Closed

A nonrational component cannot disappear

Proposition 4.57.1. (A nonrational component cannot disappear). Let C/KC/K be a smooth projective geometrically connected curve. Suppose Y/Ω∘\mathcal Y/\Omega^\circ is a semistable algebraic model of CΩC_\Omega, and let ww be the component vertex of a special component EE whose function field k‾(E)\overline k(E) is not rational. Then every semistable algebraic model X/O\mathcal X/O of CC satisfies w∈V(XΩ∘),p(w)∈V(X).w\in V(\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ}), \qquad p(w)\in V(\mathcal X). Consequently, if CC has such an original-field model, the point v=p(w)v=p(w) must satisfy ∣H(v)×∣=∣K×∣,H(v)~/k is separably generated of transcendence degree one.\begin{aligned} |\mathcal H(v)^\times|&=|K^\times|,\\ \widetilde{\mathcal H(v)}/k &\text{ is separably generated of transcendence degree one}. \end{aligned} Failure of either condition at vv rules out every original-field semistable algebraic model, including every such marked model.

Proof

Proof. Assume X\mathcal X exists. Its coefficient extension XΩ∘\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ} is a semistable algebraic model of the same curve as Y\mathcal Y, by Lemma 4.28.1 and preservation of the nodal relative-curve condition under base change, [StacksAlg] (Tag 0C5B). Apply Theorem 4.47.5 over the complete field Ω\Omega, with empty marking. It supplies an actual semistable model T/Ω∘\mathcal T/\Omega^\circ and generic-identity morphisms T⟶Y,T⟶XΩ∘.\mathcal T\longrightarrow\mathcal Y, \qquad \mathcal T\longrightarrow\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ}. The first morphism and Proposition 4.45.6 show that w∈V(T)w\in V(\mathcal T). Let FF be its special component in T\mathcal T. The actual residue-field identifications of Proposition 4.45.2, applied over Ω\Omega, give k‾(F)=H(w)~=k‾(E).\overline k(F)=\widetilde{\mathcal H(w)} =\overline k(E). If ww were absent from V(XΩ∘)V(\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ}), the necessity of the geometric forest condition for the second morphism would make FF a smooth Pk‾1\mathbf P^1_{\overline k}. Its function field would be rational, contrary to the displayed equality. Hence ww is a vertex of the coefficient extension of X\mathcal X. The geometric vertex identification in Proposition 4.45.2 projects it to the original vertex v=p(w)v=p(w) and gives the two asserted arithmetic conditions. Forgetting a marking retains a semistable algebraic model, so the same obstruction applies to every prescribed marking. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002445, 4.57.1.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record