Proposition 4.57.1. (A nonrational component cannot disappear). Let be a smooth projective geometrically connected curve. Suppose is a semistable algebraic model of , and let be the component vertex of a special component whose function field is not rational. Then every semistable algebraic model of satisfies Consequently, if has such an original-field model, the point must satisfy Failure of either condition at rules out every original-field semistable algebraic model, including every such marked model.
Proof
Proof. Assume exists. Its coefficient extension is a semistable algebraic model of the same curve as , by Lemma 4.28.1 and preservation of the nodal relative-curve condition under base change, [StacksAlg] (Tag 0C5B). Apply Theorem 4.47.5 over the complete field , with empty marking. It supplies an actual semistable model and generic-identity morphisms The first morphism and Proposition 4.45.6 show that . Let be its special component in . The actual residue-field identifications of Proposition 4.45.2, applied over , give If were absent from , the necessity of the geometric forest condition for the second morphism would make a smooth . Its function field would be rational, contrary to the displayed equality. Hence is a vertex of the coefficient extension of . The geometric vertex identification in Proposition 4.45.2 projects it to the original vertex and gives the two asserted arithmetic conditions. Forgetting a marking retains a semistable algebraic model, so the same obstruction applies to every prescribed marking. ◻