Theorem 17.8.2. (The residual obstruction in the example). The two lifted coordinate functions are harmonic but not original smooth near . Their outgoing-slope divisors are respectively Consequently the canonical tropicalization of the Jacobian of the realized curve need not be an original smooth tropicalization.
Argument in the manuscript
Proof. Proposition 17.8.1 gives the slope lists and . Each has sum zero, giving harmonicity. Matching the directions with the three residual markings gives the displayed divisors. The standard identification sends to . Nontorsion of and Example 17.7.3 show that both classes remain nonzero after tensoring with . Corollary 17.7.2 proves nonsmoothness. The analytic Abel–Jacobi map identifies these local functions with pullbacks of local coordinates of the canonical tropicalization of the Jacobian. If that tropicalization were original smooth, pullback of original smooth functions by the analytic map would make these functions original smooth, a contradiction. The realized curve has genus , using the graph and residual genus formula of Proposition 17.6.1; hence this produces the abelian threefold of GJR. ◻