Closed

Algebraic uniqueness of an exact contraction

Proposition 4.45.7. (Algebraic uniqueness of an exact contraction). Let qi:C0→Ciq_i:\mathcal C_0\to\mathcal C_i, i=1,2i=1,2, be morphisms of semistable algebraic models inducing the identity on CC. If the targets have the same component vertices in CanC^{\mathrm{an}}, there is a unique algebraic isomorphism h:C1→C2h:\mathcal C_1\to\mathcal C_2 with q2=h∘q1q_2=h\circ q_1. It induces the identity on CC.

Proof

Proof. After extension to Ω\Omega, the target vertex sets are the same by Proposition 4.45.2. The split pointed charts supplied by Theorem 4.18.2 complete to the charts of Definition 4.39.4, as in the proof of Corollary 4.42.6. Corollary 4.39.5 gives the connected open tubes and their exact component-incidence boundaries. Their completed models are isomorphic over CΩanC_\Omega^{\mathrm{an}} by Proposition 4.40.3. Write hsh_s for the resulting special-fibre isomorphism. It intertwines their specialization maps. Functoriality of specialization and its surjectivity on the source, both in Proposition 3.17.2, give hs∘(q1)k‾=(q2)k‾h_s\circ(q_1)_{\overline k} =(q_2)_{\overline k} on the underlying geometric special-fibre points. Consequently (q2)k‾(q_2)_{\overline k} is constant on every set-theoretic fibre of (q1)k‾(q_1)_{\overline k}.

We descend this assertion about actual fibres. Every field extension is faithfully flat: its only base ideals are zero and the whole field, so [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HD) gives flatness, and its nonzero closed fibre gives faithful flatness by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HP). If t1,t2∈C0,st_1,t_2\in\mathcal C_{0,s} have the same image yy under (q1)s(q_1)_s, the tensor product κ(t1)⊗κ(y)κ(t2)\kappa(t_1)\otimes_{\kappa(y)}\kappa(t_2) is nonzero by the same faithful-flatness criterion. By [StacksAlg] (Tag 00E0(2)), a prime of this tensor product supplies a point of C0,s×C1,sC0,s\mathcal C_{0,s}\times_{\mathcal C_{1,s}}\mathcal C_{0,s} whose two projections are t1,t2t_1,t_2. The extension k‾/k\overline k/k is faithfully flat by the preceding argument. On an affine base change, its tensor functor on modules is the original coefficient tensor functor, so remains faithfully flat. Surjectivity on spectra, [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HQ), lifts the chosen point to the base-changed fibre product. The lifted projections have the same (q1)k‾(q_1)_{\overline k}-image, hence the same (q2)k‾(q_2)_{\overline k}-image. Projecting back gives (q2)s(t1)=(q2)s(t2)(q_2)_s(t_1)=(q_2)_s(t_2). On the generic fibre q1q_1 and q2q_2 are identities. These two fibres exhaust the rank-one base, and their images cannot meet. Thus q2q_2 is constant on every fibre of q1q_1.

The morphisms qiq_i are proper: their graphs are closed in the products over OO, and projection from those products is proper. Their targets are normal and integral by Proposition 4.44.3. Lemma 4.44.4 gives an actual algebraic factorization hh. Interchanging the indices gives its inverse; uniqueness of factorization shows that the composites are the identity. This proves both the assertion and its uniqueness. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002276, 4.45.7.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record