Theorem 4.6.2. A smooth proper connected curve over the specified algebraically closed complete field has semistable vertex sets. Semistable formal models correspond to such vertex sets. A model dominates another exactly when its vertex set contains the other one. The associated finite metric graph is a skeleton of the analytic curve, and the local retractions glue to a deformation retraction onto it.
Argument in the manuscript
Proof. Let , , and choose with . Write for the given smooth proper connected curve and . The curve is projective [StacksAlg] (Tag 0A26). Fix any admissible semistable formal model with its identification . We will apply the correspondence for algebraic completions by proving that this very model is such a completion over . Its special fibre is a reduced curve with at worst nodes. No pointed chart on is a hypothesis of the argument.
The formal model has a finite cover by formal affines: apply the finite chart argument in Theorem 3.19.25 to the whole compact strictly analytic curve. Their generic fibres form an analytic covering with the neighbourhood property, and specialization is surjective. Hence is of finite type over . For every irreducible component its generic point has a unique analytic lift by Proposition 4.12.2; this is a type II point by Proposition 4.24.2. The formal-model clause of Theorem 4.5.1 identifies the normalization of that component with its smooth projective residual curve. Thus the disjoint union of the normalizations is proper over , and is finite surjective by [StacksAlg] (Tag 0BXR) (or Lemma 4.24.1). In particular is proper. Indeed, after any base change the preimage of a closed subset of under this surjection has the same image in the base as the closed subset, so is universally closed. The finite morphism maps the closed diagonal of onto the image of the diagonal of . The latter image is closed. The diagonal is a closed immersion locally around its image, on for affine opens ; it is therefore a closed immersion. This proves separatedness as well.
Put and let be the -th scheme truncation of , for . These form a cartesian tower, with . The ideal is nil since has rank one. Its extension to any ring is nil, so passage to the closed fibre gives a homeomorphism also after any base change on , for the base, the source and its fibre square. Universal closedness for follows from that for after these identifications. The diagonal image of is likewise closed. The same affine diagonal argument over gives separatedness.
On a formal affine admissibility gives a surjection and -torsion-freeness. Every nonzero element of divides some , so is -torsion-free, hence flat [StacksAlg] (Tag 0539). Thus is flat over . It is a quotient of , because a restricted series reduces to a polynomial. To check finite presentation, apply [StacksAlg] (Tag 05IK) on to the cyclic -module . The polynomial morphism is finitely presented, the module sheaf is of finite type, and the base has only one point, so its weakly associated points are locally finite. Every stalk of this sheaf is -flat: localization is a filtered colimit of copies of the flat module . The theorem gives finite presentation on the entire affine space. Consequently the kernel of is finitely generated, and is a finitely presented -algebra. The finite affine cover and separatedness now give properness, flatness and finite presentation of every .
Proposition B.1.2 and Theorem B.1.3 apply to precisely this tower. They give a projective flat finitely presented -scheme , at worst nodal of relative dimension one, together with compatible isomorphisms at all levels. On formal affines the rings and their restriction sheaves are the -adic inverse limits of those truncations. We obtain an isomorphism and, by Theorem 4.13.2, the specified analytic isomorphism .
This last identification comes from an isomorphism . Here is the precise use of Theorem 2.34.8. For projective -schemes , embed in projective space. An analytic map pulls back the hyperplane line bundle and its generating sections. The theorem algebraizes the line bundle and the sections; the evaluation map is surjective because its coherent cokernel has zero analytification. They define a map to projective space [StacksAlg] (Tag 01NE). Its analytification is the original projective-space map, as one sees on each coordinate chart by taking ratios of the sections. Each homogeneous equation of pulls back to an algebraic section of a tensor power whose analytification vanishes, hence to zero. The map therefore factors through scheme-theoretically. Two such algebraic maps with the same analytification have isomorphic bundles with the same ordered sections by full faithfulness, so are equal. Applying this argument to the isomorphism and its inverse gives the assertion, with the prescribed identification.
In particular is smooth. Theorem 4.18.2 gives split pointed charts at the finitely many special nodes: its finite extension is , and smoothness of makes every smoothing parameter nonzero by Theorem 4.15.3. Smooth closed special points have residue field , which is algebraically closed. Thus , with its generic identification, is a split nodal algebraic model of . The formal isomorphism over identifies the specialization maps and the component vertices.
Theorem 4.38.2, with no markings, supplies an initial model. Theorem 4.42.5 now applies to every model under consideration: it realizes every semistable vertex set, identifies the arrows inducing the identity on with reverse inclusions, and identifies the graph with its original logarithmic edge lengths. The local disc and annulus retractions glue by Theorem 4.23.3; transport along the formal isomorphism gives the asserted deformation retraction. ◻