Closed

Attaching the two ends of a nodal tube

Proposition 4.20.3. (Attaching the two ends of a nodal tube). Let X\mathcal X be a curve model and suppose given a pointed étale diagram (X,q)⟵(U,u)⟶(Wa,0ˉ),Wa=Spec⁡O[s,t]/(st−a),0<∣a∣<1,(\mathcal X,q)\longleftarrow(U,u)\longrightarrow (W_a,\bar0),\qquad W_a=\operatorname{Spec}O[s,t]/(st-a),\quad 0<|a|<1, where UU is affine and the three selected special-fibre points are kk-rational. In Y=U^ηY=\widehat U_\eta, put D=]u[D=]u[ and C=D‾C=\overline D. Let vt,vsv_t,v_s be the component points of the branches t=0,s=0t=0,s=0, respectively. Then D≃AK(∣a∣,1),C=D∪{vt,vs},∣s(vt)∣=1,∣s(vs)∣=∣a∣.D\simeq A_K(|a|,1),\qquad C=D\cup\{v_t,v_s\},\qquad |s(v_t)|=1,\quad |s(v_s)|=|a|. Every net in DD whose ∣s∣|s| tends to 11 converges to vtv_t; every net whose ∣s∣|s| tends to ∣a∣|a| converges to vsv_s. For each neighborhood of either endpoint in CC, a full radial tail of DD is contained in that neighborhood. The image of CC in XX is Cq=]q[‾C_q=\overline{]q[}; the only possible identification is that of vtv_t with vsv_s. The two endpoints map to the component points of the corresponding branches of qq.

Proof

Proof. The entire-tube isomorphisms of Corollary 4.17.3 identify ss with the annular coordinate. Write Us=Spec⁡SU_s=\operatorname{Spec}S and A=k[s,t]/(st)A=k[s,t]/(st). The given map U→WaU\to W_a induces the étale morphism Spec⁡S→Spec⁡A\operatorname{Spec}S\to\operatorname{Spec}A by base change, by [StacksAlg] (Tag 02GO). In particular SS is of finite type over kk. The two branch fields are Ft=k(s)F_t=k(s) and Fs=k(t)F_s=k(t). The map A→Ft×FsA\to F_t\times F_s is injective since (s)∩(t)=0(s)\cap(t)=0 in AA. Tensoring with SS gives the injective map S⟶(S⊗AFt)×(S⊗AFs).S\longrightarrow (S\otimes_A F_t)\times (S\otimes_A F_s). Indeed, for each prime q\mathfrak q of SS over p\mathfrak p of AA, the corresponding local map Ap→SqA_{\mathfrak p}\to S_{\mathfrak q} is flat by [StacksAlg] (Tag 02GU(1) and (2)). Localizing the displayed map at q\mathfrak q thus gives an injection at every prime. By [StacksAlg] (Tag 02GL(2)), each of the two affine fibres is a finite disjoint union of spectra of finite separable extensions of its branch field. Either fibre may be empty. This proves that SS is reduced.

If q\mathfrak q is minimal in SS, its contraction is minimal in AA. Otherwise the contraction contains an element outside both minimal primes of AA, by avoidance of these two primes. Such an element is a nonzerodivisor on SS by the displayed injection. But its image in the nonzero field SqS_{\mathfrak q} would be zero, a contradiction. For a minimal q\mathfrak q over the branch prime p\mathfrak p, localize S/qS/\mathfrak q at the nonzero elements of A/pA/\mathfrak p. The result is a nonzero domain quotient of the corresponding affine fibre algebra, hence a finite extension of that branch field. It is the fraction field of S/qS/\mathfrak q. Its transcendence degree over kk is one, so [StacksAlg] (Tag 00P0) gives dim⁡(S/q)=1\dim(S/\mathfrak q)=1. Thus the special fibre of UU is a reduced pure one-dimensional curve. Lemma 4.20.2 gives exactly the two components through uu. Lemma 4.20.1 gives C∖D⊆{vt,vs}C\setminus D\subseteq\{v_t,v_s\}. At vtv_t, the reduction of ss is nonzero, so ∣s(vt)∣=1|s(v_t)|=1; at vsv_s, the reduction of tt is nonzero, so ∣t(vs)∣=1|t(v_s)|=1 and st=ast=a gives ∣s(vs)∣=∣a∣|s(v_s)|=|a|.

The affinoid YY is compact Hausdorff. A net in DD whose ∣s∣|s| tends to 11 has cluster points in CC, and continuity of ∣s∣|s| forces every cluster point to be vtv_t. Compactness then implies convergence to vtv_t: otherwise a subnet outside a fixed neighborhood would have a cluster point there. The inner end is identical. Applying this to the Gauss points with radii tending to the two endpoints proves that both vtv_t and vsv_s belong to CC. If NN is a neighborhood of vtv_t in CC, the compact set C∖NC\setminus N has max⁡∣s∣<1\max|s|<1 after replacing NN by an open subneighborhood. Thus a full outer tail lies in NN. The minimum of ∣s∣|s| on a compact complement similarly proves the inner-tail assertion.

By Lemma 4.20.2, the two residual generic points map to component generic points of Xs\mathcal X_s. Functoriality of specialization and uniqueness of component points identify the images of vt,vsv_t,v_s. The image of compact CC is closed in Hausdorff XX and contains ]q[]q[. Conversely, continuity and density of DD in CC put that image inside ]q[‾\overline{]q[}. The restriction D→]q[D\to]q[ is an isomorphism, and an endpoint cannot map into ]q[]q[ because its specialization is generic. Consequently only the two endpoints can be identified. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002056, 4.20.3.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record