Review pending

Proposition 11.14.2 · The obstruction over any nontrivially valued field

Proposition 11.14.2. (The obstruction over any nontrivially valued field). The conclusion of Example 11.14.1 holds over every complete nontrivially valued field KK, with its fixed absolute value, and in every dimension at least two. No discrete valuation, characteristic assumption or field extension is needed.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. Put R=K∘R=K^\circ and choose 0≠a∈K∘∘0\ne a\in K^{\circ\circ}. On PR1\mathbf P^1_R, with homogeneous coordinates [x:y][x:y], define FF by 0⟶O(−1)2→ B O4⟶F⟶0,B=(−y0x−y0x0ay).0\longrightarrow\mathcal O(-1)^2 \xrightarrow{\ B\ }\mathcal O^4\longrightarrow F\longrightarrow0, \qquad B=\begin{pmatrix}-y&0\\x&-y\\0&x\\0&ay\end{pmatrix}. The minors include x2x^2 and y2y^2, so BB is locally a split injection and FF is locally free of rank two. On the special fibre its cokernel is O(2)⊕O\mathcal O(2)\oplus\mathcal O, as seen from the quotient map (x2,xy,y2,0)(x^2,xy,y^2,0) and the fourth basis vector. On the generic fibre, adding a−1a^{-1} times the fourth row to the second row makes the matrix block diagonal, with columns (−y,x)(-y,x) and (x,ay)(x,ay); each block has cokernel O(1)\mathcal O(1). Thus FK=O(1)2F_K=\mathcal O(1)^2. This is an explicit form of the preceding classical deformation; see also [Addington21] (Worksheet 2, part 3).

Set Y=P(F)\mathscr Y=\mathbf P(F) and M=OP(F)(1)M=\mathcal O_{\mathbf P(F)}(1). Its four generating sections give a morphism to the quadric X1={z0z2−z12+az1z3=0}⊂PR3.\mathscr X_1=\{z_0z_2-z_1^2+a z_1z_3=0\}\subset\mathbf P^3_R. Indeed the incidence relations are xz1−yz0=0xz_1-yz_0=0 and xz2−yz1+ayz3=0xz_2-yz_1+ayz_3=0, whose determinant is the displayed equation. The homogeneous coordinate ring is free of rank two over R[z0,z2,z3]R[z_0,z_2,z_3], because the equation is monic in z1z_1. Hence X1\mathscr X_1 is flat and of finite presentation over RR. The generic quadric is split and smooth: replacing z3z_3 by az3−z1az_3-z_1 gives the usual Segre equation. The generic morphism is the complete O(1,1)\mathcal O(1,1) embedding, so, after identifying generic fibres, f:Y→X1f:\mathscr Y\to\mathscr X_1 is a projective model morphism inducing the identity. The target has the ample extension O(1)\mathcal O(1).

To replace the DVR divisor argument, use the projective-bundle Picard formula. Over a connected base SS, this formula says that a line bundle on P(E)\mathbf P(E) is uniquely π∗N⊗O(d)\pi^*N\otimes\mathcal O(d). Here is the needed general-base justification. At any s∈Ss\in S, twist by the degree dsd_s on the projective-space fibre. Its fibre cohomology is then one-dimensional in degree zero and zero otherwise. Cohomology and base change, in the form [StacksPB] (Tag 0B9S), gives locally a line bundle N=π∗L(−ds)N=\pi_*\mathcal L(-d_s); the evaluation map is an isomorphism on every fibre and hence an isomorphism after shrinking. Thus dsd_s is locally constant, and connectedness makes it constant. The local NN glue by the evaluation isomorphisms, and uniqueness follows from π∗O=OS\pi_*\mathcal O=\mathcal O_S. This argument applies without noetherian assumptions.

Since RR is local, Pic⁡(R)=0\operatorname{Pic}(R)=0. Applying the formula twice gives Pic⁡(Y)=Z[M]⊕Z[π∗O(1)]\operatorname{Pic}(\mathscr Y)=\mathbf Z[M]\oplus\mathbf Z[\pi^*\mathcal O(1)]. On X=PK1×PK1X=\mathbf P^1_K\times\mathbf P^1_K these generators restrict to (1,1)(1,1) and (1,0)(1,0), a basis of Pic⁡(X)\operatorname{Pic}(X). Therefore restriction is injective, and any extension of LmL^m must be MmM^m. Its degree on the section defined by FK~↠OF_{\widetilde K}\twoheadrightarrow\mathcal O is zero, so it cannot be ample. Products with projective space give every higher dimension, with injectivity of Picard restriction again supplied by the same formula. No renormalization of ∣⋅∣|\cdot| has been made. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900181.

Proof in chapter