Conditional

Theorem 21.15.1 requires tropical equidistribution and canonical-measure inputs

Theorem 21.15.1. A positive-dimensional integral subvariety X⊂AX\subset A with finite stabilizer cannot have Zariski-dense points of arbitrarily small Néron–Tate height.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. Suppose otherwise and put d=dim⁡X>0d=\dim X>0. Choose NN as in Proposition 21.14.1 and let Y=α(XN)Y=\alpha(X^N). Then dim⁡Y=Nd\dim Y=Nd. The external tensor product polarization on XNX^N has height equal to the sum of the heights of its coordinates. Dense small points on XX therefore give dense small points on XNX^N. More explicitly, the product of a Zariski-dense set with itself is dense; directing finite avoidance conditions and height bounds gives a generic net Pj∈XNP_j\in X^N with height tending to zero. Its image is generic in YY, since inverse images of proper closed subsets of YY are proper closed subsets of XNX^N. Quadratic height estimates for the difference homomorphism make the image heights tend to zero. Let μ\mu and ν\nu be the normalized tropical canonical measures on Trop⁡(X)N\operatorname{Trop}(X)^N and Trop⁡(Y)\operatorname{Trop}(Y). Equidistribution and compatibility of normalized finite Galois-orbit measures with the map give αtrop⁡,∗μ=ν,αtrop⁡(u1,…,uN)=(u2−u1,…,uN−uN−1).\alpha_{\operatorname{trop},*}\mu=\nu, \qquad \alpha_{\operatorname{trop}}(u_1,\ldots,u_N) =(u_2-u_1,\ldots,u_N-u_{N-1}). For completeness, a map of finite transitive Galois sets has fibres of equal cardinality, so the pushforward of uniform orbit measure is uniform orbit measure. Pushforward of weak convergence by a continuous map follows by testing against pullbacks of continuous functions. Choose a small compact dd-dimensional polytope σ\sigma in the relative interior of a top cell of Trop⁡(X)\operatorname{Trop}(X), contained in one affine lift of the real torus. The product σN\sigma^N has dimension NdNd and strictly positive μ\mu-mass. If VV is the dd-dimensional tangent space of σ\sigma, the differential of αtrop⁡\alpha_{\operatorname{trop}} on VNV^N kills the diagonal copy of VV. Hence dim⁡αtrop⁡(σN)≤(N−1)d<Nd.\dim\alpha_{\operatorname{trop}}(\sigma^N)\leq(N-1)d<Nd. The compact image τ=αtrop⁡(σN)\tau=\alpha_{\operatorname{trop}}(\sigma^N) is a lower-dimensional polyhedral subset of Trop⁡(Y)\operatorname{Trop}(Y), so ν(τ)=0\nu(\tau)=0. But the measure identity implies 0<μ(σN)≤μ(αtrop⁡−1(τ))=ν(τ)=0,0<\mu(\sigma^N)\leq\mu(\alpha_{\operatorname{trop}}^{-1}(\tau))=\nu(\tau)=0, a contradiction. This last inequality uses a Borel set directly; no choice of a continuous cutoff equal only at a single point would suffice in its place. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-900424.

Proof in chapter