17.1 Harmonic coordinates: the geometric obstruction to original smoothness
Numerical triviality and principal triviality differ
An original affine coordinate is built from logarithms of analytic units. Its residual line-bundle data is therefore principal in the appropriate local description. A numerical harmonic function only asks the associated residual class to be numerically trivial. A degree-zero line bundle on a residual curve need not be trivial or torsion. This difference can prevent a numerical harmonic function from being original smooth.
On a curve whose residue field is algebraic over a finite field, torsion properties of residual degree-zero classes improve the comparison. The relevant statement in GJR is a curve result. It should not be generalized to every dimension over a finite extension of merely because the residue field is finite.
What the enlarged sheaf is intended to repair
If harmonic functions are geometrically natural but unavailable as original smooth coordinates, differential constructions based only on analytic units may be too restrictive. GJR allows harmonic tropicalizations and pulls back real smooth superforms through them. The resulting weakly smooth sheaf contains the original one and supports a differential calculus and integration theory.
The adjective weakly smooth refers to the enlarged coordinate class; it has no connection with weak positivity. Its continuous dual consists of strong currents in the terminology of that paper; again, this says which tests are allowed, not which positive cone is used. The detailed constructions and the direction of the restriction map follow in the next section.
The curve cohomology calculation
Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff also construct a compatible differential theory on weighted metric graphs and use it to calculate weakly smooth Dolbeault cohomology of compact Berkovich curves. For a connected compact curve without boundary in their setting, the dimensions satisfy The integer on the right is the first Betti number of the underlying analytic topological space. It is not in general the algebraic genus. A smooth proper curve with good reduction can have positive algebraic genus and .
This is an important warning for the proposed passage from tropical Hodge theory to Berkovich Hodge theory: one must specify which cohomology is being compared. Residual algebraic geometry is not automatically encoded in the first Betti number of a skeleton. A statement resembling a Hodge diamond may concern tropical Dolbeault groups rather than algebraic de Rham cohomology.
References. [GJR] (Sections 7, 10, 15–17); [GJRc] (Theorems 6.4.3 and 6.4.5).
17.2 Harmonic tropicalizations and weakly smooth forms
Throughout this section, is complete and nontrivially valued, and is a good strictly -analytic space. The version of Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff cited here is arXiv:2111.05741v3, dated 7 March 2025. The adjective weakly in weakly smooth concerns the allowed coordinate functions. It has no connection with the distinction between weakly, strongly, and ordinarily positive forms.
From analytic units to numerically trivial models
A smooth tropicalization is locally a map defined by invertible analytic functions. To describe the enlargement of this class of maps, we first specify the model-theoretic meaning of harmonicity.
Definition 17.2.1. (Local model functions and harmonicity). Let . An integral model function near has the form on an analytic neighbourhood , where is a formal -model of and is a model of , with its specified generic-fibre trivialization. An -model function is locally a finite real linear combination of such functions.
An -model function is semipositive at if it can be represented on a neighbourhood of by an -model line bundle whose restriction to the special fibre is nef. It is harmonic at if both and are semipositive there. These conditions are imposed at every point to obtain semipositivity or harmonicity on .
Here nefness means nonnegative degree on every proper integral curve in the special fibre. An -model line bundle means a finite real linear combination of integral model line bundles, with degrees extended linearly. Proposition 7.1 and Definition 7.2 of [GJR] identify this definition with the corresponding condition on the residue class on the reduction of the analytic germ . In particular, Numerical triviality is the condition on the relevant proper curves. It does not assert that is trivial or torsion.
NAG-900304 Open proof obligation
Proposition 17.2.2. (Elementary direction and functoriality). If is an invertible analytic function, then is harmonic. Harmonic functions are stable under pullback by analytic morphisms and under extension of the ground field. Every real harmonic function is locally a finite real linear combination of integral harmonic functions.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the nontrivial harmonic and PL assertions currently assigned to GJR Propositions 7.6 and 7.5.
Remark (The relevant topology). The PL functions form a sheaf for the analytic -topology. Harmonicity and semipositivity in Definition 17.2.1 are local in the ordinary analytic topology and do not form sheaves for the -topology [GJR] (Remark 7.3(3)). A covering by formal domains therefore cannot be substituted without argument for analytic neighbourhoods in this definition.
Definition 17.2.4. (Harmonic tropicalization). A harmonic tropicalization of a compact good strictly analytic space is a map whose coordinates are integral harmonic functions.
This is [GJR] (Definition 8.1). A smooth tropicalization is harmonic, but a harmonic tropicalization need not arise from analytic units. The integrality of the coordinates is part of the definition. The last assertion of Proposition 17.2.2 explains how general real harmonic functions are nevertheless represented in such charts.
The sheaf and its differential operations
Definition 17.2.5. (Weakly smooth preforms and forms). Let be open with compact strictly analytic closure . A preform of type on is a pair , where is a harmonic tropicalization and is a smooth Lagerberg -form on . Two pairs and represent the same preform if The sheafification of this presheaf is denoted . Its sections are weakly smooth forms.
This is [GJR] (Definitions 10.3 and 10.8). Passing to a product chart puts any finite collection of preforms on a common tropicalization. On that chart, wedge products and derivatives are those of Lagerberg forms: For types and , the commutativity sign is , and the Leibniz sign for either differential is . These are total-degree signs.
NAG-900305 Open proof obligation
Theorem 17.2.6. (Comparison of the three sheaves). There are injective morphisms of sheaves The first sheaf is the original CLD sheaf. The last consists of piecewise smooth forms and is endowed with the polyhedral differentials . Both morphisms preserve wedge products and the indicated differentials. Weakly smooth forms admit functorial pullback by analytic morphisms.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Supply the exact inclusions and comparison of the smooth, weakly smooth and delta-form categories; GJR Proposition 10.14 and its supporting constructions.
NAG-900306 Open proof obligation
Proposition 17.2.7. (Harmonicity detected by the weak differential). A real-valued function on is harmonic if and only if
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove injectivity of pullback on the harmonic chart and the converse with the stated face hypotheses; GJR Proposition 10.9 supplies injectivity.
Example 17.2.8. (A harmonic function which is not CLD-smooth). Assume that is algebraically closed and that its residue field is not algebraic over a finite field. Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff construct a smooth proper genus-three curve with a theta graph as skeleton and an elliptic residual component at one vertex . Let be the origin of and choose a nontorsion point .
The local construction produces an integral harmonic function whose residue at has degree zero but represents On a smooth analytic curve, the quotient of harmonic germs by CLD-smooth harmonic germs at such a point is identified with this residual Picard space. Thus is weakly smooth by Proposition 17.2.7 and is not CLD-smooth. The construction and the nonvanishing obstruction are given in [GJR] (§17.3 and Proposition 17.4); the sheaf comparison used here is explained in Remark 15.10.
The obstruction is algebraic: degree zero only detects numerical triviality, while the nonzero Picard class prevents a representation by the local logarithms that give smooth harmonic functions. Hence the first inclusion in Theorem 17.2.6 can be strict even in bidegree .
Remark (Cases in which the first inclusion is equality). On a smooth analytic curve potentially locally isomorphic to , or over a residue field algebraic over a finite field, every harmonic function is CLD-smooth and [GJR] (Remark 15.10). Strictness is therefore not a statement about every analytic curve.
Strong currents and restriction of test spaces
Now assume that is Hausdorff, boundaryless, and of pure dimension . Write for compactly supported weakly smooth forms, endowed with the locally convex topology of [GJR] (§12.1). In charts, its defining convergence uses fixed compact support control and uniform convergence of every derivative of the representing Lagerberg forms.
Definition 17.2.10. (Strong currents, in the bidegree convention of these notes). Set where the prime denotes the continuous real dual. Its elements are the strong currents of bidegree .
In [GJR] (§12.2), the notation is : the indices record the degrees of the test forms. Thus their is our . The explicit dual formula is the reliable way to translate conventions.
NAG-900307 Conditional on stated inputs
NAG-900307 · Conditional on stated inputs
Proposition 17.2.11. (The direction of the comparison map). Restriction of functionals gives a canonical map Using the assertion in [GJR] (§12.1) that the original CLD test-space topology is the induced subspace topology, this map is surjective. Its kernel consists precisely of the functionals vanishing on all original smooth test forms. An extension of a smooth-test current is unique if those forms are dense in the weak test space.
Proof. Let and . Continuity of gives restriction . If , the induced subspace topology supplies a continuous seminorm on such that for every . The real Hahn–Banach theorem extends to a linear functional on dominated by , hence to an element of . This proves surjectivity. The kernel description is immediate; a continuous functional vanishing on a dense subspace vanishes everywhere. ◻
NAG-900308 Open proof obligation
NAG-900308 · Open proof obligation
Remark (What this proposition does not identify). The Hahn–Banach extension is not canonical and does not, by this argument, preserve positivity. Density is a separate question; it does not follow from the inclusion of sheaves. In particular, enlarging the test forms does not by itself give an inclusion of the corresponding spaces of currents, or an isomorphism of those spaces.
The differential of a strong current is defined by duality with the same total-degree signs as for smooth-test currents. Restriction commutes with and . Proper direct images and multiplication by weakly smooth forms are available [GJR] (§12.2). These constructions do not give arbitrary currents a wedge product or a pullback under every analytic morphism.
NAG-900309 Open proof obligation
Theorem 17.2.13. (Poincare–Lelong against weak tests). Let be a regular meromorphic function on , meaning locally a nonzero quotient of analytic functions that are non-zero-divisors on the local rings. Then
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove the Poincare–Lelong equality on the full weakly smooth test class of the statement; GJR Theorem 12.7 is supplied.
Example 17.2.14. (Polyhedral differentiation misses a corner mass). On , put and . This is a piecewise smooth function. On the two cells and it is affine, so Its current derivative is different. For a smooth compactly supported test function on the real skeleton, Consequently is twice the Dirac measure at the radius-one Gauss point. This explicitly distinguishes polyhedral differentiation from differentiation of currents. On this genus-zero curve weakly smooth forms agree with CLD-smooth forms; is not weakly smooth at that point.
For weakly smooth forms , Stokes gives and . For arbitrary piecewise smooth forms, these identities require the missing face terms; they cannot be inferred from the injection into currents in [GJR] (§12.4).
Positivity, regularization, and the scope of comparison
NAG-900310 Open proof obligation
Theorem 17.2.15. (Model positivity implies original current positivity). Let be good, separated, and strictly analytic. If is a semipositive -PL function, then the original CLD current is positive on . The same conclusion holds locally for uniform limits of semipositive PL metric weights.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove metric/current positivity and the converse with their exact hypotheses; GJR Theorem 7.14 and Remark 7.16 are supplied.
NAG-900311 Open proof obligation
Theorem 17.2.16. (Regularization on smooth analytic curves). Let be a rig-smooth boundaryless analytic curve over , and let be subharmonic in Thuillier’s sense. For every relatively compact open subset , there is a decreasing net of weakly smooth psh functions on converging pointwise to .
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove regularization on curves in the stated net and weakly smooth scope; GJR Proposition 15.11 is supplied.
NAG-900312 Open proof obligation
NAG-900312 · Open proof obligation
Remark 17.2.17 (Canonical metrics and an explicitly corrected argument). The canonical tropicalization in Raynaud uniformization is harmonic [GJR] (Proposition 16.2). It need not be CLD-smooth [GJR] (Corollary 17.5). Remark 16.4 explicitly explains that Gubler–Künnemann’s earlier argument in the 2017 paper, Examples 8.15 and 9.17, used the incorrect smoothness assertion to conclude that canonical metrics are -metrics. GJR leaves the latter conclusion open in the original -metric theory. This corrects the cited argument; it does not prove that the metrics are not -metrics.
The version concordance is recorded in Section 18.3.4; the elementary formula corrections are collected in Remark A.1.12.
17.3 Ordinary forms, G-forms, and harmonic forms in CLD25
The change of psh definition in CLD25 does not change its ordinary smooth test forms. Three sheaves must nevertheless be distinguished. We retain the good Hausdorff hypotheses on ; whenever currents enter the comparison, is purely -dimensional and boundaryless.
Definition 17.3.1. (The analytic affine and PL structures). An affine function in the sense of CLD25 is, locally for the ordinary topology, of the form A PL function is a continuous function which has this description -locally, on analytic domains. Finite sums are included in this description by clearing rational denominators and multiplying units. These are the structures of [CLD25] (Proposition 12.4.1 and §12.4.6). They use rational slopes and real constants; this notation does not silently mean arbitrary -PL functions.
Here a -cover consists of analytic domains such that, at each point, finitely many members containing that point have union a neighbourhood. An ordinary open cover is a -cover, but a -cover need not provide a single member which is a neighbourhood of a point on an interface.
Definition 17.3.2. (The two smooth sheaves). For a polyhedral subset of a real affine space , let denote smooth ambient superforms restricted to , modulo forms whose restrictions to the tangent spaces of every cell in vanish. More precisely, this is the quotient sheaf of [CLD25] (§1.9.1–§1.9.3); it is independent of subdivision.
For an analytic domain , form the direct limit where has PL coordinates, contains , and transition maps are affine maps between ambient spaces. Products of charts give common refinements. The associated sheaf on the analytic -site is denoted here. Its sections are the smooth -forms of [CLD25] (§3.3.3–Definition 3.3.4).
Write for the map to the ordinary topological site. The ordinary smooth sheaf consists of forms represented, on an ordinary neighbourhood of each point, by an affine chart and a smooth superform. This is [CLD25] (Definition 6.2.1).
NAG-900313 Open proof obligation
Proposition 17.3.3. (The ordinary sheaf is unchanged). There is a canonical identification It respects wedge product and the two differentials. The operators called correspond by the sign conversion already specified above.
Open proof obligation (RC2). Prove both local moment-map presentation and matching nullity of representatives on the common product chart; CLD25 Proposition 15.1.1(b), CLD12 Lemma 3.2.2 and CLD25 Proposition 3.4.4.
The distinction between the two sheaves is the covering condition, not the replacement of analytic units by arbitrary continuous coordinates. Indeed, [CLD25] (Proposition 15.1.1(a)) still presents every -form by analytic moment maps, but on a -cover. The ordinary smooth forms remain the test objects in [CLD25] (§7.1.1).
Definition 17.3.4. (The harmonic subsheaf). A PL function is harmonic in [CLD25] (Definition 7.8.2) if More general harmonic functions are defined to be local finite real linear combinations of such PL harmonic functions. The sheaf consists of -forms locally represented by , where has PL harmonic coordinates and is a smooth superform on a neighbourhood of a polyhedron containing ; see [CLD25] (§7.8.7).
Affine functions are harmonic, so these definitions give inclusions All three are differential algebras, but integration into currents has different differential properties. Denote the operators on -forms by . Every PL function satisfies because it is affine on a -cover. This does not imply : distributional differentiation can detect the interfaces. Already on the real line, has zero piecewise Hessian, whereas its distributional Hessian is . The harmonic condition is therefore an additional condition on a PL function.
For a harmonic form , the extra boundary terms vanish: This is [CLD25] (Theorem 7.8.5 and Corollary 7.8.8). The resulting map to currents is injective in the present boundaryless setting by [CLD25] (Corollary 7.3.9 and Theorem 12.11.1). It does not redefine currents as duals of all -forms.
NAG-900314 Open proof obligation
NAG-900314 · Open proof obligation
Remark 17.3.5 (Comparison with GJR requires a numerical theorem). CLD25 starts with a vanishing original curvature current for a PL function. GJR defines harmonicity through numerical triviality of the residual model class, with its own integral and real PL classes; see Definition 17.2.1. An identification of the two harmonic sheaves requires a PL curvature comparison with matching hypotheses, and then a comparison of their chart presentations. The degree-one vanishing assertion of [CLD25] (Theorem 18.8.4) addresses the numerical/current step for its integral PL metrics; its scope is discussed in Section 19.3. No unrestricted identification with the GJR weakly smooth sheaf is assumed here. Also, CLD25 does not define every continuous solution of to be harmonic: [CLD25] (Remark 7.8.3) explicitly distinguishes that question from the PL-generated definition.
17.4 Graph forms and harmonic cohomology
The first-order equations on a graph
Let be a finite connected metric graph without boundary, and choose orientations of its edges. On an open edge with coordinate , forms have the familiar expressions , , , and . At vertices, the smoothness conditions are those of the harmonic-coordinate graph calculus. In particular, the first-order compatibility is tied to a weighted conservation law.
For constant coefficients on oriented edges, closed -forms correspond to flows satisfying Kirchhoff’s law: the weighted outgoing coefficients sum to zero at each vertex. In the unweighted case, the incidence matrix has rank for a connected graph. Its kernel therefore has dimension This linear algebra explains the occurrence of the graph genus in . Subdividing an edge adds one vertex and one edge and leaves the dimension unchanged.
Why integration detects the top cohomology
For a compact graph without boundary, Stokes gives for a -form . Thus integration descends to a functional on . Conversely, a top-degree form of total integral zero can be integrated along edges to produce a primitive; constants of integration are chosen so that the vertex conditions hold. The obstruction is precisely the total integral.
This gives in the connected compact case. If the graph has boundary, flux may escape through boundary vertices, changing the obstruction and the cohomology. The source gives the exact boundary-dependent dimension formulas. The boundary must therefore be specified before applying a duality statement.
The circle as a complete example
For a circle of length , take a periodic coordinate on its universal cover. A closed -form has a constant coefficient after passing to its cohomology class, and its period is the invariant. A -form is exact precisely when its integral over one period is zero. A -form has a primitive of the required periodic type precisely when its total integral is zero. Hence the four cohomology groups in bidegrees all have dimension one.
The pairing of with is in the simplest constant representatives. It is nondegenerate. This gives a concrete model for the Poincaré duality proved in the curve theory, while retaining the metric length in the pairing.
The good-reduction curve as a contrasting example
A smooth proper curve with good reduction can have a one-point skeleton and first Betti number zero. Its weakly smooth Dolbeault groups in bidegrees and are therefore zero in the cited theorem, while remains one-dimensional by integration. If the algebraic genus is positive, algebraic differential forms still exist; they belong to a different cohomology theory.
This example prevents a misleading inference from the graph picture. The weakly smooth calculus is designed to have robust tropical analytic properties and duality. It is not claimed to reproduce every algebraic Hodge number. To compare it with algebraic de Rham theory, one would need an additional construction accounting for the residual geometry.
From graph forms to analytic forms
The passage to Berkovich curves uses skeleta adapted to the forms and harmonic maps between graph presentations. It is not a claim that every form factors through one minimal skeleton. Enlarging a skeleton can add trees and local coordinates while preserving the appropriate cohomological information. Compatibility under these changes is what makes the analytic sheaf and its cohomology intrinsic.
This gives a successful example of the general strategy discussed in Chapter 24: first understand a finite tropical complex, then prove compatibility under refinement, then identify the resulting analytic cohomology. The proof contains more than a topological deformation retraction, because the differential and vertex-smoothness conditions also have to be preserved.
References. [GJRc] (Sections 2–3 and Theorems 6.4.3, 6.4.5).
17.5 The differential complex on a compact graph
We give the graph calculation underlying the curve comparison. It is useful both as a complete example of a differential theory and as a warning about what a skeleton retains. Let be a finite connected metric graph with at least one edge. We first take all edge weights to be one and no designated boundary. Multiple edges and loops are allowed; a loop contributes two outgoing germs at its vertex.
Choose an orientation of every edge and a parameter . A smooth function is continuous on , smooth up to each endpoint on each edge, and satisfies the following local conditions. At a vertex of valency one it is constant nearby. At valency two it is an ordinary smooth function across the vertex. At higher valency its outgoing first derivatives have sum zero.
A -form has edgewise expressions . Reversing orientation reverses the coefficient. At a leaf it vanishes nearby, at a two-valent vertex the one-form extends smoothly across, and at higher valency its outgoing coefficients have sum zero. The definition of -forms is identical with . A -form has expressions , unchanged by orientation reversal. It vanishes near leaves, is smooth across two-valent vertices, and has no extra matching condition at higher-valent vertices. These are the unweighted GJR graph conventions.
The edgewise formulas are The vertex conditions ensure that these derivatives lie in the indicated form spaces. They also imply Stokes: the endpoint terms of sum to the outgoing coefficient sums, hence vanish.
The incidence matrix
Let denote the vertices and the chosen oriented edges. Define by putting at an edge’s tail and at its head; a loop column is zero. Connectedness implies Indeed the columns have coordinate sum zero. Along a path, signed sums of columns produce the difference of the two endpoint basis vectors. Since any vertex can be joined to a fixed one, these differences span the zero-sum hyperplane. We write .
NAG-900315 Proof review pending
Proposition 17.5.1. The -closed -forms are exactly the edgewise constant forms whose coefficient vector belongs to . Consequently and .
Proof. The displayed formula for forces on each edge. The vertex conditions then reduce to . At a leaf this equation forces the incident constant to be zero, so the required vanishing on a neighbourhood follows as well. At valency two it makes the constants match with the orientation signs. Conversely these conditions give a smooth closed form. There are no forms of type , hence no boundaries in this group. ◻
NAG-900316 Proof review pending
Theorem 17.5.2. (Periods and exactness). Integration around cycles induces an isomorphism
Proof. For a -form , set . The period on a cycle is . If , these integrals are endpoint differences and all periods vanish.
Conversely suppose all periods vanish. Fix a basepoint and define by integrating along a path from it to . Any two paths differ by cycles, so is well defined. It is continuous and has derivative on each edge. Near a leaf, , so is constant. At a two-valent vertex, smooth matching of the one-form gives smooth matching of its primitive. At a higher-valent vertex, the outgoing derivatives of are the outgoing coefficients of , whose sum is zero. Thus belongs to and .
To prove surjectivity, represent a functional on by some vector . On each edge choose a smooth bump supported strictly inside the edge and of integral . These coefficients define a -form because they vanish near every vertex. Its periods are the prescribed functional. ◻
This proof is stronger than a dimension count: it supplies an exactness criterion and a primitive. It also shows why smoothness at vertices cannot be ignored. Edgewise primitives always exist, but their values and derivatives must satisfy the graph’s matching conditions.
NAG-900317 Proof review pending
Theorem 17.5.3. (Top-degree exactness). The image of is precisely the kernel of integration. Hence .
Proof. Stokes gives one inclusion. For the other, let have total integral zero and put . An edgewise solution is At a tail the outgoing coefficient is ; at a head it is . Therefore the vertex equations are The right side has total sum . By the description of , constants solving these equations exist. They give the value matching at two-valent vertices and the coefficient sums at higher-valent ones. Derivative matching at a two-valent vertex follows by differentiating and using the smooth matching of . At a leaf, vanishes nearby and the vertex equation sets to zero there. Thus is an admitted -form and .
An interior bump on any one edge gives a -form of nonzero integral, proving that integration is surjective on the quotient. ◻
NAG-900318 Proof review pending
Corollary 17.5.4. (Graph duality). For this compact connected graph, Integration of wedge products gives perfect pairings between complementary bidegrees.
Proof. A function with zero edge derivatives is constant by connectedness, giving . The other dimensions were proved above. For and , write the first class as a constant flow and the second by its edge integrals . Their pairing is . It is the natural pairing of with its dual from Theorem 17.5.2, hence perfect. Constants pair perfectly with the integral coordinate of . Stokes ensures independence of representatives. ◻
What changes when a boundary is designated
Let be nonempty and impose no vertex matching condition there, apart from continuity of functions. Write for the incidence matrix with only the rows indexed by . These rows are independent. Indeed a linear relation, extended by zero at boundary vertices, gives a vector in , hence a constant vector; because it is zero at one boundary vertex, it is zero everywhere.
NAG-900319 Proof review pending
Proposition 17.5.5. For a connected graph with nonempty designated boundary,
Proof. Closed -forms are the constant flows in , whose dimension is . The period proof for is unchanged: path integration still gives a continuous primitive and there are fewer endpoint conditions to check. The proof of top-degree exactness now solves the vertex equations only at interior vertices. Since is onto, these equations always have a solution, with no total-integral constraint. Thus every -form is exact. ◻
For an interval with both endpoints designated as boundary, and . For the same interval with no designated boundary, the leaf conditions give and . The topological interval alone does not determine this differential complex: the boundary convention is part of its data.
Weights and the curve comparison
If an edge has positive weight , put , so its new length is . Pullback replaces a one-form coefficient by and a two-form coefficient by . The weighted vertex conditions become the preceding unweighted ones. Since , this is an isomorphism of differential algebras. Its integration rule agrees with .
The passage from these graph groups to weakly smooth forms on a Berkovich curve is a separate theorem. In the setting of GJR’s curve paper, a suitable strictly semistable model gives a pullback from graph forms inducing the cohomology isomorphism. Finite extension and Galois descent handle a curve without such a model over the initial field. We use that comparison, not a claim that every continuous retraction induces an isomorphism of differential complexes.
In particular, a skeleton consisting of one isolated point has no graph -forms under the definitions above. It cannot by itself compute the top-degree cohomology of a proper analytic curve. The comparison theorem uses an appropriate model; one may blow up to avoid smooth connected components of the special fibre and obtain a nontrivial skeleton. Attaching the resulting tree does not change , but it supplies the graph differential data needed for top-degree integration.
17.6 Residual genus and topological genus
The discrepancy between algebraic genus and graph genus can be calculated without differential forms. Let be a connected proper nodal curve over an algebraically closed field. Let be its normalized irreducible components and let be its dual graph. There is one vertex per component and one edge per node, including loop edges for self-nodes.
NAG-900320 Proof review pending
Proposition 17.6.1. The arithmetic genus satisfies
Proof. Normalization gives an exact sequence At a node, the last map takes the difference of the two branch values. Its exactness follows from the local description : a pair of power series in and comes from this ring exactly when its constant terms agree. Taking Euler characteristics yields Since is connected and proper, . Thus , as asserted. ◻
For a proper semistable model of a smooth curve, constancy of Euler characteristic in the flat family identifies this arithmetic genus with the genus of the generic fibre. The skeleton retains the graph contribution ; the remaining summands are genera of residual components. Good reduction gives a one-vertex dual graph and all the genus is residual. Totally degenerate reduction has genus-zero residual components and all the genus is graph-theoretic.
Consequently the weakly smooth cohomology formula cannot be identified with the dimension of algebraic differentials without an additional hypothesis. For a good-reduction elliptic curve these dimensions are respectively zero and one. This does not contradict either theory: their complexes retain different information. In a proposed tropical-to-Berkovich comparison, the relevant sheaf and the treatment of residual components must be specified before drawing a Hodge-theoretic conclusion.
References. Graph definitions and the unweighting are [GJRc] (Section 2.2); the graph calculation above is an explicit incidence-matrix proof of the cohomology and duality statements. The analytic comparison is [GJRc] (Theorems 6.4.2–6.4.5).
17.7 Residual divisors and harmonic coordinates
A harmonic function on a curve satisfies a conservation law for outgoing slopes. An original smooth harmonic function satisfies an additional local algebraic condition. The difference is visible on the residual curve of a type II point. This section calculates that difference and then revisits the canonical tropicalization example of Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff with consistent coordinates.
Work over a complete algebraically closed nontrivially valued field . At a type II point of a smooth analytic curve, the residual function field determines a smooth projective curve over . Its closed points correspond to tangent directions. We use the slope formula: for an analytic meromorphic function whose normalized reduction at is , outgoing slopes of are the orders of , with the sign reversed for . The identification of tangent directions and this slope formula are geometric inputs; they are not consequences of the abstract graph calculation.
The sign can be checked in the open disc direction at the Gauss point: with outward distance , the reduction of has order one at , while has outgoing slope .
NAG-900321 Proof review pending
Proposition 17.7.1. Let be a harmonic germ represented by a PL function on a finite star at . If is its outgoing slope in the direction , then If is a real linear combination of logarithms of local analytic units, then has zero class in .
Proof. Only finitely many directions have a nonzero slope, so the divisor is defined. Harmonicity is precisely the vanishing of the outgoing slope sum; the residual field is algebraically closed, so all residual points have degree one. For , the slope formula identifies with , hence with a principal divisor. Multiplying by a real scalar and adding preserves the zero divisor class. Constants have all slopes zero. ◻
The converse is not asserted from this calculation alone: lifting a residual principal relation to analytic units is a local analytic theorem. Thuillier’s comparison identifies the relevant quotient of harmonic germs by smooth harmonic germs with in the curve setting used below. GJR records this input in Remark 15.10 and the proof of Proposition 17.4. It also records that original smooth harmonic germs are the sheaf generated by logarithms of analytic units. We use these two comparison results explicitly.
NAG-900322 Proof review pending
Corollary 17.7.2. In this setting, a harmonic germ with nonzero class cannot be an original smooth function. A degree-zero residual divisor is therefore not enough to guarantee original smoothness.
Proof. If the germ were original smooth, it would be a smooth harmonic germ, hence a real linear combination of logarithms of analytic units. Proposition 17.7.1 would make its residual class zero. ◻
NAG-900323 Proof review pending
Example 17.7.3. (Why the residue field matters). If a smooth projective curve is defined over an algebraic closure of a finite field, every point of its Jacobian is torsion. Indeed the variety and any chosen point descend to a finite field; the group of points over that finite field is finite. Thus . Over other algebraically closed fields, an elliptic residual curve can have nontorsion points, and their degree-zero divisor classes survive tensoring with . For an abelian group , the kernel of is its torsion subgroup, and extension from to is faithful. This justifies the last assertion. The vanishing of the residual obstruction is consistent with the equality of the two harmonic sheaves in the finite-residue-field case; the analytic equality itself uses the cited comparison theorem.
17.8 A consistent theta-graph calculation
Let be three edges from to , all oriented in that direction, with lengths . Choose the cycles The notation means traverse from to and return along the indicated other edge. Use the basis dual to on . The edge-length pairing has matrix Thus is a full lattice in , and the graph Jacobian is . The positivity also follows directly from the positive edge-length pairing on the cycle space.
NAG-900324 Proof review pending
Proposition 17.8.1. A lift of the Abel–Jacobi map based at , on a star around , has the following formulas, where is distance from : Modulo , these formulas agree at and define a continuous map on the whole graph. Each coordinate is harmonic near .
Proof. Integrating the two harmonic one-forms corresponding to gives coefficient vectors on , on , and on . Their sums at vanish. At , the three lifted values are , , and . Their differences from the third are the negatives of the first and second columns of , so they represent the same point of the quotient. The period of each cycle is the corresponding column of , as required by the Abel–Jacobi definition. ◻
Attach an elliptic curve at , with the directions marked by distinct points , where is the identity and are nontorsion. Attach a projective line at , with three distinct markings. The lifting theorem for metrized complexes, used in GJR Section 17.3, realizes this data by a smooth proper analytic curve after choosing the lengths in the value group. This realization and compatibility of analytic and tropical Abel–Jacobi maps are the two geometric inputs in the example.
NAG-900325 Proof review pending
Theorem 17.8.2. (The residual obstruction in the example). The two lifted coordinate functions are harmonic but not original smooth near . Their outgoing-slope divisors are respectively Consequently the canonical tropicalization of the Jacobian of the realized curve need not be an original smooth tropicalization.
Proof. Proposition 17.8.1 gives the slope lists and . Each has sum zero, giving harmonicity. Matching the directions with the three residual markings gives the displayed divisors. The standard identification sends to . Nontorsion of and Example 17.7.3 show that both classes remain nonzero after tensoring with . Corollary 17.7.2 proves nonsmoothness. The analytic Abel–Jacobi map identifies these local functions with pullbacks of local coordinates of the canonical tropicalization of the Jacobian. If that tropicalization were original smooth, pullback of original smooth functions by the analytic map would make these functions original smooth, a contradiction. The realized curve has genus , using the graph and residual genus formula of Proposition 17.6.1; hence this produces the abelian threefold of GJR. ◻
Remark 17.8.3 (Two coordinate slips in the cited version). In GJR v3, Section 17.2 names the first cycle as and the second as , but its Gram matrix and Abel–Jacobi formulas use the opposite ordering. Taking as above makes the displayed formulas consistent. In the proof of Proposition 17.4, the printed first-coordinate slope list along is incompatible with both those formulas and the subsequently stated divisor . The list gives the stated divisor. These are indexing and slope corrections; they preserve the non-smoothness example. In particular, one should not use the printed list to replace by : distinct nontorsion do not by themselves imply that is nontorsion.
17.9 Consequences for the choice of differential sheaf
A harmonic tropicalization is built from local numerical harmonic functions, including the functions above. Pullback of a real smooth function along such a map is weakly smooth by definition. Original smoothness, on the other hand, requires presentation through logarithms of analytic units. The obstruction is therefore a change of coordinate class, not a failure of the elementary real chain rule.
For a smooth real function and harmonic coordinates , the weakly smooth calculus has The first-derivative terms vanish in that calculus because there. This is not a proof that are original smooth functions, and it cannot be inserted into the original smooth Leibniz rule against an arbitrary original current without a comparison theorem. Chapter 14 isolates exactly that background-current kernel requirement.
The example also explains the limitation of an earlier argument about canonical metrics. GK17 used smoothness of canonical tropicalizations to claim that all canonical metrics on abelian varieties are original delta-metrics. GJR Remark 16.4 explicitly withdraws that argument: its conclusion requires a further proof, while weakly smooth coordinates are available. The non-smooth coordinate example does not by itself prove that a particular canonical metric fails to be an original delta-metric; a metric might admit another presentation. This distinction between a failed presentation argument and a false existence statement is essential when citing the correction.
References. [GJR] (Remark 15.10, Proposition 15.11, Proposition 16.2, Remark 16.4, Sections 17.1–17.4); the graph calculation above fixes all orientations before applying the cited geometric comparisons.