Review pending

Example 11.16.3 · A fixed-chart obstruction already for smooth psh functions

Example 11.16.3. (A fixed-chart obstruction already for smooth psh functions). The function u=xyu=xy on CanC^{\mathrm{an}} is original CLD smooth and psh on all original tests. Nevertheless, the function F(a,b)=abF(a,b)=ab restricted to τ(Can)\tau(C^{\mathrm{an}}) has no ambient convex extension on any convex open neighbourhood of the origin. Moreover, on any subset containing (h,h),(2h,0),(0,2h)(h,h),(2h,0),(0,2h) with h>0h>0, every restriction GG of an ambient convex function satisfies max⁡z∈{(h,h),(2h,0),(0,2h)}∣G(z)−F(z)∣≥h22.\begin{equation} \max_{z\in\{(h,h),(2h,0),(0,2h)\}}|G(z)-F(z)|\geq\frac{h^2}{2}. \end{equation} Every ordinary open neighbourhood of ξ\xi has a tropical image containing such a triple for some h>0h>0. Consequently a fixed-chart uniform approximation by ambient convex functions fails on every such neighbourhood.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. Smoothness follows because x,yx,y are logarithms of analytic units and multiplication is a smooth operation. The case distinction in Proposition 11.16.1 gives the additional identity u=H(s),H(v)=(max⁡{v,0})2+4(max⁡{−v,0})2.u=H(s),\qquad H(v)=(\max\{v,0\})^2+4(\max\{-v,0\})^2. The real function HH is convex: its derivative is 8v8v for v<0v<0 and 2v2v for v>0v>0, with common value zero at the origin. Choose smooth convex regularizations HϵH_\epsilon converging uniformly on compact real intervals to HH. The function s=−log⁡∣t∣s=-\log|t| is original smooth and pluriharmonic, since tt is a unit. Therefore d′d′′Hϵ(s)=Hϵ′′(s) d′s∧d′′s≥0.d'd''H_\epsilon(s)=H_\epsilon''(s)\,d's\wedge d''s\geq0. For every compactly supported original CLD test, ss is bounded on its support, so Hϵ(s)→uH_\epsilon(s)\to u uniformly there. Passing to curvature currents preserves positivity on every original positive test. This proves psh without asserting that the ambient polynomial abab is convex. The relative function has touching affine lower supports: zero at the vertex and a tangent affine function along a ray away from the vertex.

Suppose the maximum error on the three points is ϵ\epsilon. Since (h,h)(h,h) is the midpoint of (2h,0)(2h,0) and (0,2h)(0,2h), convexity gives h2−ϵ≤G(h,h)≤12G(2h,0)+12G(0,2h)≤ϵ.h^2-\epsilon\leq G(h,h) \leq\tfrac12G(2h,0)+\tfrac12G(0,2h)\leq\epsilon. This proves (11.16.1) and rules out an exact extension. The three Gauss-point paths toward 0,1,−10,1,-1 are continuous and have common limit ξ\xi as their radii tend to 11. An ordinary neighbourhood of ξ\xi therefore contains initial segments of all three paths, giving the asserted triple for small hh. The argument also rules out uniform convergence on a fixed compact set containing the corresponding three analytic points. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900194.

Proof in chapter