Review pending

Proposition 11.17.1 · Positive tangential Hessian without ambient convex extension

Proposition 11.17.1. (Positive tangential Hessian without ambient convex extension). Let 0<ε<1/20<\varepsilon<1/2, and put Fε(x,y,z)=xy+ε(x2+y2+∑i=1d−1zi2),uε=Fε∘τ.\begin{equation} F_\varepsilon(x,y,z)=xy+\varepsilon\left(x^2+y^2+\sum_{i=1}^{d-1}z_i^2\right), \qquad u_\varepsilon=F_\varepsilon\circ\tau. \end{equation} Then uεu_\varepsilon is original CLD smooth and psh. For each maximal face σ\sigma of S×Rd−1S\times\mathbf R^{d-1} and each vector vv tangent to σ\sigma, D2Fε(v,v)≥2ε∥v∥2.\begin{equation} D^2F_\varepsilon(v,v)\geq2\varepsilon\|v\|^2. \end{equation} Nevertheless, Fε∣S×Rd−1F_\varepsilon|_{S\times\mathbf R^{d-1}} has no ambient convex extension near zero. If an ambient convex function GG is defined on a convex set containing ph=(h,h,0),qh=(2h,0,0),rh=(0,2h,0),h>0,p_h=(h,h,0),\qquad q_h=(2h,0,0),\qquad r_h=(0,2h,0),\quad h>0, then max⁡a∈{ph,qh,rh}∣G(a)−Fε(a)∣≥1−2ε2h2.\begin{equation} \max_{a\in\{p_h,q_h,r_h\}}|G(a)-F_\varepsilon(a)| \geq\frac{1-2\varepsilon}{2}h^2. \end{equation} Every ordinary neighbourhood of ξd\xi_d contains analytic points realizing such triples for all sufficiently small h>0h>0. Thus ambient convex approximation in this chart cannot converge uniformly on any fixed such neighbourhood.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. Theorem 11.16.5 proves that xyxy is original smooth psh, by expressing it as the convex function s+2+6s−2s_+^2+6s_-^2 of s=−log⁡∣t∣s=-\log|t| and using smooth regularization. The added quadratic is an ambient smooth convex function of unit logarithms. Its pullback is smooth psh, so their sum is psh on all original CLD tests. No pullback operation on arbitrary currents is involved.

Write a tangent vector as v=(aα,aβ,vz)v=(a\alpha,a\beta,v_z), where (α,β)(\alpha,\beta) is a generator of one of the four rays. In each case αβ≥0\alpha\beta\geq 0, and D2Fε(v,v)=2a2αβ+2ε∥v∥2,D^2F_\varepsilon(v,v)=2a^2\alpha\beta+2\varepsilon\|v\|^2, which proves (11.17.2). This is the precise tangential positivity assertion used here; it is not a claim about every possible convention for strict psh.

Since ph=(qh+rh)/2p_h=(q_h+r_h)/2, the values of FεF_\varepsilon give the midpoint defect Fε(ph)−Fε(qh)+Fε(rh)2=(1−2ε)h2.F_\varepsilon(p_h)-\frac{F_\varepsilon(q_h)+F_\varepsilon(r_h)}2 =(1-2\varepsilon)h^2. If the error at all three points is at most ee, convexity of GG bounds this defect above by 2e2e. This proves (11.17.3). The Gauss-point paths in Theorem 11.16.5, with wi=1w_i=1, converge to ξd\xi_d and realize the three rays in question. Fixing one sufficiently small hh in a proposed approximation domain gives a positive error lower bound independent of the approximant. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900197.

Proof in chapter