NAG-002470 · Accepted whole
Actual initial models along a projective skeleton
5 Tropicalization, multiplicities and balancing
Open in the English reader · PDF page 1082
Statement · exact TeX
\begin{theorem}[Actual initial models along a projective skeleton]
\label{v038:faithful:wholefibreinitial}
In the stated model setting, the tuple $F$ of
Lemma~\ref{v038:faithful:chartpreparation} can be chosen so
that the resulting closed immersion
$\varphi:U\hookrightarrow\mathbf G_{m,K}^N$ has the
following additional property. Let $s\in S$, put
$\omega=\trop_\varphi(s)$, and choose a refined chart
containing its specialization, with label $(I,\eta)$.
For every complete isometric $L/K$ realizing the coordinates
of $\omega$ in its value group, the actual initial scheme
of $U_L$ at $\omega$ is isomorphic to a principal open of
\[
E_{\lambda,I,\eta,\widetilde L}
\times\mathbf G_{m,\widetilde L}^{|I|-1}
\]
which meets every geometric irreducible component.
In particular this initial scheme is smooth and geometrically
reduced. The quotient norm of the normalized tropical-fibre
presentation is its spectral norm, and its integral quotient
model is the spectral unit ball.
\end{theorem}Full selected proof · exact TeX
\begin{proof}
Use precisely the finite lists constructed in
Lemma~\ref{v038:faithful:chartpreparation}. Fix $s$ and its
chart, and write $h=h_{\lambda,I,\eta}$. The normalization
field $L$ exists by Theorem~\ref{cand:realinitialdegeneration};
the argument below works for every such $L$.
Choose the standard-coordinate normalizers with product
$a_\lambda$ as in Proposition~\ref{v038:faithful:weightedchart}.
Let $B_0$ be that proposition's selected weighted model.
We first locate the entire tropical fibre. Every point of
the actual fibre
\[
Y_\omega=\trop_\varphi^{-1}(\omega)
\subset U^{\an}
\]
has, on every algebra generator of the selected chart, the
same absolute value as $s$, which is at most one. Algebraically
$U$ is contained in this chart by construction. Hence the
actual bounded-coordinate description of
Lemma~\ref{cand:affineflatformalcompletion} puts the entire
fibre inside the completed chart. The coordinates $X_i$
impose its weights $w_i$, and the coordinate $h$ imposes
$|h|=|h(s)|=1$. The same argument over $L$ places the entire
base-changed fibre in $\mathcal M_L(B_0[1/\pi])$.
This also shows explicitly how points outside the selected
formal chart are excluded: their chart-generator norms
cannot satisfy all these equalities.
For each $p\in P$, choose $b_p\in L^\times$ with
$|b_p|=|p(s)|$. The function $p$ is regular on this chart
because $\mathcal V_\lambda\subset\mathcal W$.
Proposition~\ref{v038:faithful:weightedchart} gives this same
norm at every Shilov point of $B_0[1/\pi]$.
Lemma~\ref{v038:faithful:peaklocalization} therefore gives
\[
B'_0=B_0\langle V_p:p\in P\rangle/
((p/b_p)V_p-1:p\in P).
\]
Its reduction is a principal open of the stated smooth
product and meets every geometric component.
Its generic fibre is exactly $Y_{\omega,L}$. In one direction
this follows from the preceding containment and the
equalities $|p|=|p(s)|$. In the other direction those
equalities make all members of $P$ invertible and thus
put a point in $U_L^{\an}$. Every remaining coordinate of
$F$ is $p_f/q_f$ with $p_f,q_f\in P$, so it has the
required absolute value as well. The presentations of
rational domains identify the analytic structures, not only
the sets of points; equivalently, use
Proposition~\ref{fnd:rationalcompletebasechange} and the
universal property of these displayed equations.
It remains to identify the integral model with the actual
initial quotient. Choose normalizers $b_f$ for all
coordinates of $F$. Changing them by norm-one constants
only changes torus coordinates. Put
\[
T_0=L^\circ\langle Z_f^{\pm1}:f\in F\rangle,
\qquad T=T_0[1/\pi],
\qquad Z_f\longmapsto f/b_f.
\]
All these images and their inverses belong to $B'_0$.
For $f=p_f/q_f$ this follows by using the normalized
$p_f,q_f$ and a norm-one scalar. The map $T_0\to B'_0$
is surjective, as can be checked on its actual restricted
presentation. Every chart algebra generator $u$ is the
image of $b_u Z_u$, with $b_u\in L^\circ$ because
$|u(s)|\leq1$. Every $U_i^{\pm1}$ is the image of
$Z_{X_i}^{\pm1}$ multiplied by a norm-one scalar.
The generator $h^{-1}$ is the image of a norm-one scalar
times $Z_h^{-1}$. Finally the generators $(p/b_p)^{-1}$
are the images of $Z_p^{-1}$. These are all the generators
in the displayed construction of $B'_0$.
Their lifts are integral Laurent polynomials of Gauss norm
at most one. Substitution lifts every integral restricted
series in them to $T_0$, by Proposition~\ref{fnd:substitution}.
Thus the map is surjective, rather than merely having
dense image.
Let $\mathfrak a$ be the algebraic ideal of the closed
immersion $U_L\hookrightarrow\mathbf G_{m,L}^N$, in these
normalized coordinates. Proposition~\ref{cand:torusfibrealgebra}
identifies the generic map with
\[
T/\mathfrak aT\ \simeq\ B'_0[1/\pi].
\]
Since $B'_0$ is $L^\circ$-flat and is embedded in its
generic algebra, the kernel of $T_0\to B'_0$ is precisely
$\mathfrak aT\cap T_0$. Consequently
\[
T_0/(\mathfrak aT\cap T_0)\ \simeq\ B'_0.
\]
Proposition~\ref{cand:initialcompletionreduction} identifies
the reduction of this quotient with the actual initial
scheme of the algebraic immersion. Its special fibre was
computed above. Lemma~\ref{cand:reducedspecialcanonical}
now identifies the quotient norm with the spectral norm
and the quotient model with the spectral unit ball.
The arbitrary-real-weight interpretation and independence
of normalization are those of
Theorem~\ref{cand:realinitialdegeneration}; the calculation
has retained every component throughout.
\end{proof}Standing context 1 · exact TeX
Let $K$ be complete for its specified nontrivial real-valued
absolute value. Write $O=K^\circ$, $k=\widetilde K$, and
$v=-\log|\cdot|$, and fix $\pi\in O$ with $0<|\pi|<1$.
We use the algebraic model setting of
Theorem~\ref{v035:faithfulglobal}: $\mathcal X$ is a given
projective, flat, finitely presented $O$-scheme, its generic
fibre $X$ is smooth and integral, and a finite collection of
affine opens covering $\mathcal X_s$ has \etale maps to
\[
\operatorname{Spec}R_\lambda,\qquad
R_\lambda=
O[X_0,\ldots,X_{r_\lambda},T_1,\ldots,T_{q_\lambda}]/
(X_0\cdots X_{r_\lambda}-a_\lambda),
\quad 0<|a_\lambda|<1.
\]
Let $S\subset X^{\an}$ be the compact skeleton of the completed
model. All rational functions below belong to the original
field $K(X)$.
For such a chart $\mathcal V=\operatorname{Spec}C$ and a
nonempty $I\subset\{0,\ldots,r\}$, write $S_I$ for its
residual stratum over
\[
D_I=\{X_i=0\ (i\in I),\ X_j\ne0\ (j\notin I)\}
\]
and $Q_I$ for the finite set of generic points of $S_I$.
These are the strata and labels of
Proposition~\ref{cand:actualskeletalfibrestrata}. If
$s=x_{\eta,w}$, then $I=\{i:w_i>0\}$ and
$\eta\in Q_I$. An irreducible residual component in this
section is a component of this locally closed stratum.
Typeset reader excerpt

Typed proof inputs
- NAG-000232 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-001693 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-002035 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-002037 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-002081 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-002084 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-002085 · selected whole (selected native whole)
- NAG-002467 · selected whole (earlier same family whole)
- NAG-002468 · selected whole (earlier same family whole)
- NAG-002469 · selected whole (selected native whole)
Reader cross-references
- cand:actualskeletalfibrestrata
- cand:affineflatformalcompletion
- cand:initialcompletionreduction
- cand:realinitialdegeneration
- cand:reducedspecialcanonical
- cand:torusfibrealgebra
- fnd:rationalcompletebasechange
- fnd:substitution
- v035:faithfulglobal
- v038:faithful:chartpreparation
- v038:faithful:peaklocalization
- v038:faithful:weightedchart
Proof map
Verified map inputs · NAG-002470
AND · joint registered proof inputs
- NAG-000232 · Substitution · accepted whole Exact source window 373–398
- For each normalizer the prescribed value makes the required scalar factors integral. The normalized torus images lift every generator of the actual integral completion, including bounded chart generators, inverse Laurent generators and separators. Contractive substitution lifts the entire restricted series.
- NAG-001693 · Rational domains under complete-extension base change · accepted whole Exact source window 348–371
- Each denominator is regular on the actual chosen chart. Its common value at all Shilov points gives the canonical simultaneous Laurent localization retaining all geometric components. Match the actual ordinary fibre domains by their unit equations and the full completed base-change property.
- NAG-002035 · A reduced special fibre determines the unit ball · accepted whole Exact source window 400–422
- Identify the normalized fibre algebra by the exact torus quotient. Torsion-freeness identifies its integral kernel with the full saturation, so the initial scheme is the reduction of the actual integral model. The geometrically reduced case gives the quotient norm and the spectral unit ball, with arbitrary real weights retained.
- NAG-002037 · Affine algebraic models · accepted whole Exact source window 320–346
- Use the actual normalization realizing all F weights, the chosen chart, and the supplied separator. Equal values of every chart generator force the full tropical fibre into that completed domain, with the specified weighted coordinates and |h|=1. The same argument holds after the given isometric extension.
- NAG-002081 · The tropical fibre algebra · accepted whole Exact source window 400–422
- Identify the normalized fibre algebra by the exact torus quotient. Torsion-freeness identifies its integral kernel with the full saturation, so the initial scheme is the reduction of the actual integral model. The geometrically reduced case gives the quotient norm and the spectral unit ball, with arbitrary real weights retained.
- NAG-002084 · Completion retains the initial relations · accepted whole Exact source window 400–422
- Identify the normalized fibre algebra by the exact torus quotient. Torsion-freeness identifies its integral kernel with the full saturation, so the initial scheme is the reduction of the actual integral model. The geometrically reduced case gives the quotient norm and the spectral unit ball, with arbitrary real weights retained.
- NAG-002085 · Initial degenerations at arbitrary real weights · accepted whole Exact source windows 400–422, 320–346
- Identify the normalized fibre algebra by the exact torus quotient. Torsion-freeness identifies its integral kernel with the full saturation, so the initial scheme is the reduction of the actual integral model. The geometrically reduced case gives the quotient norm and the spectral unit ball, with arbitrary real weights retained.
- Use the actual normalization realizing all F weights, the chosen chart, and the supplied separator. Equal values of every chart generator force the full tropical fibre into that completed domain, with the specified weighted coordinates and |h|=1. The same argument holds after the given isometric extension.
- NAG-002467 · Algebraic coordinates on a common affine open · accepted whole Exact source window 320–346
- Use the actual normalization realizing all F weights, the chosen chart, and the supplied separator. Equal values of every chart generator force the full tropical fibre into that completed domain, with the specified weighted coordinates and |h|=1. The same argument holds after the given isometric extension.
- NAG-002468 · A weighted chart with one residual component · accepted whole Exact source windows 320–346, 348–371
- Use the actual normalization realizing all F weights, the chosen chart, and the supplied separator. Equal values of every chart generator force the full tropical fibre into that completed domain, with the specified weighted coordinates and |h|=1. The same argument holds after the given isometric extension.
- Each denominator is regular on the actual chosen chart. Its common value at all Shilov points gives the canonical simultaneous Laurent localization retaining all geometric components. Match the actual ordinary fibre domains by their unit equations and the full completed base-change property.
- NAG-002469 · Localization at a common Shilov value · accepted whole Exact source window 348–371
- Each denominator is regular on the actual chosen chart. Its common value at all Shilov points gives the canonical simultaneous Laurent localization retaining all geometric components. Match the actual ordinary fibre domains by their unit equations and the full completed base-change property.
NAG-002470 · Actual initial models along a projective skeleton · Chapter argument