Theorem 4.57.2. (A potential smooth model with an original-field obstruction). Assume , and choose with . Let be the projective curve It is smooth and geometrically connected. If then has no semistable algebraic model over the original valuation ring .
Nevertheless, if satisfies and , the curve has the smooth projective model The unique component vertex of is fixed by every isometric -automorphism of . In particular, for , , with the specified absolute value , the choice gives the stated nonexistence over .
Proof
Proof. We first verify the actual model and its special curve. The integers and are units in , and hence in . The two affine charts and cover : the equation rules out a projective point with . Their coordinate rings are Each is free over the polynomial algebra in the first variable, since its equation is monic, up to a unit, in the second. They are therefore flat over . They have finite algebra presentations; the projective closed embedding makes the resulting morphism separated and quasi-compact, so it is finitely presented.
On the first chart, makes and a cover; the corresponding partial derivatives and are units. On the second chart, a point with belongs to the first chart, whereas a point with has invertible. These are actual standard smooth presentations by [StacksAlg] (Tag 01V9(6)). Thus is smooth of relative dimension one.
Over any extension field of , the polynomial is not a square in the rational function field in : its order at infinity is , whereas the order of a square is even. Therefore is irreducible. Its quotient ring injects into the corresponding quadratic field over that rational function field, by its monic degree-two basis, so the affine chart is integral. The only point of its projective complement is . Every fibre is smooth of relative dimension one; in particular this point is on a one-dimensional component and cannot be an additional component by itself. The affine chart is consequently dense, and the fibre is connected. It is geometrically reduced and regular by [StacksAlg] (Tag 056T). This verifies the exact semistable-model conditions, including geometric connectedness, over .
The same calculation with over any extension of proves that is smooth and geometrically connected: the affine chart has equation , with partial derivatives and , which cannot both vanish on it; the unique point at infinity has a unit partial derivative in the chart . Its affine polynomial is irreducible by the same odd-order calculation. The root exists in the chosen algebraically closed . The extension has its actual degree and is complete with the extending absolute value by Lemma 1.12.1. The displayed coordinate change identifies the generic fibre of with , and for this unchanged extending value.
Write for the special curve after extension to . Its function field is not rational. Here is a direct verification. On the affine chart the differential extends across a zero of as , since and there. Near infinity put and , so . The affine coordinates are and ; differentiating the equation gives This is regular at infinity. The differential is nonzero: on the affine function field the derivation , respects the equation and evaluates to .
If were , [StacksAlg] (Tag 0BY1), applied to the smooth projective curve and , would identify these curves. But a regular differential on has the form on its affine line, with ; at it is , which is regular at only when . The nonzero is a contradiction.
Complete along any fixed . Theorem 4.13.2 identifies its actual analytic generic fibre with . Proposition 4.12.2 supplies the unique component vertex over the generic point of . Put . The reduction identification in Proposition 4.24.2 shows that the affine functions and have norm one at , since both have nonzero residues at the generic point of . Hence the original rational functions and satisfy They are nonzero elements of , so either failure in the hypothesis makes its value group strictly larger than . Proposition 4.57.1 now rules out every original-field semistable model.
Finally, let be an isometric -automorphism of . Then with , and . The canonical semilinear action on transforms the displayed integral coordinates by These substitutions and their inverses preserve the equation over , so give an actual semilinear automorphism of the smooth model. Its unique special component, and thus its component vertex , is preserved. For and , the two displayed values are and , neither of which lies in . Throughout, the absolute value was extended and never rescaled. ◻