Review pending

Theorem 11.16.5 · A fixed-chart smooth psh obstruction over every nontrivial field

Theorem 11.16.5. (A fixed-chart smooth psh obstruction over every nontrivial field). Let KK be any complete nontrivially valued non-Archimedean field, with its fixed absolute value. Set P(t)=t2−t+1,C=PK1∖({0,1,∞}∪V(P)),f=t(t−1),g=tP(t),x=−log⁡∣f∣,y=−log⁡∣g∣,s=−log⁡∣t∣.\begin{gathered} P(t)=t^2-t+1,\\ C=\mathbf P^1_K\setminus\bigl(\{0,1,\infty\}\cup V(P)\bigr),\\ f=t(t-1),\qquad g=tP(t),\\ x=-\log|f|,\quad y=-\log|g|,\quad s=-\log|t|. \end{gathered} Then u=xyu=xy is original smooth psh on CanC^{\mathrm{an}}, but it has no ambient convex presentation in the fixed chart (x,y)(x,y) near the unit-disc Gauss point. The quantitative bound (11.16.1) still holds. The example extends to an ordinary open subset of (PK1)d(\mathbf P^1_K)^d for every d≥1d\geq 1. In particular, residue characteristics 22 and 33 are included.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. Both ff and gg are units on CC. If ∣t∣<1|t|<1, then ∣t−1∣=∣P(t)∣=1|t-1|=|P(t)|=1, giving (x,y)=(s,s)(x,y)=(s,s). If ∣t∣>1|t|>1, then ∣t−1∣=∣t∣|t-1|=|t| and ∣P(t)∣=∣t∣2|P(t)|=|t|^2, giving (x,y)=(2s,3s)(x,y)=(2s,3s). If ∣t∣=1|t|=1, put f=t(t−1)f=t(t-1) and note the exact identity P=f+1P=f+1. The numbers ∣f∣,∣P∣|f|,|P| are at most 11 and cannot both be smaller than 11. Since ∣g∣=∣P∣|g|=|P| in this case, at least one of x,yx,y is zero. Therefore u=H(s),H(v)=(max⁡{v,0})2+6(max⁡{−v,0})2.u=H(s),\qquad H(v)=(\max\{v,0\})^2+6(\max\{-v,0\})^2. This function HH is convex, with derivatives 12v12v for v<0v<0 and 2v2v for v>0v>0. The same convex regularization argument as above proves positivity against all original compactly supported tests. The formula u=xyu=xy proves original smoothness.

The diagonal and horizontal ray segments at the origin are realized by Gauss points of small discs around 00 and 11. To exhibit the vertical segment, choose a root aa of PP in a finite extension K′/KK'/K, endowed with the unique extended absolute value. Both roots have absolute value 11, and P(1)=1P(1)=1 implies ∣a−1∣=1|a-1|=1. Gauss points of K′K'-discs centered at aa with radii r<1r<1 and close to 11 therefore have ∣t∣=∣t−1∣=1|t|=|t-1|=1, while ∣P(t)∣<1|P(t)|<1 approaches 11 as r↑1r\uparrow 1. More precisely, factor PP over a finite splitting extension. On such a disc, ∣P∣a,r=∏P(b)=0max⁡{r,∣a−b∣},|P|_{a,r}=\prod_{P(b)=0}\max\{r,|a-b|\}, where roots are counted with multiplicity. For rr sufficiently close to 11, this is rqr^q with q∈{1,2}q\in\{1,2\}, so it realizes a whole vertical interval. Restricting these multiplicative seminorms to K[t]K[t] gives actual points of CanC^{\mathrm{an}} tending to its unit-disc Gauss point. This use of an auxiliary field constructs points over KK; the function, the positivity proof and the approximation question have not been base-changed, and no current-descent assertion is used.

Every ordinary neighbourhood of that Gauss point consequently contains analytic points with tropical coordinates (h,h),(2h,0),(0,2h)(h,h),(2h,0),(0,2h) for small h>0h>0. Their function values are h2,0,0h^2,0,0, giving the same midpoint obstruction and error bound. The product construction of Corollary 11.16.4 gives every positive dimension. Repeated roots of PP cause no difficulty: their multiplicities are already included in the displayed Gauss-norm formula. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900196.

Proof in chapter