Proposition 4.45.6. (Necessity of the geometric marked forest condition). Let be a morphism of marked semistable algebraic models inducing the identity on and on the generic marking. Then , and this subset satisfies the marked forest condition in .
Proof
Proof. Complete along . Lemma 4.40.4 gives the vertex inclusion. Extend the original absolute value isometrically to the comparison field of Lemma 4.45.1. Both base-changed models are actual projective flat nodal -models of , and their analytic generic fibres are by Lemma 4.28.1. Their nodes have split rational pointed charts: Theorem 4.18.2 applies, and a finite extension of the algebraically closed field is itself. Thus the algebraically closed model results apply to these models.
Proposition 4.45.2 identifies their vertex sets with the entire inverse images of the two original vertex sets. Put and . For a component of meeting , Lemma 4.41.2 shows that the source skeleton in is a finite tree with one or two boundary ends, and all its component curves are smooth . Its vertices and internal edges are exactly one connected component of the induced removed graph. Its boundary ends are exactly the attaching branches, counted separately even when they end at the same protected component.
The set is the actual tube of a closed point of the target. For every removed component with generic point , functorial specialization gives . Since is closed, every point of that component, including all its marked specializations, also maps to . If , the target point is smooth, and the closed immersion has at most one geometric point over it. Thus . If , then is nodal and the marking avoids it, so . This proves the stated condition on every removed geometric tree. ◻