Theorem 11.16.5. (A fixed-chart smooth psh obstruction over every nontrivial field). Let be any complete nontrivially valued non-Archimedean field, with its fixed absolute value. Set Then is original smooth psh on , but it has no ambient convex presentation in the fixed chart near the unit-disc Gauss point. The quantitative bound (11.16.1) still holds. The example extends to an ordinary open subset of for every . In particular, residue characteristics and are included.
Argument in the manuscript
Proof. Both and are units on . If , then , giving . If , then and , giving . If , put and note the exact identity . The numbers are at most and cannot both be smaller than . Since in this case, at least one of is zero. Therefore This function is convex, with derivatives for and for . The same convex regularization argument as above proves positivity against all original compactly supported tests. The formula proves original smoothness.
The diagonal and horizontal ray segments at the origin are realized by Gauss points of small discs around and . To exhibit the vertical segment, choose a root of in a finite extension , endowed with the unique extended absolute value. Both roots have absolute value , and implies . Gauss points of -discs centered at with radii and close to therefore have , while approaches as . More precisely, factor over a finite splitting extension. On such a disc, where roots are counted with multiplicity. For sufficiently close to , this is with , so it realizes a whole vertical interval. Restricting these multiplicative seminorms to gives actual points of tending to its unit-disc Gauss point. This use of an auxiliary field constructs points over ; the function, the positivity proof and the approximation question have not been base-changed, and no current-descent assertion is used.
Every ordinary neighbourhood of that Gauss point consequently contains analytic points with tropical coordinates for small . Their function values are , giving the same midpoint obstruction and error bound. The product construction of Corollary 11.16.4 gives every positive dimension. Repeated roots of cause no difficulty: their multiplicities are already included in the displayed Gauss-norm formula. ◻