Proposition. (A tame nondiscrete curve with no original-field F5 model). Use the admitted field and quadratic extension Then is dense, is tame Galois of degree two, and both residue fields are . The curve is smooth, projective and geometrically connected of genus three. It admits a smooth projective stable model over , but admits no F5 model over . The geometric dual graph of the supplied stable model has a single vertex and no edges, and is fixed by the Galois action. Thus invariant stable vertices do not imply even existence of some original-field F5 model.
Proof
Proof. The field, value group, completeness and extension data are exactly those of C.1.85 and C.1.86, with and in place of . We reuse these facts. In particular with , the residue field does not change, and . No assertion that is finite or etale is being used; the admitted coefficient result in fact proves that is not finite over .
For the homogeneous polynomial the partial derivatives are They cannot vanish simultaneously at a projective point over any field extension of . On each affine chart the dehomogenized partials likewise have no common zero on the curve, by the displayed formula and the degree-four Euler identity. Inverting a nonzero partial gives a standard smooth presentation as in Stacks Tag 00T6; Stacks Tag 00T7 gives smoothness and relative dimension one. Thus is a geometrically smooth plane quartic. These smooth hypersurfaces are pure one-dimensional and have no embedded points, so Stacks Tag 0BYD applies over and over every field extension. It gives and genus . In particular is geometrically connected: a disconnection over an algebraic closure would give a nontrivial idempotent in that field of global functions. Projectivity is part of its displayed construction.
Let be the plane quartic and put The same computation makes a smooth projective geometrically connected curve of genus three. Hence is a projective smooth family with these geometric fibres. It is stable by Stacks Tag 0E6T and Stacks Tag 0E75: a smooth connected genus-three curve has no rational tails or bridges. There is an -isomorphism Indeed , and multiplication of the third coordinate by gives its inverse. This supplies the required stable model with generic-fibre identification.
Under , the canonical semilinear action of is the coefficient action of together with For example, the pullback of is . This action extends to , since is defined over and preserves its equation. Uniqueness in 4.14.5 identifies it with the specified action on the stable model. On the special fibre it is , which sends to the distinct point . It is therefore not the identity on the special fibre.
If an F5 model of over existed, Lemma G.0.1 would force this action to be the identity, a contradiction. Finally, the geometric special fibre of is a smooth connected curve, hence has one irreducible component and no nodes. Its geometric dual graph therefore has one vertex and no edges; the action fixes that graph. This graph statement does not assert that its geometric component vertex descends to an original-field F5 vertex. ◻