Closed

The weak numerical conditions do not characterize vertices

Theorem 4.55.3. (The weak numerical conditions do not characterize vertices). Use KK, qq, LL and α\alpha from Proposition 4.55.2. Let J=GL(Y)J=G_L(Y) and put X=α+qYX=\alpha+qY in JJ. Restriction of this absolute value to K(X)K(X) defines a point v∈(PK1)anv\in(\mathbf P^1_K)^{\mathrm{an}} satisfying H(v)=GL(Y),∣H(v)×∣=∣K×∣,H(v)~=Fp(y).\begin{aligned} \mathcal H(v)&=G_L(Y),\\ |\mathcal H(v)^\times|&=|K^\times|,\qquad \widetilde{\mathcal H(v)}=\mathbf F_p(y). \end{aligned} Nevertheless vv is not a component vertex of any semistable algebraic model over the original K∘K^\circ in Definition 4.45.3.

The actual rational Gauss coordinate u=Xp−X−q−1qu=\frac{X^p-X-q^{-1}}q has ∣u(v)∣=1|u(v)|=1 and residue −y-y, and K(X)/K(u)K(X)/K(u) is finite separable. Its completed extension satisfies [H(v):GK(u)]=p,[H(v)~:Fp(uˉ)]=1.[\mathcal H(v):G_K(u)]=p, \qquad [\widetilde{\mathcal H(v)}:\mathbf F_p(\bar u)]=1. Thus the obstruction occurs on a curve which already has the smooth original model PK∘1\mathbf P^1_{K^\circ}.

Proof

Proof. The element XX is transcendental over KK, since YY is transcendental over LL. Its induced multiplicative seminorm on K[X]K[X] gives an affine analytic point by Theorem 2.33.23, and hence a point of the analytic projective line by Proposition 2.33.24. Proposition 2.33.28 identifies its completed residue field with the closure of K(X)K(X) in JJ. Set b=Xp−X−q−1=qpYp−qY.b=X^p-X-q^{-1}=q^pY^p-qY. The Gauss norm gives ∣b∣=∣q∣=ρ<1|b|=|q|=\rho<1. The series z=∑i≥0bpiz=\sum_{i\geq0}b^{p^i} converges in H(v)\mathcal H(v), satisfies zp−z=−bz^p-z=-b, and has norm at most ρ\rho. Hence X+zX+z is a root of PP. Its difference from α\alpha has norm at most ρ<1\rho<1, whereas every other root α+c\alpha+c, 0≠c∈Fp0\ne c\in\mathbf F_p, is at distance one from α\alpha. Therefore X+z=αX+z=\alpha. It follows that H(v)\mathcal H(v) contains LL and Y=(X−α)/qY=(X-\alpha)/q. Since L(Y)L(Y) is dense in JJ, it equals JJ. The unit Gauss calculation of Proposition 4.50.2, applied over LL, now gives the displayed value group and residue field.

We have u=qp−1Yp−Yu=q^{p-1}Y^p-Y, so ∣u∣=1|u|=1 and uˉ=−y\bar u=-y. Reduction of a normalized nonzero polynomial in uu shows that its induced norm is the unit Gauss norm, over both KK and LL. In GL(u)G_L(u) iterate Y0=−u,Yr+1=qp−1Yrp−u.Y_0=-u,\qquad Y_{r+1}=q^{p-1}Y_r^p-u. All iterates have norm at most one. Their successive differences decrease to zero, since the map has Lipschitz constant at most ∣q∣p−1<1|q|^{p-1}<1 on that ball. The element Y∈JY\in J is its fixed point, and the same estimate shows Yr→YY_r\to Y in JJ. The complete subfield GL(u)G_L(u) is closed, so it contains YY. Consequently J=GL(u)J=G_L(u), and Lemma 4.55.1 gives [J:GK(u)]=[L:K]=p[J:G_K(u)]=[L:K]=p. The residual degree is one because uˉ=−y\bar u=-y. The equation Xp−X−q−1−qu=0X^p-X-q^{-1}-qu=0 makes K(X)/K(u)K(X)/K(u) finite, and its derivative −1-1 makes the extension separable.

It remains to exclude all original models, not just this particular coordinate. Choose the comparison field Ω\Omega of Lemma 4.45.1, using an algebraic closure containing LL. For every c∈Fpc\in\mathbf F_p let wcw_c be the Gauss point over Ω\Omega of the disc ∣X−(α+c)∣≤∣q∣.|X-(\alpha+c)|\leq|q|. The map α↦α+c\alpha\mapsto\alpha+c defines a KK-automorphism of LL, and is isometric by Lemma 1.12.1. Applied coefficientwise to any polynomial in K[X]K[X], it shows that every wcw_c restricts to vv. These points are distinct: at wcw_c, the function X−(α+c)X-(\alpha+c) has norm ∣q∣|q|, while at wc′w_{c'} for c′≠cc'\ne c it has norm one.

Suppose vv were a model component vertex, with special component EE. Proposition 4.45.2 gives k(E)=Fp(y)k(E)=\mathbf F_p(y) and identifies the entire geometric inverse image of vv with the component generic points above EE. That set has one element. Indeed, Fp(y)⊗FpF‾p=F‾p(y)\mathbf F_p(y)\otimes_{\mathbf F_p} \overline{\mathbf F}_p =\overline{\mathbf F}_p(y) is a field. To verify the equality, every finite coefficient extension k′/Fpk'/\mathbf F_p stays linearly independent over Fp(y)\mathbf F_p(y), by clearing polynomial denominators. The tensor with k′k' is therefore a finite-dimensional domain and hence a field; it contains the inverses of all nonzero polynomials with coefficients in k′k'. Taking the union over these finite coefficient fields proves the equality. The comparison-field residue is F‾p\overline{\mathbf F}_p by Lemma 4.45.1. The pp distinct points wcw_c above vv contradict this singleton-fibre conclusion. Thus no such original model can have vv as a component vertex. Finally, the standard model PK∘1\mathbf P^1_{K^\circ} has its two polynomial affine charts, flat by the coefficientwise ideal criterion [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HD) and smooth with their displayed coordinates. It is projective and its special fibre is the geometrically integral projective line. It belongs to the stated model category. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002440, 4.55.3.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record