine functions on to affine functions on . Such a map exists by extending affine coordinates, and all the relevant spaces are finite-dimensional. If , replace by . It agrees with on . At the finitely many other incident vertices the change in the support gap is The absolute values of these expressions are bounded by for a fixed finite . The finitely many strict gaps in (11.19.6) have a positive minimum. For sufficiently small , all remain positive, so Lemma 11.19.3 gives . If there are no strict gaps to test, the same conclusion holds for every . This proves interiority.
For , the points are interior to relative to . The density of in gives admissible rational approximants tending to , exactly as in Theorem 11.19.4. Moreover, a sufficiently small ball about in is contained in the closure of the admissible class, hence in . A linear subspace containing such a ball is all of . This proves both equalities and the decreasing conclusion. ◻
The hypothesis has an explicit source of examples, valid in arbitrary dimension and without a one-scale restriction. The subdivision must be the one specified below; adding arbitrary faces can destroy the strict certificate.
NAG-900210 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.19.6. (Subdivisions of a finite rational maximum). Let be a full-dimensional compact polytope given by , where the have rational slopes and constants in . Let Form the complex of all nonempty regions and all their faces. On any nonempty subcomplex of this complex, belongs to and has strict face supports. Every vertex of lies in . Thus the continuity criterion of Theorem 11.19.1, component by component, is necessary and sufficient for a relatively supported to admit the approximants (11.19.5).
Proof. The regions form a polyhedral complex: is the equality face for on , and similarly on . All defining normals are rational and constants belong to . At a vertex, a full-rank set of active equations has a rational inverse matrix, so the coordinates belong to . This argument also applies to lower-dimensional regions.
Fix a face , choose , and set and . Define On , both and every in this sum are nonnegative. Their sum vanishes precisely where all the indicated maximum branches and boundary constraints are active. This set is exactly : inside any with , these are all the constraints active at , hence they define the minimal face containing . Consequently on and at every point of . Formula (11.19.7) supplies the required strict face supports, even after restricting to a subcomplex. The function is rational affine on each cell. Proposition 11.19.5 and Theorem 11.19.1 finish the proof. ◻
One fixed refinement
A complex need not itself have strict face supports. Refinement gives a precise remedy when its cells have rational normals and value-group constants. The continuity obstruction, however, survives every fixed refinement of the kind considered here.
NAG-900211 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.19.7. (Continuity closure under a fixed refinement). Let be a finite compact polytopal refinement of with the same support: each refined cell lies in a coarse cell, and each coarse cell is a union of refined cells. Suppose that every cell of has rational tangent space, and all vertices of both complexes belong to . Under the natural inclusion ,
Proof. Restriction to the refined cells gives , hence one inclusion. For the reverse inclusion, use Theorem 11.19.1 on , component by component, to represent by slope parameters and root constants. For each coarse cell , take all refined cells of dimension . They cover : their finite closed union contains the relative interior densely and therefore contains its closure. Choose a rational basis for the tangent space of . Being affine on implies Conversely, these equations, together with continuity, force affinity on . Subtract an ambient affine function with slope ; the remainder is constant on every full-dimensional refined cell. The intersection graph of these cells is connected because they cover the connected compact polytope , so their constants agree.
Equations (11.19.9) are rational linear equations in the slope parameters. Their intersection with is therefore a rational linear subspace containing the chosen representative of . Approximate within that subspace by rational parameters, and approximate each root constant in . The resulting functions converge uniformly to , belong to , and are affine on every coarse cell. On a coarse cell their expression agrees with that of any full-dimensional refined cell, so it has rational ambient slope and constant in . They thus belong to , proving (11.19.8). Zero-dimensional coarse cells require no slope equation. ◻
NAG-900212 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.19.8. (Relative approximation after one fixed refinement). Suppose each cell of the finite compact complex is given by finitely many affine weak inequalities with rational slopes and constants in . There is a finite compact refinement , depending only on , such that for every the following are equivalent:
.
is a uniform limit of functions in .
has approximants in that class satisfying (11.19.5).
Proof. List all affine functions occurring in inequalities for all cells, writing equalities as two inequalities. Choose a cube containing in its interior, with and a sufficiently large integer. On this cube set The regions of this maximum are exactly the nonempty sign regions in : equality in the maximum requires equality in each nonnegative term . Include their faces. Each original cell is a union of these arrangement cells, since its defining inequalities occur in the list. Take the subcomplex consisting of arrangement cells contained in ; call it . It refines every original cell and has the same support. All its vertices lie in , and Proposition 11.19.6 supplies strict face supports for .
The relative-support condition depends on the function and the support , not on a chosen subdivision. Thus also belongs to . If (1) holds, restriction gives , and Proposition 11.19.5 proves (3). Clearly (3) implies (2). Finally (2) gives , which is by Lemma 11.19.7. Its rational-tangent hypothesis holds because the original defining normals are rational. ◻
In particular, a fixed rational value-group refinement can remove the extra support obstruction, but cannot remove the continuity obstruction for a target affine on the old cells. This does not exclude progressively changing subdivisions: their arithmetic continuity equations also change. The following construction shows that the distinction is substantive, even when the target is already PL.
Example 11.19.9. (Moving subdivisions resolve the rectangle test). Use the rectangle and function of Example 11.12.17, with and . Thus , , and on the top and right edges. Put Define on the left, top and right edges, and on the bottom edge set The two branches meet at . Both have rational slopes and constants in . Their maximum equals at and at , so is continuous around the rectangle. On the bottom edge it is convex. Near each corner its affine branch and the branch on the adjacent edge extend to one ambient affine function, because the edge directions are independent. It therefore has relative affine lower supports everywhere. The same holds for .
Since , both branches lie below , and Consequently on all of , and . This is a coefficient-compatible decreasing uniform approximation, obtained by adding just one moving breakpoint. It cannot be carried by any single finite refinement with vertices in : Lemma 11.19.7 would then imply , contrary to (11.12.5). Pullback to gives the same construction in every positive dimension. These remain abstract polyhedral examples; no balancing or analytic realization is asserted. The changing arithmetic equations can be seen directly. Write and , so . For rational slopes on the two bottom segments, on the top and on the vertical edges, continuity splits as The approximant has and satisfies both equations. The target would have and satisfies neither. There is no contradiction with convergence: the equation coefficients change with . This also explains why a failure of fixed-complex density cannot decide moving-subdivision density.
Propagation of a common scale
There is another useful route back to the one-scale theorem. Rational simplices of dimension at least two have a stronger arithmetic property than general polytopes with rational facet normals. The property propagates through a shared edge.
NAG-900213 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.19.10. (Scale propagation through edges). Let be a finite compact simplicial complex in . Suppose every maximal simplex has dimension at least two, every edge has rational direction, and the graph joining maximal simplices that share an edge is connected. If all vertices belong to , then for some and every vertex lies in . Consequently every has decreasing approximants in , uniformly on .
Proof. First take one simplex with vertices , . Write , with nonzero . The are linearly independent. The edge is a real multiple of a rational vector. A rational left inverse to the matrix with columns shows that the ratio is rational: its two nonzero coordinates are real multiples of two nonzero rational numbers. Thus all vertex differences of this simplex belong to for one positive real .
If two simplices share an edge, its nonzero vector belongs to both and , forcing . Propagate this relation along the connected graph. Starting from one vertex , shared vertices then show that every vertex lies in for a common positive . A nonzero coordinate of an edge shows after the initial choice of scale; multiplying by a positive integer makes it an element of without changing . Translate by and apply Theorem 11.18.1. Translation preserves rational slopes and changes a rational affine constant by , so the approximants retain the required coefficients. ◻
Example 11.19.11. (Rational normals do not ensure rational triangulations). The rectangle has integral facet normals and vertices in for . Nevertheless it has no finite triangulation all of whose edges have rational direction, even allowing extra vertices. Indeed, the triangles in any finite triangulation of a rectangle are connected through shared edges. To see this, join interior points of two triangles by a polygonal path in the interior, chosen to avoid the finitely many vertices and to cross edges transversely. The proof of Proposition 11.19.10, up to the value-group assertion, puts all vertices of such a rational-direction triangulation in for some real . The two boundary vectors and would then force both and to be rational, a contradiction.
This example concerns a compact polytope, not a balanced tropical variety and not a counterexample to the conditional theory in APW26. Section 2.1.6 of that source explicitly assumes the existence of a rational simplicial structure. The example explains why this assumption cannot be replaced silently by rationality of facet normals. Nor may Proposition 11.19.10 be applied to simplices meeting only at vertices or to one-dimensional complexes: the shared nonzero edge is the mechanism that compares their scales.
Convex extension on individual cells
The moving-subdivision problem has a further elementary part that can be completed without a global comparison theorem: matching convex boundary data on one polytope. Recording it separately identifies the remaining issue at joins between cells.
NAG-900214 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.19.12. (Coefficient-compatible convex boundary extension). Let be a positive-dimensional compact polytope defined by rational-slope, -constant affine inequalities. Suppose is continuous on its relative boundary, and on each facet is the maximum of finitely many ambient affine functions with those coefficients. Then extends to a function on which is itself a finite maximum of such affine functions. If an affine real function satisfies on the boundary, then for every one can arrange
Proof. For each facet , choose a rational-slope, value-group-constant affine function on whose zero set on is exactly . Take one affine branch of . We claim that on the whole boundary for some nonnegative rational . Refine the boundary into finitely many compact polytopes on which is affine. At a vertex with , we already have . At all other vertices impose There are only finitely many bounds, so a nonnegative rational exists. Vertex inequalities imply the inequalities on every boundary cell. The modified branch still restricts to on and retains rational slopes and constants in . Take the maximum of all modified branches, over all facets and all their branches. It agrees with on each facet and is convex on .
If , every modified affine branch is at most at all vertices of , hence at most throughout . To obtain the lower bound, choose a rational-slope, -constant affine function with Such a choice follows by approximating the slope and constant of , using compactness and the density of . On the boundary, . Adding to the finite maximum therefore preserves the boundary values and gives (11.19.12). ◻
NAG-900215 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.19.13. (Decreasing cellwise-convex approximation). Let have the coefficient-compatible defining inequalities of Theorem 11.19.8, and let . There are continuous rational-slope, -constant PL functions on , carried by subdivisions allowed to depend on , such that each is convex on every original cell and No relative affine support across different original cells is asserted.
Proof. Put and fix . At each vertex choose a value in between and . Induct on cell dimension. Once a continuous function has been defined on the -skeleton, its restriction to the boundary of each -cell is a finite maximum of coefficient-compatible affine functions on each facet, by the preceding induction steps. Apply Lemma 11.19.12 with and additional error . The extensions agree on common faces because those values have already been fixed. After dimension , the resulting continuous function satisfies on and is convex on every original cell. A common refinement by the finitely many branch comparisons gives a finite coefficient-compatible PL presentation.
For the th construction choose , write , and set . Then , and . The shift belongs to and preserves convexity on each cell. ◻
The qualification is necessary. On with cells and , the functions are affine on each cell and converge uniformly to the relatively convex function , but have no affine lower support at : its slope would have to be both at least and at most . Small uniform errors therefore do not control the support condition at a join. In the boundary-extension proof, the constants provide domination but no bound on the normal slopes. A relative-convex version needs such control, or another argument preserving supports across the old faces. Section 11.20 supplies that slope control for compatible polyhedral geometry. The value-only cellwise result by itself is not used to infer nef residues or original smooth psh approximation.
Analytic use and remaining limits
To use these results on a fixed ordinary unit chart, retain the hypotheses of Proposition 11.11.5 and Theorem 11.11.6: the ground field is nontrivially valued, , and the analytic space is good, strictly analytic and pure-dimensional. Suppose the chart image is contained in , and . Theorem 11.19.4 gives a decreasing sequence on the whole same , with uniform error. Pullback therefore gives actual Q-PL functions on the whole same ordinary chart domain, with nef residues by the cited inputs. If the integral-projective hypotheses of Corollary 11.11.7 also hold, that corollary supplies an original smooth decreasing sequence near each point on one fixed ordinary neighbourhood.
The same analytic conclusion follows from Theorem 11.19.8 when the original complex has rational normals and value-group constants and . Its refinement changes neither the tropical support nor the ordinary inverse-image domain. In contrast, Example 11.19.9 has not been realized as an analytic tropical chart, so no analytic conclusion is inferred from that example alone.
This application uses the existing model and residue comparisons; a formal real PL expression is not substituted for actual Q-PL membership. In particular, [GRPSH] (Theorem 4.3) assumes an actual R-PL function and nontrivial valuation before identifying classical psh with semipositivity. The real coordinate calculations above do not rescale the absolute value, extend the ground field, replace original CLD tests, or enlarge their actual supports.
The distinction from [APW26] (Proposition 5.21) remains essential. That proposition produces locally uniform real PL approximants on one neighbourhood; its proof passes through a projective compactification and functions . Neither a common finite subdivision for all approximants nor the coefficient and strict-support conditions of this section are supplied by that statement. Our criteria can be applied to an individual output only after those data are checked, or to a sequence after the domains and error choices are made compatible. We have not proved that every relevant analytic tropical image admits the certificate of Proposition 11.19.6. Thus the general relative coefficient replacement, Wu Theorem A.3 and the stronger CLD25 closure comparison remain open here. The primary full text of the separate mixed-calculus Theorem 6.13 has still not been obtained; it is not an input to any proof in this section.
References. Finite-dimensional reconstruction in this manuscript, extending the continuity-only note of v0.21. Source scope checked against APW26 Sections 2.1, 5.2 and Proposition 5.21 (v1), and GRPSH Theorem 4.3 (v2). The strict-support certificate and closure proofs are given above; no general source theorem is declared corrected or disproved by them.
11.20 Controlled slopes and moving relative approximation
The value-only extension in Section 11.19.6 leaves the normal slopes uncontrolled. Here the fixed geometry of the original cells supplies the missing estimate. We first strengthen the extension lemma, then show that small cellwise Lipschitz errors preserve strict relative supports. A fixed strict barrier reduces a general relatively supported PL target to that case. The resulting approximants may change subdivision, but never change the compact support.
A boundary extension with controlled slopes
Use the standard Euclidean norm in the fixed ambient space. For a function on a compact convex cell , write for its Lipschitz seminorm, and set this seminorm to zero on a point. All constants below depend on the original finite polytopes, not on subdivisions of their boundary data.
NAG-900216 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.20.1. (Controlled convex extension).
Let be as in Lemma 11.19.12. There is with the following property. Let be real affine, let , and let be continuous on , a finite maximum of rational-slope, -constant affine functions on each facet. Suppose Then has a finite-max extension with the same coefficient conditions and
Proof. Fix a facet and a compatible affine barrier vanishing exactly on . In a finite-max representation of , discard branches never active on a relatively open subset. This does not change the function, including at its boundary, by continuity. For a remaining branch , the tangential part of on has norm at most . The tangent space of is rational. Its orthogonal complement therefore has dense rational points. Add to a function , where is a vertex and is rational, orthogonal to the tangent space, chosen so that the new branch satisfies The added constant is in . For a zero-dimensional facet the same construction uses its single boundary value and no tangential constraint. At a point where the original branch is active, . If , it follows that on .
We next bound the penalty needed to dominate every other facet. If , then for every one can choose such that with a fixed finite constant. Indeed, write as a convex combination of the vertices of , keep the vertices in , and replace all other vertices by one fixed vertex . One may take the largest ratio over vertices outside . Since and the function is -Lipschitz on , If the two facets are disjoint, has a positive minimum on , and the uniform bounds above give the same inequality with another fixed constant. Thus, independently of the branch and the boundary subdivision, there is such that every modified branch is dominated on the boundary after subtracting , where is any rational number in .
Take the maximum of these penalized branches over all facets. It extends exactly and retains the coefficient conditions. Every branch has gradient within of , where depends only on the chosen facet barriers. Hence , a maximum of these affine differences, is -Lipschitz on . Each branch is at most at the vertices, so throughout . Comparing with any boundary point gives . Taking proves the lemma. ◻
NAG-900217 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.20.2. (Cellwise Lipschitz approximation). For a compatible finite compact complex , every and every admit a continuous coefficient-compatible PL function , convex on each original cell, such that Its subdivision may depend on .
Proof. Repeat the skeleton induction of Proposition 11.19.13, now using Lemma 11.20.1. Let bound its constants for all positive-dimensional cells and let . Choose the vertex errors at most . At step , both the uniform error and the facetwise Lipschitz error are at most , and the lemma bounds both errors on the new cell by . The functions agree on shared faces by construction. The finite-max presentations give rational slopes and value-group constants on a finite refinement. If , the vertex choices alone suffice. ◻
Preserving the relative supports
NAG-900218 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.20.3. (Stability near a strict PL function). Let have strict face supports. There is such that every continuous , a finite maximum of real affine functions on each cell, has local relative affine lower supports whenever holds. More quantitatively, if with and fixed having strict face supports, one may take for a constant independent of and .
Proof. Choose the strict support for a face . On any coface , put . It is affine and nonnegative, with zero set exactly . The vertex replacement argument used in (11.20.2) gives, for every , a point with , for one finite over all proper incidences.
Take and an active affine branch supporting at . Its tangential gradient differs from that of by a vector of norm at most . This follows by testing the supporting inequality in both tangent directions near . Regard as a tangent vector in the ambient Euclidean space and set Then on and . For , use the point above and the Lipschitz estimate within to obtain Thus suffices. A small neighbourhood of meets only cofaces of , so is the required relative support. If is maximal, the active branch alone suffices.
For the quantitative statement, add a support of to times a strict support of . The gap on each coface is at least times the corresponding gap for . The same vertex replacement construction therefore gives the distance bound with constant , which may itself be less than one. This proves the stated bound without using a uniform bound on the values of . ◻
NAG-900219 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.20.4. (Relative rational approximation with moving subdivisions). Let and let be a finite compact polytopal complex whose cells are defined by rational-slope, -constant affine inequalities. Every continuous cellwise-affine with local relative affine lower supports has continuous coefficient-compatible PL approximants on the same support , themselves admitting such supports, with The subdivisions of the approximants may vary with . No continuity-closure condition is required.
Proof. Use the fixed arrangement refinement and strict function from Theorem 11.19.8. The function is still affine on each refined cell and has relative supports. Set and . Choose Apply Corollary 11.20.2 to the real PL target with error , obtaining . Lemma 11.20.3 gives relative affine supports for , and Put . This is an allowed value-group shift, preserving the supports and coefficients. The inequalities imply (11.20.4). Every construction takes place on the same . The arrangement refinement is fixed once; only the further finite-max subdivisions used to build vary. ◻
The same proof applies termwise to a decreasing sequence of such real PL targets on the same compact support, even if their compatible complexes differ. Choose supported rational with and add . Then . The limit is the original pointwise limit of ; uniform convergence is claimed only when the targets themselves converge uniformly.
The source interface still to be checked
On an actual ordinary unit chart, the analytic consequences in Section 11.19.7 now apply to every relatively supported real PL target whose finite compact complex has the stated coefficient-compatible geometry. Actual Q-PL identification, nontrivial valuation, nef-residue comparison and integral-projective original-smooth transfer remain separate cited inputs. The arithmetic normalization and original tests are unchanged.
This does not yet cover the arbitrary real intercepts allowed by APW26, nor an arbitrary smooth target without a suitable PL approximation on a common domain. The argument also does not extend the current calculus to arbitrary positive backgrounds or prove first-stage closure. These distinctions are part of the theorem: the new result removes the fixed-subdivision obstruction by controlled moving subdivisions within the compatible-polyhedral class. It is an elementary reconstruction assembled from the explicit extension and support estimates above, not a claim that an unverified source theorem has been proved in its full generality.
Section 11.21 goes further for rational-direction PL germs and for families with an explicit common transport domain. Section 11.21.4 isolates an earlier issue in the literal APW26 PL convention; the gap is not resolved merely by replacing real intercepts with value-group constants.
11.21 Real intercepts, moving germs and common domains
A real intercept can be an obstruction to keeping a subdivision fixed without being an obstruction to approximating the function. There is a local way to remove it: move the centre of a PL star inside the stratum of the original support. The support remains fixed, whereas the break loci move. We prove this germ statement first. We then give a separate transport criterion that works on a prescribed compact set, and explain why the germ statement alone cannot be applied termwise to a source approximation on one neighbourhood.
Section 11.22 gives a subsequent replacement for the fixed-domain approximation question: continuous relative supports suffice, without rational directions or a one-scale input subdivision. The present constructions retain their explicit geometric interpretation and illustrate why termwise germ arguments alone do not control a common domain.
Moving a centre within its stratum
Throughout this section is a nonzero additive subgroup. A compatible polyhedron is one defined by rational-slope affine inequalities with constants in . A rational polyhedron, without the word compatible, may have arbitrary real constants. All complexes used locally are finite after restriction to a sufficiently small neighbourhood. Relative supports always mean ambient affine lower supports in the relative topology of the specified support.
NAG-900220 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.21.1. (Compatible points in a face). If is a nonempty compatible polyhedron, then is dense in . Its tangent space is rational.
Proof. The affine hull is specified by those rational equations that hold identically on . Gaussian elimination gives a particular solution and a basis for the homogeneous solutions. Thus . Since contains for some , points with are dense in this affine hull and have compatible coordinates. Intersect with the relatively open set . The case is included. ◻
NAG-900221 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.21.2. (A fixed support near a stratum). Let be the support of a locally finite compatible complex, and let . There are and a finite union of rational polyhedral cones such that In particular, for every . If is continuous and affine on a finite rational polyhedral subdivision near , then, after decreasing , where is continuous and homogeneous of degree one, affine on a finite rational conical subdivision of . If has relative supports near , then has relative supports on all of .
Proof. Only cells containing meet a sufficiently small ball. In each such cell, inequalities that are strict at remain strict in a smaller ball; the active inequalities become homogeneous after translating to the origin. Their normals are rational, and vanish on , because they vanish on the face . Their tangent cones form the asserted union , invariant under both signs of every vector in . This also proves the equality after changing the centre to .
Apply the same active-constraint construction to the finite rational subdivision of , together with the original complex. On a cell containing , its affine expression becomes . The expressions agree on overlaps, first near zero and then everywhere by homogeneity. They define on . To transfer a relative support to a point , choose so small that and a neighbourhood of it lie in the ball where (11.21.1) holds. A support for near gives the support near . At zero use the given support directly. ◻
NAG-900222 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.21.3. (Rational approximation of a real-intercept PL germ). Let be locally the support of a compatible complex and let be continuous, affine on a locally finite rational polyhedral subdivision of , with local relative affine lower supports. For every there is a compact neighbourhood of in and continuous coefficient-compatible PL functions on , themselves having relative supports, such that The intercepts of the subdivision of need not belong to . The neighbourhood depends on the germ ; the theorem makes no uniform-domain assertion for a family of different germs.
Proof. Use Lemma 11.21.2. Choose a closed box with coordinate endpoints in such that and , and put . For close to , define The equality makes this a function on exactly the same . It has relative supports, and its cells are intersections of with translates by of rational cones. These cells are compatible. Thus satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem 11.20.4, although its function coefficients can still be real.
There is a constant with on . Indeed, the segment from to lies in , since its direction belongs to . Partition that segment at the finitely many conical cells of . On each piece its slope is bounded by the norm of a chosen ambient slope of that cell; take to be the largest of these norms. Lemma 11.21.1 now gives so close to that this error is at most .
Theorem 11.20.4 supplies a supported coefficient-compatible on with . Hence . Set . The shift is in and gives (11.21.2), including decrease because . No affine map of an analytic space has been introduced: only the real function used in a fixed set of coordinates has changed. ◻
Transport on a prescribed compact set
For a single germ the preceding construction is enough. For a sequence, a useful alternative is to move an entire one-scale presentation on a domain fixed in advance. The scale below is a real geometric parameter; it is not the normalization of a field valuation.
NAG-900223 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.21.4. (One-scale transport). Let be a finite union of rational cones, let be a rational subspace with , and let . Let be relatively open in . Let be a closed compatible box with nonempty . Suppose is continuous, has relative supports on , and is affine on a finite polyhedral structure in a neighbourhood of , whose cells are defined by inequalities Here the same and are used for all cells, and equalities are allowed. Then has decreasing coefficient-compatible relative PL approximants satisfying (11.21.2) on this prescribed . Neither nor is required to have value-group coordinates.
Proof. Choose and tending to and , respectively, and define The maps preserve bijectively and converge to the identity, as do their inverses, uniformly on compact sets. Choose a relatively open neighbourhood of with compact closure in , contained in the neighbourhood where the stated finite presentation is valid. Sufficiently close choices ensure . On put . Supports are transported by this invertible affine map in the real coordinate space. The transformed cell inequalities are They are compatible, since only rational numbers multiply elements of . Their intersections with form a compatible compact complex with support exactly . Uniform continuity of on allows the choices to satisfy . Apply Theorem 11.20.4 with error , and add as in the previous proof. ◻
NAG-900224 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.21.5. (An edge-connected simplicial certificate). In Theorem 11.21.4, the one-scale presentation condition follows if is affine on a finite compact simplicial complex covering a neighbourhood of in , every maximal simplex has dimension at least two, every edge has rational direction, the maximal simplices are connected by shared edges, and one vertex belongs to . The vertices need not have value-group coordinates.
Proof. Use the geometric part of the proof of Proposition 11.19.10, before its value-group step. It gives one positive real such that all vertices lie in . Indeed, within a simplex the rational directions of its edges force the edge scales to have rational ratios; a shared nonzero edge propagates the ratio between simplices. Each simplex is therefore times a polytope with rational vertices, allowing lower-dimensional affine-hull equations. Its defining inequalities have the form (11.21.3), with . Apply Theorem 11.21.4. This is a consequence of the earlier scale-propagation proof and the new transport argument, rather than a separate density theorem. ◻
This certificate is deliberately checkable. It does not apply merely because a source uses the word simplicial: unbounded polyhedra, pieces joined only at vertices, one-dimensional cells, and a missing lineality anchor require additional arguments. In an ambient vector space one may take , so the anchor condition is automatic; on a branching support it is a real restriction.
NAG-900225 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.21.6. (Families with a common transport domain). Let decrease pointwise on the same . Suppose each satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem 11.21.4 near the same , with its own finite structure, scale and lineality translation. Then there are supported coefficient-compatible PL functions on with The pointwise limit is unchanged. If instead converges uniformly to a finite function on , without monotonicity, a subsequence and the same error-shift construction give decreasing supported coefficient-compatible PL approximants to on .
Proof. For the first assertion choose with and set . Then . For the second, select with and approximate that term within . The resulting lies within of , so the same shift proves the claim. Parameters may be chosen separately for each target; no uniform slope bound or common subdivision is used. ◻
Why the germ quantifiers matter
Example 11.21.7. (Shrinking stars despite uniform control). Take and let be the secant interpolation of at the dyadic nodes of , with mesh . On one has The slopes increase with , so is convex. Refining each interval inserts a point of the convex graph below its old chord, hence . Also . Nevertheless, the maximal centred interval on which for a degree-one homogeneous PL function is : there , and the slope changes at . Thus no positive-radius star works for all . Pullback by the first-coordinate projection gives the same phenomenon in every positive dimension.
This is not a failure of approximation: the functions are already coefficient-compatible, convex and decreasing uniformly to a smooth convex target. It disproves only the inference from termwise PL stars, uniform convergence and a uniform Lipschitz bound to a common star radius. The domain in Theorem 11.21.3 therefore cannot simply be intersected over the approximants furnished by a source theorem.
NAG-900226 Open proof obligation
Corollary 11.21.8. (Original smooth approximation of a rational-direction PL germ). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, let be an integral projective -variety of positive dimension, and let be ordinary open. On fix analytic units and the map . Let . Suppose near that the actual image is contained in a support of a locally finite -compatible complex, where , and where is finite continuous, affine on a locally finite rational subdivision of , and has local relative affine lower supports. Then some ordinary open neighbourhood of carries original smooth psh functions . Convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the analytic germ bridge using the required curvewise-to-model implication; GRPSH Theorem 4.3.
For a family on a prescribed compatible box, Corollary 11.21.6 can replace the germ theorem in this proof, after its geometric presentation conditions are checked term by term. Neither route changes the chosen valuation, extends the ground field, enlarges the support of an actual analytic test, or replaces original CLD tests. The auxiliary real support must be specified in the hypothesis; no unsupported extension of from the actual image is being asserted. These are consequences of the displayed real constructions and the named model and smoothing inputs, not a full comparison with the generated source classes.
The PL convention in the source regularization
There is a logically earlier issue than the value-group constants. In the fixed version [APW26] (Section 1.6; Sections 2.1, 2.1.4–2.1.6), affine functions have real coefficients, rational half-spaces have integral normals and arbitrary real intercepts, and polyhedral structures are declared rational and simplicial unless specified otherwise. The last step of Proposition 5.12, printed page 38, invokes a continuous finite-selection argument to conclude PL membership. The following two examples explain why that step needs an explicit convention or an additional geometric argument. They do not disprove the existence statements of Propositions 5.12 or 5.21.
The examples below concern finite or locally finite subdivisions, as explicitly stated. The displayed definition in the source Section 2.1.6 does not itself list local finiteness. This convention also needs clarification when that definition is used: we do not infer a statement about arbitrary non-locally-finite decompositions from the finite-boundary argument below.
Example 11.21.9. (A maximum with an irrational break direction). On , the affine functions and are affine on every rational triangulation. Their maximum is not affine on the cells of any locally finite rational polyhedral structure near the origin. Indeed, each full-dimensional affine cell must lie on one side of the break line . Hence an open segment of would lie in the finite union of rational supporting lines of the cells near the origin. One such line would have to contain an open segment of , and therefore equal . But has no nonzero rational tangent vector. This is a contradiction. The function is nevertheless an ordinary real-polyhedral PL function and is ambient convex. Products with give the same distinction in every dimension .
NAG-900227 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.21.10. (Uniform density does not give Lipschitz-small errors). Let and let be a closed ball of positive radius centred at the origin. If is continuous and affine on a locally finite rational polyhedral subdivision of a neighbourhood of , then This holds even when the affine coefficients of are real. Nevertheless, rational numbers give coefficient-compatible convex functions converging uniformly to on .
Proof. A nontrivial segment of the irrational line inside cannot be covered by the finitely many rational boundary lines of the subdivision. Choose a point on that segment in the interior of a full-dimensional cell. Near , the function is one affine function with gradient . On the two open sides of , the gradients of are respectively and . Its Lipschitz seminorm on bounds both norms, by evaluating differences in small line segments lying in the corresponding open side. The triangle inequality gives For uniform approximation, the maximum operation is -Lipschitz in the sup norm of its two entries, so the error is at most . The same obstruction holds in every ambient dimension at least two by restricting to the rational plane where the other coordinates vanish. The lower bound is sharp among rational-subdivision PL functions with real affine coefficients: the single affine function has and Lipschitz error . Among coefficient-compatible functions the infimum is the same, by approximating this affine gradient by rational vectors; an allowed constant can be chosen independently because the Lipschitz seminorm ignores constants. ◻
Thus the cellwise Lipschitz estimates used in Section 11.20 cannot simply be demanded for arbitrary real-polyhedral targets on a preassigned rational complex. A rational subdivision of the input was a substantive hypothesis of the germ construction. This obstruction concerns the stronger error norm only; it neither obstructs uniform rational approximation nor disproves the source regularization statement.
The same proof applies to the maximum of two affine functions with gradients whenever their break hyperplane cannot be a facet in the permitted subdivision class; the bound is . This also distinguishes value-group intercepts from rational directions. For example, with , on every coefficient-compatible PL approximation to has : its finitely many rational breakpoints miss , so is affine there. Yet converges uniformly when tends to . Thus moving the centre in Theorem 11.21.3 is compatible with uniform error control, without implying Lipschitz convergence. Products give this intercept phenomenon in every positive dimension.
Example 11.21.11. (Compatible coefficients without rational triangulability). Let . Each of the four functions , , and admits a rational simplicial conical subdivision of , translated to a point on its break line. Their sum has rational slopes and constants on a compatible polyhedral complex. But it admits no locally finite rational simplicial subdivision on a neighbourhood of . Its gradient changes across each of the four bounding lines. No full-dimensional cell of an affine presentation can cross any of those lines. Thus the cells inside the rectangle would give a finite rational-direction triangulation of it, contradicting Example 11.19.11. All the cells contained in the bounded rectangle are compact simplices, irrespective of how simplicial unbounded polyhedra are defined outside it.
The first example concerns rational directions, independently of any valuation. The second retains rational directions and compatible coefficients, but concerns the extra simplicial requirement. Neither example is a counterexample to approximation by supported rational functions: the first is ambient convex and admits such approximations by Section 11.12.4, while the second is already coefficient-compatible. They identify the category in which a finite-selection proof is valid.
NAG-900228 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.21.12. (Coefficient-compatible finite selections). On the support of a finite compatible complex, a continuous selection from finitely many affine functions , with and , is coefficient-compatible PL on a finite compatible refinement. The same conclusion holds for a continuous selection from finitely many coefficient-compatible PL functions. No simplicial refinement is asserted.
Proof. Cut each cell by all equations . These are compatible hyperplanes. On the relative interior of a resulting cell, two branches are either identical or everywhere distinct, with a fixed strict order. A continuous selection must choose one of these distinct branches on each connected relative interior: locally it cannot change to a different branch across a positive value gap. Continuity extends that affine expression to the closed cell. For PL inputs first take their finite common compatible refinement and apply the same argument to their affine branches there. ◻
With arbitrary real affine coefficients the same proof produces a real-polyhedral refinement, whose face directions may be irrational. Thus there are two honest ways to use the last step of the source Proposition 5.12: either specify the unrestricted real-polyhedral PL category and separately prove the later rational/model interface, or establish coefficient and subdivision control during the construction. Merely citing a finite-selection theorem does not supply that control. The germ theorem above assumes a rational subdivision of the input and therefore does not silently cover the first alternative. Section 11.22 supplies the second route for continuous relative-support inputs on a fixed compact set. The companion mixed-calculus Theorem 6.13 remains unverified here because its primary full text has not been obtained.
The primary-file check also confirms the localization correction already proved in Lemma 11.11.11. On the compact neighbourhood used in APW Proposition 5.10, the intersection of the closures of its shrinking sets is , not the printed zero set of . This is a recheck of that earlier repair, not an additional result of the present section.
11.22 Rational affine bumps on a fixed compact support
The coefficient problem can be treated before the PL subdivision is produced. The local modification and finite-cover argument of [APW26] (Propositions 5.10 and 5.12) suggest the following replacement: approximate the raised affine supports by coefficient-compatible affine functions, then perform the gluing. A small quadratic term supplies the strict separation needed to absorb that perturbation. The proof below is given in full, including the common domain and the last finite-selection step. It is an elementary reconstruction of that argument with coefficient control, not a claim of a new regularization principle.
Local modifications with controlled coefficients
Fix a nonzero additive subgroup , and set . An allowed affine function is with and . Let be nonempty and compact. A continuous has relative affine lower supports if, for every , some ambient affine satisfies and on a relative neighbourhood of . No polyhedrality of is needed until the polyhedral conclusion is stated.
NAG-900229 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.22.1. (A rational affine local bump). Suppose that is continuous and has relative affine lower supports. Fix , and an ambient affine such that For every there is an allowed affine function and a continuous function with relative affine lower supports, satisfying
Proof. The groups and are dense in . Approximate the coefficients of so closely that This is possible by coefficientwise approximation on a bounded ball; the centre and the radius need not be compatible. At one has . On one has . If also , then Define on and elsewhere. On an annulus around the patching boundary both formulas equal . Hence the definition is continuous and gives (11.22.1). Locally it is either or a maximum of and an affine function. A support of an active term supports the maximum at that point; this proves the support assertion, including the tie locus. No smooth cutoff is used. ◻
NAG-900230 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.22.2. (A finite active cover removes the background). Let be continuous functions on compact , with . Suppose that cover , and that on for allowed affine functions . Then is a continuous selection from . Moreover, near each point of , it is the restriction of a maximum of a fixed subset of these affine functions. In particular, it has relative affine lower supports.
Proof. At , one has . Every maximizing index therefore has . Let . For these indices, continuity keeps near , so there. For the other indices, the strict inequalities persist on a sufficiently small common neighbourhood, because the list is finite. Consequently near . The covering also gives , although no uniform lower bound independent of the approximation is needed. ◻
The local and global assertions in this lemma are different. An affine branch may exceed outside the patch on which it was used; the construction does not give on all of . Near a point, however, every active modification is strictly above the background and therefore equals its affine branch. This is the precise reason why the local maximum conclusion survives the gluing.
Coefficient-compatible density and fixed-domain sequences
NAG-900231 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.22.3. (Density by rational finite selections). Let be nonempty and compact and let be continuous with relative affine lower supports. For every there is a continuous function , locally a finite maximum of allowed affine functions and globally a selection from one finite list of them, such that If is the support of a finite coefficient-compatible polytopal complex, then is coefficient-compatible PL on a finite refinement. No rational subdivision, differentiability or PL hypothesis is imposed on . The refinement is not asserted to be simplicial.
Proof. Set and choose so that . The function is continuous and has relative supports. More precisely, if supports near , then satisfies in that neighbourhood. Choose so that this holds on , and choose Lemma 11.22.1 gives , and the relatively open sets cover . Take a finite subcover and set equal to the maximum of its modifications. Then Lemma 11.22.2 gives the local maxima and the global finite selection. If is coefficient-compatible polyhedral, apply Lemma 11.21.12: cut by the equations , whose slopes are rational and constants lie in . The original balls and the possibly nonpolyhedral sets disappear from this final presentation. It is therefore unnecessary to make their radii or boundaries compatible. ◻
NAG-900232 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.22.4. (Decreasing approximation on the same support). Under the hypotheses of Theorem 11.22.3, fix and put . There are functions of the type constructed there such that Thus uniformly on . The local maximum neighbourhoods may vary with ; their domains of definition are all .
Proof. Approximate from above within and add the allowed constant . This gives the displayed bounds, and gives decrease. Adding a constant preserves every support and every local maximum presentation. This is the geometric-error shift used earlier, now applied after the rational bump construction. ◻
NAG-900233 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.22.5. (Continuous supported families). Let be continuous functions with relative affine lower supports on the same compact . If pointwise, then there are rational finite selections , each locally a maximum of allowed affine functions, with If instead uniformly with no monotonicity, then a subsequence and suitable allowed shifts give such a decreasing approximation of . In the polyhedral case all these functions are coefficient-compatible PL. No common subdivision or common local maximum radius is needed.
Proof. For decreasing targets, apply Theorem 11.22.3 to the th target with error , then add . The bounds imply . For uniformly convergent targets, choose within of , approximate it from above within , and add . Then ; the same geometric ratio gives decrease. The pointwise statement does not assert uniform convergence to a discontinuous or infinite limit. ◻
NAG-900234 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.22.6. (Smooth cellwise convex inputs have relative supports). Let be the support of a locally finite polyhedral complex in , and let be on an ambient neighbourhood of . Assume that its restriction to every cell is locally convex. Then has relative affine lower supports. It is enough, for functions, that the Hessian be positive semidefinite on the tangent space of each cell at its relative interior points.
Proof. Fix . By local finiteness and closedness, a sufficiently small ball meets only cells containing . On each of the finitely many incident cells, local convexity at gives convexity on its intersection with a sufficiently small ball. Take a common such ball; every segment from to a point in that cell stays in the convex intersection. The one-variable tangent inequality gives The right side is one ambient affine function, independent of the cell, and it equals at . This proves the assertion. In the case the tangential Hessian condition extends to cell boundaries by continuity, and its restriction to each segment gives the required convexity. In affine coordinates the support is , not unless the coordinates have first been centred at . ◻
This is the local tangent-support argument used in [Wu26] (Appendix A, p. 53), with its affine translation written explicitly and local finiteness included. Combined with Theorem 11.22.3, it gives coefficient-compatible approximation on any fixed compact compatible support inside the ambient domain. It does not assume, without a separate comparison theorem, that positivity of an arbitrary CLD current supplies this cellwise Hessian hypothesis.
NAG-900235 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.22.7. (Finite ordered families). Let be a finite family satisfying Theorem 11.22.3, indexed by a finite partially ordered set, with whenever . The decreasing rational approximants may be chosen to preserve all these inequalities simultaneously.
Proof. Choose approximants from Corollary 11.22.4, with the same for all . Set . The index sets are nested when , so the order is preserved. Also , because the term is present and . Finite maxima preserve the local affine-maximum presentations and decrease in . ◻
The actual analytic consequence
NAG-900236 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.22.8. (Continuous relative-support potentials on unit charts). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, let be an integral projective -variety of positive dimension, and let be ordinary open. Fix analytic units on and . Suppose that , where is continuous and has ambient affine lower supports locally in the relative topology of the actual image. Then, for every , there is one ordinary neighbourhood carrying original smooth psh functions . Convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Establish the analytic chart replacement and positivity inputs for the regularization; the proof applies GJR and GRPL.
NAG-900237 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.22.9. (Ordered families in one actual chart). In Theorem 11.22.8, replace by continuous relatively supported functions on the same actual image, and assume pointwise. Then has original smooth psh approximation on one ordinary neighbourhood of each point. The limit may be ; compact-uniform convergence is asserted only when the analytic limit is finite continuous. The same conclusion holds for locally uniform limits of such , after restriction to a compact image.
Proof. Use the same affinoid and the same for every term, apply Corollary 11.22.5, and repeat the local unit-logarithm maximum argument and the fixed-domain transfer steps in the preceding proof. ◻
There is also a consistent longer route: Proposition 11.11.5 gives Q-PL membership from finite selections, and Theorem 11.11.6 gives nef residues from relative supports. The latter uses [GRPSH] (Theorem 4.3), whose hypotheses are a good strictly analytic space over a nontrivially valued field and an already R-PL function. The direct maximum argument above is sufficient here because the new approximants have the stronger local maximum presentation. Neither route infers PL membership from current positivity alone.
For a finite continuous endpoint , the conclusion also gives on every original CLD positive test. Indeed, for such a compactly supported test , compact-uniform convergence gives , by the finite signed measure defined by the top-degree form . This is the passage in Lemma 11.9.1. The endpoint is not thereby asserted to be PL, nor is an arbitrary-background BT product being defined.
This proves a local forward implication for the stated continuous relative-support presentations. It does not identify every original positive current with such a presentation, treat arbitrary positive-current backgrounds, remove integral projectivity from the transfer input, or settle the discontinuous predecessor and first-stage closure issues in CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11. The complete Wu Theorem A.3 is not deduced. The ground field and valuation normalization are unchanged, and the conclusion concerns original CLD smooth functions and tests.
What the construction does not preserve
Example 11.22.10. (A balanced branching support without an ambient convex extension). In , take the rays with primitive directions and weights . They form a balanced one-dimensional fan. Define for and on the other three rays. This continuous coefficient-compatible PL function has relative affine lower supports: zero supports it at the origin, and away from the origin it is affine on a single local ray. But it is not the restriction of an ambient convex function on any neighbourhood of the origin. Indeed, for small , On a compact compatible truncation, Theorem 11.22.3 nevertheless applies. Its local ambient-convex neighbourhoods must be allowed to shrink with the approximation. Taking a product with gives the same example on a balanced support in every positive dimension .
Example 11.22.11. (Relative supports need not survive a uniform limit at a boundary). On , set for . Each function is smooth on a neighbourhood of the interval and convex there, hence has affine lower supports at every point of the interval. As , the functions decrease uniformly to , with error between zero and . Yet has no affine lower support at zero: such a support would be , and for all sufficiently small positive is impossible. Products give the same boundary phenomenon in every dimension.
This is a statement about relative supports on a compact polyhedral boundary, not a counterexample to an analytic regularization theorem. It explains why Corollary 11.22.5 treats limits directly instead of silently assuming that the limit still satisfies the input support definition.
The local bump proof controls values, not Lipschitz differences. Proposition 11.21.10 remains valid, including its irrational-intercept variant. The construction also uses essentially for coefficient approximation: on with , every allowed affine function has value zero, so even the constant function one cannot be approximated in this coefficient class. This does not assert failure of original smooth regularization over a trivially valued field.
For the local analytic purpose, Theorem 11.22.8 supersedes the rational-direction and one-scale restrictions in Section 11.21, once the continuous relative-support input is verified. The earlier proofs remain useful for their explicit geometry and, in Section 11.20, their stronger error estimates. The present proof does not repair the global twisted, simplicial or sedentary formulations of the source by redefining their terminology. It supplies a coefficient-controlled local replacement and leaves those comparisons separate.
For comparison of conventions, [BBS22] (Definition 2.1) explicitly requires a locally finite closed polyhedral cover; its real Euclidean framework should not be read as imposing value-group constants. The finite-selection characterization in [FL00] (p. 74, equation (1.1)) likewise concerns real affine data. Our rational conclusion comes from choosing the branches before gluing, not from attributing a rationality assertion to either source.
Continuous supports at vanishing coordinates
The Euclidean quadratic in the first proof cannot simply be used at an infinite tropical coordinate. There is, however, a bounded strictifying function on each compact extended image. We now give the argument separately, with the precise boundary support convention. This treats continuous inputs by constructing new locally finite-max approximants; it does not identify every pre-existing relative PL presentation at the boundary.
Put with the topology for which , with , is a homeomorphism onto . At , an admissible affine germ is a function on a neighbourhood of , where . For a real affine germ the coefficients are real; for an allowed germ and . Thus an affine germ used at a boundary point is independent of every coordinate that is infinite at that point. Relative lower supports below must be admissible real affine germs, with equality at the point.
NAG-900238 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.22.12. (Rational bumps on compact extended images). Let , let be nonempty compact, and let be continuous with relative admissible affine lower supports. For every , there is continuous with , such that has a finite relative open cover on each member of which is a finite maximum of allowed admissible affine functions. The decreasing, decreasing-family and uniformly-convergent-family conclusions of Corollaries 11.22.4 and 11.22.5 hold on this same , with this local presentation.
Proof. Write and . The function is continuous and bounded on . At put On a neighbourhood where all coordinates in stay finite, this is an admissible affine function, , and Equality holds exactly at : the first summands vanish exactly when , and the last ones exactly when . Choose with and set . If supports relatively near , then supports , with strictly positive gap off in that neighbourhood.
Use the metric . Choose so that lies in the support neighbourhood and all its coordinates in stay in bounded real intervals. On the compact annulus the continuous gap has a positive minimum , if the annulus is nonempty. If it is empty, choose any . Take . Approximate within on the closed ball by an allowed affine using only coordinates in . Their boundedness makes coefficient approximation uniform; no infinite-coordinate term is introduced.
Define on and outside. On , . Thus the patching is continuous, equals outside , raises the value at by at least , and changes by at most . As before, a finite positive cover yields with .
At a point , every active modification is strictly above , so its affine branch is defined on a neighbourhood of . Each coordinate on which that branch depends is finite there. The active-index argument of Lemma 11.22.2 therefore gives a local finite maximum of admissible affine functions. Compactness gives a finite open cover by such presentations. The affine branches have specified local domains; no evaluation of an inactive branch at a point where it is undefined is needed. Finally the geometric shifts and subsequence arguments of Corollaries 11.22.4 and 11.22.5 apply without change. ◻
NAG-900239 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.22.13. (The analytic transfer through zeros). In Theorem 11.22.8, allow to be analytic functions, possibly vanishing, set , and impose the admissible relative-support hypothesis of Theorem 11.22.12 on the actual image. The same original smooth decreasing approximation exists on one ordinary neighbourhood of every point. The corresponding decreasing and locally uniformly convergent continuous families on the same extended chart also satisfy Corollary 11.22.9.
Proof. Take one compact strict affinoid neighbourhood , put , and apply Theorem 11.22.12. This image is compact by continuity; polyhedrality is not needed. For each local maximum presentation of an approximant near , all coordinates used in its active branches are finite. The corresponding are nonvanishing near , and hence analytic units after restriction to an ordinary neighbourhood. The denominator and unit-logarithm calculation in Theorem 11.22.8 applies there. Thus each approximant is actual Q-PL with nef residues on the same . Apply the fixed-domain transfer, and use the same compact image for families. The neighbourhoods used to verify individual PL germs are not intersected over the sequence. ◻
The support condition at the boundary is essential to this statement. It is a condition on a real-valued function on the actual extended image, expressed by affine germs independent of the infinite coordinates. It is not obtained merely by checking separate finite strata, taking their closures, or allowing cancellation of infinite affine terms. The construction does not alter the original field or its absolute value. General source-class identification, the first-stage closure problem and the full comparison theorems remain separate.
Single smooth inputs and sequences
NAG-900240 Open proof obligation
Proposition 11.22.14. (Local rational approximation of one original smooth psh function). In the integral-projective, nontrivially valued setting of Theorem 11.22.8, let be an original CLD smooth function on with . For each there is one ordinary neighbourhood and a sequence of actual Q-PL functions with nef residues on , decreasing to uniformly. Each is locally a finite maximum of rational unit logarithms. The neighbourhood and the tropical presentation in this assertion may depend on .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Supply the local boundary-separation and approximation steps used to pass from one original smooth input; GRPL Theorem 7.7 argument and section 7.2.
For a sequence of different smooth inputs , this proposition supplies neighbourhoods and presentations that may depend on . Their intersection need not be a neighbourhood. Corollaries 11.22.9 and 11.22.13 apply when the continuous supported inputs are already presented on one common actual chart; they do not manufacture such a chart for an arbitrary smooth sequence. Thus the single-input comparison above does not close the full family comparison in Wu Theorem A.3 or the first-stage closure issue in CLD25 Proposition 8.1.11.
For finitely many , intersect their presentation neighbourhoods, take the product unit chart and add boundary-separating coordinates once. Each ambient remains smooth; the same integration argument gives relative supports on the common image away from the boundary. One compact affinoid therefore works for all inputs. Corollary 11.22.7 also preserves any prescribed finite order in the rational approximants. This uses finite intersections and products; it supplies no countable common chart.
The common-domain replacement for arbitrary original smooth families in this projective setting is completed in Theorem 11.24.3. It uses finite extended presentations on each prescribed affinoid, rather than a countable product of unit charts. The remaining sheaf-level decreasing closure is distinguished in Section 11.24.4.
11.23 Varying unit charts on one affinoid neighbourhood
A fixed finite chart is stronger than the approximation argument requires. It is enough that the charts of the individual terms be defined on one affinoid neighbourhood: boundary-separating coordinates can then be chosen once, while the other coordinates vary. We prove this criterion first. We then give a decreasing smooth psh sequence with a finite continuous uniform limit for which the criterion’s presentation hypothesis fails on every neighbourhood of a rational point. Thus the criterion advances the common-domain argument but does not remove its general gluing problem.
Separating the boundary before choosing the terms
Throughout this section, is complete and nontrivially valued, is an integral projective -variety of positive dimension, and is ordinary open. Interiors are taken in ; denotes the analytic boundary of an affinoid domain over . A global unit presentation on means an equality , where for finitely many , and is on an ambient open neighbourhood of . This is a hypothesis on the whole of , stronger than original smoothness at each point.
NAG-900241 Open proof obligation
Lemma 11.23.1. (A boundary separator independent of the input). Let be a compact strictly affinoid neighbourhood of . There are compact strictly affinoid neighbourhoods and of , and a unit tropicalization , such that, for every finite unit tropicalization on , the product satisfies The choices of , and depend only on , not on or on the number of charts subsequently considered.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Supply boundary separation by analytic functions in the given setup; the proof applies GRPL’s Theorem 7.7 construction.
The lemma fixes the analytic domain, not the tropical image. With infinitely many input charts the sets may have different dimensions and subdivisions. They need not embed into one finite-dimensional common chart. The estimates below are imposed after pullback to the same , where they can be compared.
NAG-900242 Open proof obligation
Theorem 11.23.2. (Simultaneous rational replacement on a common affinoid). Let be original CLD smooth psh functions on , and suppose that every has a global unit presentation on the same compact strictly affinoid neighbourhood of . The finite tuples of units and the ambient smooth functions may depend on , with no uniform bound on their number or derivatives. There is one compact strictly affinoid neighbourhood of such that, for every sequence , there are continuous functions on satisfying and each is actual Q-PL with nef residue classes, locally a finite maximum of rational unit logarithms. The same works before the errors are prescribed.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Supply the uniform chart replacement with the asserted error and positivity in the stated scope; GRPL (7.7.1).
Decreasing families and continuous uniform limits
NAG-900243 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.23.3. (A family transfer without a common finite chart). Under the hypotheses of Theorem 11.23.2, assume either that pointwise on , with values of in , or that locally uniformly on with finite and continuous. Then one ordinary neighbourhood of carries decreasing actual Q-PL functions with nef residues and pointwise limit . On one further neighbourhood , there are original smooth psh functions . In the second case, and whenever the endpoint in the first case is finite and continuous, convergence is uniform on compact subsets of .
Proof. Fix and . In the decreasing case apply Theorem 11.23.2 with error and put . On one has Thus on . Adding preserves Q-PL membership and nef residues because .
In the locally uniform case, choose increasing indices with . Replace with error and again add . The resulting functions satisfy so they decrease to on the same . In both cases Theorem 11.10.11 supplies the required original smooth sequence on one final . For a finite continuous endpoint, Dini’s theorem on each compact subset gives the stated convergence. No change of ground field, normalization or original test class occurs. ◻
For an already decreasing original smooth sequence, the last original-smooth conclusion by itself is tautological. The substantive assertion is its replacement by decreasing actual Q-PL functions with nef residues on one fixed domain. For a locally uniform, nonmonotone sequence, the argument additionally produces a decreasing sequence. These are consequences of the stated presentation hypothesis, not an identification of all sheaf-generated classes.
Why a common affinoid presentation is a genuine condition
NAG-900244 Open proof obligation
Lemma 11.23.4. (Unit logarithms on a closed polydisc). Let , with . Every has constant absolute value on . Consequently, if an affinoid neighbourhood of contains , every function given by any finite unit presentation on is constant on this same . The statement holds for any number of such functions, even when their tuples of units differ.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the analytic Tate-algebra unit criterion used in the argument; Bosch14 Section 2.1, Corollary 4.
Example 11.23.5. (Uniform decreasing approximation without common unit presentations). For every , on there is a decreasing sequence of original smooth psh functions converging uniformly to the finite continuous function , but no affinoid neighbourhood of carries global unit presentations for every term of the sequence.
Proof. Fix , and let be a nonnegative even function supported in with integral one. Define, for , This is smooth, convex and nondecreasing, equals for , and equals for . Moreover Choose any and put Each equals on a neighbourhood of . On , it is an ambient smooth function of the unit logarithm . With , its second derivative is Thus is original smooth and psh on , using a constant presentation near and the unit chart elsewhere; the displayed nonnegative Hessian pulls back to a positive -form. For fixed , differentiation in gives Consequently decreases, and on all of . This proves uniform convergence, including at .
Suppose a common affinoid neighbourhood supplied the claimed unit presentations. It contains a polydisc with and . Lemma 11.23.4 would make every constant on this same disc. For large enough that , however, whereas at the Gauss point with all radii equal to one has . This is a contradiction. ◻
This is a counterexample only to automatic simultaneous global unit presentations. It is not a counterexample to regularization: the functions themselves are the required regularization. They share the extended coordinate , with an admissible constant germ at , as permitted in Corollary 11.22.13. It also shows that local uniform convergence does not, by itself, give a uniform radius for the original smooth presentations. The same obstruction occurs in every positive dimension, although it is already detected by the first coordinate.
A common-domain argument must therefore do more than ask for global units on a smaller affinoid. The next section allows global analytic functions with zeros outside their local patches. It proves that these extended presentations suffice to handle arbitrary original smooth psh families on a fixed affinoid in the stated setting. The counterexample above remains valid for global unit presentations.
11.24 Gluing presentations on a fixed affinoid
The obstruction in Example 11.23.5 concerns global units. It disappears if a global analytic function is allowed to vanish outside the patch on which its logarithm is used. The following argument exploits this distinction. On a Laurent domain, a sufficiently accurate rational approximation to a unit has exactly the same absolute value. Finitely many such replacements, together with the functions defining the domains, place all local presentations in one extended tropical image. Relative affine supports then pass to that image. This gives rational approximation on a prescribed compact affinoid, before a sequence of inputs is chosen.
Exact absolute values from rational approximation
NAG-900245 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.24.1. (Replacing local units by global fractions). Let be strictly affinoid, and let be a Laurent domain, where . For every there are , both nonvanishing on , such that One can take to be a product of nonnegative integral powers of the . No equality of analytic functions with is asserted.
Proof. If is empty, take . Otherwise the Laurent-domain algebra is This is the affinoid localization of Section 2.1; see also [Bosch14] (Section 3.3, Proposition 11). Truncation in the Tate algebra shows that the image of is dense in . In particular its elements approximate in the supremum seminorm on . Since is a unit, . Choose a fraction in this dense subalgebra with . The ultrametric equality proves (11.24.1) at every Berkovich point. The denominator is a product of the , hence is nonvanishing on ; the equality makes nonvanishing there as well. ◻
We also need the ordinary topology, rather than just an affinoid-domain cover. For any point of and any relative ordinary neighbourhood, choose finitely many strict inequalities and defining a smaller neighbourhood. Nontriviality makes dense in . The thresholds can therefore be chosen in this group, with strict inequalities at the point and with their closed versions still inside the prescribed neighbourhood. Raising to positive integral powers and dividing by constants in writes the resulting compact domain in the form above. Its strict locus is a relative ordinary neighbourhood of the point. Both and are determined by absolute values of global analytic functions on . This elementary construction does not say that every member of an arbitrary affinoid-domain cover contains an ordinary neighbourhood.
A finite extended presentation with relative supports
Call a finite continuous function locally unit-supported if, near each point in the ordinary topology, it has a unit tropical presentation , where is continuous on the actual image and has relative affine lower supports. The ambient affine slopes in these supports may be real. This definition includes local finite maxima of rational unit logarithms. In our integral-projective, nontrivially valued setting, it also includes every original smooth psh function: the boundary-adapted positivity argument in the proof of Proposition 11.22.14 supplies precisely these local supports.
NAG-900246 Proof review pending
Proposition 11.24.2. (Globalizing a finite local presentation). Let be complete and nontrivially valued, let be compact strictly affinoid, and let be continuous and locally unit-supported in its relative ordinary topology. Then finitely many global analytic functions give an extended tropicalization such that for a continuous having relative admissible affine lower supports in the sense of Theorem 11.22.12. In particular, at a point where a coordinate is infinite, its supporting affine germ does not use that coordinate. No global-unit assertion is made for the .
Proof. At each point choose a local supported presentation, then a Laurent domain inside its ordinary presentation domain whose strict locus contains the point, as constructed above. Compactness yields finitely many covering . Write the presentation on as Apply Lemma 11.24.1 to each unit on , obtaining with the same absolute-value ratio. Include all these numerators and denominators, and every global function defining the inequalities of the , in the finite list defining . Identically zero constraint functions are harmless; unused coordinates can be omitted.
Because the strict inequalities defining are recorded among the coordinates, there is an open such that . These cover . On , the coordinates of are differences of the finite coordinates corresponding to and . Denote this linear map on that finite-coordinate locus by . If two points of have the same -image, choose containing one; saturation puts both in , and gives equal values. Thus defines a function on . The map is a continuous surjection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space, hence a quotient map; consequently is continuous.
Finally fix . Every and is nonvanishing on , so all coordinates used by are finite near . A relative affine lower support of at , restricted to , pulls back to . On a sufficiently small relative neighbourhood of in , this affine function is at most and equals it at . It only uses coordinates finite at , so is admissible. This proves the asserted support property at every point, including the extended boundary. ◻
Only the presentations are glued. The fractions need not agree as analytic functions on overlaps, because equality of their absolute values with the prescribed local units is enough. The functions agree on the actual image by their common pullback ; no ambient extension across all patches is asserted. Polyhedrality of the global extended image is also unnecessary for Theorem 11.22.12.
Fixed-domain replacement and first decreasing stages
NAG-900247 Proof review pending
Theorem 11.24.3. (Rational approximation on a prescribed affinoid). Let have the hypotheses of Section 11.23, and fix a compact strictly affinoid domain with nonempty ordinary interior . If is finite continuous and locally unit-supported on , then for every there is a continuous with and is locally a finite maximum of rational unit logarithms, hence actual Q-PL with nef residues. This applies in particular to every original smooth psh on . The affinoid is fixed independently of and .
Proof. Restrict the local supported presentations of to and apply Proposition 11.24.2. Apply Theorem 11.22.12 to the resulting compact image , with . Pull back its approximant to . At every point of , each active affine branch uses only coordinates finite there. Their global analytic functions are therefore units on an ordinary neighbourhood of that point. The denominator calculation and finite-maximum semipositivity argument of Theorem 11.22.8 give the asserted rational PL and nef properties. The domain was never reduced in this construction. For original smooth psh inputs, local supported presentations come from the already verified boundary-adapted argument, as stated above. ◻
NAG-900248 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.24.4. (First-stage comparison in the stated projective setting). For an ordinary open , let be its finite original smooth psh functions, let be its finite continuous locally unit-supported functions, let be its functions locally expressible as finite maxima of rational unit logarithms with constants in , and let have the meaning of Section 11.10.6. For one of these classes , write for germs at representable as on one ordinary neighbourhood of , with all in that class on that neighbourhood. Allow endpoints in . Then If a sequence in converges locally uniformly to a finite continuous , then its germ also belongs to these equal classes. The resulting decreasing original smooth approximation converges uniformly on compact subsets of one neighbourhood.
Proof. The local supported-presentation argument gives . Let decrease to , and fix a compact strictly affinoid neighbourhood of once. Apply Theorem 11.24.3 to every , with error , and add . The inequalities in the proof of Corollary 11.23.3 give a decreasing sequence with limit . Thus . The local unit-log residue and maximum statements give . Finally Theorem 11.10.11 gives , closing the chain. For a locally uniform sequence use the subsequence and separated errors from Corollary 11.23.3, now with Theorem 11.24.3 in place of the common-unit-presentation hypothesis. Dini’s theorem gives compact-uniform convergence at a finite continuous endpoint. ◻
Equation (11.24.2) is an equality of explicitly defined first-stage germ classes over the fixed nontrivially valued field and integral projective variety. It does not assert that this class is already closed under every further locally defined decreasing operation, or under the full transfinite procedure in CLD25. Identifying Wu’s precise analytic/algebraic generator conventions and all of its field hypotheses remains separate. No arbitrary-positive-current Bedford–Taylor product, new field descent, or verification of the unavailable mixed-calculus Theorem 6.13 is used or obtained. The proof is a synthesis of affinoid localization, the local positivity input, compact extended-image density, and the existing projective transfer; no independent priority claim is made.
A second diagonal when all rows have one domain
The first-stage equality leaves a separate question: can a decreasing limit of first-stage germs again be represented on one neighbourhood? The following elementary diagonal argument settles the case in which all rows already have a common domain. It does not manufacture that domain. Unlike the uniform-error diagonal, it permits discontinuous and row limits.
NAG-900249 Proof review pending
Lemma 11.24.5. (Compact diagonal for ordered row limits). Let be compact, and let be continuous. Suppose as , and as , allowing limits in . Fix any positive strictly decreasing . There are integers such that No metrizability, countable dense subset, continuity of , or uniform convergence of the rows is assumed.
Proof. Choose inductively so that, in addition to , For every pair in the second line, . For the first line the inductive lower bound gives wherever is finite. Where it equals , also , so the same strict inequality holds. For any one of these finitely many continuous upper bounds , the open sets increase with and cover . Compactness makes one of them equal to . Taking the largest of finitely many resulting indices imposes all the inequalities simultaneously. This constructs and proves decrease of .
Since , its limit satisfies . For each fixed , inequality (11.24.4) holds for all sufficiently large , so . Taking the infimum first in , then in , gives . Thus . The finite upper bounds were used only as constraints in the selection; their minimum is not used as an approximating function. ◻
For original smooth psh rows on one open , restrict to a compact affinoid neighbourhood and then to its ordinary interior. Each selected remains original smooth psh. For rows in or , choose the shifts in and obtain the same conclusion in that generator class. This is a common-domain second-stage closure statement. Merely knowing, for each , that the germ of belongs to provides possibly different row domains; it does not satisfy this lemma’s hypothesis. That ordinary-neighbourhood/sheafification issue, together with the precise transfinite predecessor requirement, is the next comparison task.
NAG-900250 Proof review pending
Corollary 11.24.6. (Full collapse of the raw compact hierarchy). Let be compact Hausdorff and let be nonempty and stable under addition of real constants. For the raw hierarchy of Definition 11.6.2, This equality includes discontinuous and -valued endpoints. It concerns actual functions on the same compact domain, without sheafification.
Proof. If decreases to , choose a row decreasing to each on . Lemma 11.24.5 gives . Stability under constants places every selected term in , so is closed under decreasing sequences. Since constant sequences give , transfinite induction in the stated recursion proves the equality: successor steps use this closure, and limit steps take unions. ◻
Theorem 11.6.4 remains useful for its uniform-closure characterization at continuous endpoints. The present corollary strengthens only its raw, fixed-domain conclusion. A local sheaf section may be produced on changing neighbourhoods before any compact representation is available; that operation is absent from the recursion used here. Thus this corollary does not supply the missing representation property in Corollary 11.6.5.