Review pending

Theorem 11.18.1 · Rational approximation with one geometric scale

Theorem 11.18.1. (Rational approximation with one geometric scale). Let Γ⊂R\Gamma\subset\mathbf R be a nonzero additive subgroup, and fix λ∈Γ>0\lambda\in\Gamma_{>0}. Let Π\Pi be a finite polytopal complex in Rr\mathbf R^r such that every vertex belongs to λQr\lambda\mathbf Q^r. Let F:∣Π∣→RF:|\Pi|\to\mathbf R be continuous, affine on each cell, and admit a relative affine lower support near every point. Then there are continuous functions FjF_j on ∣Π∣|\Pi|, affine on the same cells with rational slopes and constants in λQ⊂ΓQ\lambda\mathbf Q\subset\Gamma_{\mathbf Q}, admitting relative affine lower supports and satisfying Fj+1≤Fj,0≤Fj−F≤3λ8−jon ∣Π∣.\begin{equation} F_{j+1}\leq F_j,\qquad 0\leq F_j-F\leq3\lambda8^{-j}\quad\text{on }|\Pi|. \end{equation} Here polytopal means that the cells are compact polytopes. In particular, the hypothesis on the vertices holds for a finite (Z,Γ)(\mathbf Z,\Gamma)-polytopal complex when Γ=λZ\Gamma=\lambda\mathbf Z. The conclusion does not require Γ\Gamma itself to be discrete if the displayed one-scale hypothesis holds.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. First write t=λzt=\lambda z and F^(z)=F(λz)/λ\widehat F(z)=F(\lambda z)/\lambda. This is a change of real coordinates and function units for the calculation; the absolute value on any analytic base field remains unchanged. The scaled complex has rational vertices. An affine function with rational coefficients in zz pulls back, after multiplication by λ\lambda, to a function with rational slopes and λQ\lambda\mathbf Q-constants in tt. It therefore suffices to approximate the function and its supports with rational coefficients in the scaled coordinates.

Write the affine expression on a cell σ\sigma as pσ(z)+cσp_\sigma(z)+c_\sigma. For every face ρ\rho, introduce an affine support variable aρ(z)+bρa_\rho(z)+b_\rho. The conditions are pσ(v)+cσ=pτ(v)+cτ(v a vertex of σ∩τ),aρ(v)+bρ=pρ(v)+cρ(v a vertex of ρ),aρ(v)+bρ≤pσ(v)+cσ(σ⊇ρ, v a vertex of σ).\begin{equation} \begin{aligned} p_\sigma(v)+c_\sigma&=p_\tau(v)+c_\tau &&(v\text{ a vertex of }\sigma\cap\tau),\\ a_\rho(v)+b_\rho&=p_\rho(v)+c_\rho &&(v\text{ a vertex of }\rho),\\ a_\rho(v)+b_\rho&\leq p_\sigma(v)+c_\sigma &&(\sigma\supseteq\rho,\ v\text{ a vertex of }\sigma). \end{aligned} \end{equation} The first line is continuity. To justify the support conditions, choose x∈relint⁡(ρ)x\in\operatorname{relint}(\rho). A touching affine lower support agrees with F^\widehat F on the affine span of ρ\rho, since their affine difference has a local minimum of zero there. For y∈σ⊇ρy\in\sigma\supseteq\rho, apply the support inequality at x+s(y−x)x+s(y-x) for small s>0s>0. Linearity on σ\sigma and equality at xx extend the inequality to all of σ\sigma. Testing it on vertices is sufficient. Conversely, the last two lines give a lower support on every cell containing ρ\rho. A small neighbourhood of xx avoids the other cells: the complex is finite, and a cell containing a point in relint⁡(ρ)\operatorname{relint}(\rho) contains ρ\rho. Thus the system is equivalent to the required local relative supports.

All vertices are rational in the scaled coordinates, so (11.18.2) is a finite homogeneous rational linear system in the combined tuple (pσ,cσ,aρ,bρ)(p_\sigma,c_\sigma,a_\rho,b_\rho). Use the rational-density argument already given in Section 11.12.7: impose the active inequalities as equalities, choose a rational basis of the resulting nullspace, and approximate the tuple within that subspace. The inactive inequalities remain strict for sufficiently close approximations. This preserves both continuity and the existence of supports, rather than merely approximating the cellwise formulas.

Return to the tt-coordinates and choose the approximation GjG_j so that ∣Gj−F∣≤ϵj:=λ8−j|G_j-F|\leq\epsilon_j:=\lambda 8^{-j} on ∣Π∣|\Pi|. This is possible by controlling the error at the finitely many vertices: on each cell the difference is affine, and its absolute value is bounded by the largest vertex error. Put Fj=Gj+2ϵjF_j=G_j+2\epsilon_j. Constants still belong to λQ\lambda\mathbf Q, and F+ϵj≤Fj≤F+3ϵj,Fj+1≤F+38ϵj≤Fj.F+\epsilon_j\leq F_j\leq F+3\epsilon_j, \qquad F_{j+1}\leq F+\tfrac38\epsilon_j\leq F_j. Shifting the supports by 2ϵj2\epsilon_j preserves contact. This proves (11.18.1). For the discrete value-group case, a vertex of a (Z,λZ)(\mathbf Z,\lambda\mathbf Z)-polytope is the solution of a full-rank rational linear system with right-hand side in λZ\lambda\mathbf Z, so its coordinates lie in λQ\lambda\mathbf Q. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900204.

Proof in chapter