Review pending

Lemma 11.16.2 · A smooth barrier does not remove the first-order obstruction

Lemma 11.16.2. (A smooth barrier does not remove the first-order obstruction). Let F0F_0 denote the relative PL function of Example 11.10.9, so F0(h,h)=hF_0(h,h)=h and F0(2h,0)=F0(0,2h)=0F_0(2h,0)=F_0(0,2h)=0. For every ambient C2C^2 function BB near the origin, F0+B∣ΣF_0+B|_\Sigma still has no ambient convex extension near the origin. If ∥D2B∥op≤M\|D^2B\|_{\mathrm{op}}\leq M on the relevant segments, its midpoint convexity defect is at least h−Mh2h-Mh^2.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. Put a=(h,h)a=(h,h) and v=(h,−h)v=(h,-h). The affine part of the Taylor expansion cancels in B(a)−12B(a+v)−12B(a−v)B(a)-\frac 12B(a+v)-\frac 12B(a-v). The remainder is bounded below by −M∥v∥2/2=−Mh2-M\|v\|^2/2=-Mh^2. Adding the exact defect hh of F0F_0 gives the assertion, which is positive for all sufficiently small h>0h>0. Thus even an arbitrarily large fixed quadratic barrier cannot correct this first-order failure. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900193.

Proof in chapter